Discussion Topic

The conflicts in Monster by Walter Dean Myers

Summary:

The conflicts in Monster by Walter Dean Myers include Steve Harmon's internal struggle with his identity and guilt, and the external conflict of his trial for a crime he may not have committed. The story explores themes of justice, race, and the impact of the legal system on a young black teenager.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the main conflict in Monster?

The primary external conflict concerns Steve versus society as he struggles to overcome the racially prejudiced criminal justice system, which views him as a monster for being on trial. As a young Black teenager, Steve struggles with the unjust stigma attached to him and attempts to distance himself from characters...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
like Richard "Bobo" Evans and James King. Steve recognizes that he is viewed as a "typical" Black criminal and his lawyer acknowledges that the jury will assume he is guilty before the trial begins. Sandra Petrocelli also represents the prejudiced justice system, which dehumanizes young black men like Steve by labeling them monsters.

The primary internal conflict Steve experiences revolves around his identity. Throughout the story, Steve wrestles with his conscience and struggles to recognize who he is as a person. Steve questions his morals and tries to justify his actions. In prison, Steve expresses his conflicting feelings in his diary and continually examines himself in the mirror. Steve replays the day of the crime, contemplates his true intentions, and attempts to rationalize his entire experience. He regrets even being associated with criminals like James King and believes that he is genuinely a good person. However, Steve struggles to acknowledge his true character and questionable morals. Although he states that he is innocent, there is evidence to suggest otherwise. Even after the trial, Steve continues to search for his true identity by filming himself from different angles and questioning his morals.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the main conflict in Monster?

While there are many external conflicts in the novel, the primary conflict in Monster is within Steve. Steve is placed in opposition to numerous elements of the criminal justice system and to society overall. However, what matters the most in terms of his position as protagonist is his ability to hold onto his identity. Walter Dean Myers reveals Steve’s numerous struggles as the boy reflects on his activities before he was arrested as an accomplice. The author emphasizes the importance of creativity for Steve, who finds a crucial outlet in his writing. He must find a way to cope with the massive pressures he faces as others oppress him with their label of "monster." Furthermore, this creative outlet must have future-oriented dimensions, as Steve knows that long-term incarceration might be his future.

While Steve realizes that his dream of making films must be put on hold as he focuses on acquittal, he does not abandon that dream. The internal conflict is shown through the doubts that his story often raises about whether he can sustain this fundamental optimism or whether he will succumb to despair in the bleak surroundings. The support that his film teacher offers in court helps Steve cling to his hopes, but only he can finally achieve a positive sense of self.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the main conflict in Monster?

I would argue that there are two equally strong conflicts in Dean's book Monster.

First, Steve is on trial for being an accomplice to a robbery that turned into a murder. Most of the book centers around his trial and various testimonies. One interesting facet of this conflict is that it is never fully resolved for the reader. Although Steve is found not guilty, the reader is left wondering whether he really did act in conjunction with King, sweeping the store they robbed to make sure no one was inside. Following the verdict, Steve's own attorney stiffens when he tries to hug her, and he is left wondering what she truly sees in him. This external conflict of Steve vs. society is perhaps due to Steve's own actions—and maybe not.

Second, Steve battles internal conflict from the very beginning. In the jail, he doesn't recognize himself in the mirror, metaphorically representing that he doesn't fully recognize the person he's become. Is this because he was actively involved in the murder or because of the way society views him? Five months after the trial concludes, Steve is still struggling with whether his lawyer views him as a "monster," and he is still trying to find some inner peace. Again, his inner conflict is not resolved with the plot's conclusion. There are no easy resolutions to be found with the conflicts in Monster.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the main conflict in Monster?

The main conflict in Monster concerns Steve Harmon's loss of identity. Throughout the novel, Steve is referred to as a "monster" by the prosecuting attorney. Like many other teenage minorities caught up in the justice system, Steve fits the stereotype and is automatically viewed as a criminal before the trial begins. Steve is placed in a violent detention center where he fears for his life every day. As the novel progresses, Steve's confidence diminishes, and he begins to wonder if he really is a "monster." Steve also questions his morals and is unsure about who he truly is. At the end of his trial, Steve is found not guilty and attempts to hug his attorney, Kathy O'Brien. However, instead of hugging Steve, O'Brien turns away from him. This gesture deeply upsets Steve, and he wonders if she viewed him as a "monster." Steve spends the rest of his days as a free man filming himself, trying to find his true identity. 

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the main conflict in Monster?

The main conflict of Walter Dean Myers' book, Monster, is about a teen accused of murder trying to clear his name in both the legal and social settings.  Steve is 16 years old and claims to be at the wrong place at the wrong time, and claims to be the victim to inaccurate eyewitness accounts.  Steve must also deal with the most frightening nature of the justice system.  Steve's conflicts are primarily settled in the domain of an individual against a social order. Steve's battle to prove his innocence is the major conflict within the novel.

In addition to this, we never really know if Steve is innocent or guilty.  The journal/ script aspect of the novel makes it upon us to think about such an issue.  Perhaps, this is another conflict of the novel, only this one is left for us to analyze.  This question has been asked before and you can check out that answer and compare it to this one.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the external conflicts in Monster by Walter Dean Myers?

There are multiple external conflicts found in Walter Dean Myers' novel Monster. External conflicts are defined through the following: man versus man, man versus supernatural, and man versus nature. In the novel, the external conflict of man versus man is prevalent.

Steve faces many different external conflicts. For one, he must face society. Given that he has been arrested, those in society may believe him to be guilty.

Second, Steve must face the man he is testifying against: King. Both Steve and King are on trial for murder. King repeatedly tries to intimidate Steve. When seated next to each other, King gives Steve harsh looks.

Third, Steve conflicts with his father. At the end of the novel, Steve's father cannot look at him in the same way he had prior to Steve's arrest and trial.

Fourth, Steve must face the jury. Steve's future is in the hands of the jury. It is up to them to decide if he is guilty or not.

Fifth, Steve must survive jail. In the opening of the novel, Steve explains how frightening jail at night is. He states that night is the only time a person can cry given the sounds of abuse going on.

Lastly, Steve conflicts with his lawyer. O'Brien believes that winning Steve's case simply means taking the death penalty off of the table. Steve's conflict with his attorney exists because she seems to think Steve is actually guilty.

Last Updated on