Student Question
In Monster, why does Steve's mother's departure and her comment "No matter what anybody says" upset him?
Quick answer:
In Monster, it bothers Steve so much when his mother leaves because, whereas she’s convinced of Steve’s innocence, he wonders whether he’s fooling himself. And her comment that "no matter what anybody says," she knows he’s innocent is particularly disturbing to Steve because he isn’t as sure as she is that he hasn’t done anything wrong.
This particular episode in the story is one of many that adds to the ambiguity over the question of Steve’s guilt. Some people are convinced that Steve is absolutely guilty. Others are convinced that he’s completely innocent. And Steve’s mom is clearly one of them. As she gets up to leave her son after paying him an emotional visit in jail, she says, “No matter what anybody says, I know you’re innocent, and I love you very much.”
One might think that Steve would be very pleased to have such a ringing endorsement from his mother. At the very least, it might make him feel a little better about his predicament to know that, despite everything, his mother still loves him and believes in his innocence. But as Steve lies down on the cot in his cell, he’s not feeling happy at all— quite the opposite. Of course, he's upset by seeing his mom cry, but there's something deeper, more complex going on here. As Steve admits, he doesn’t share his mother’s firm belief in his innocence. While she's certain that he didn’t do anything wrong, he can't say the same thing about himself. In fact, he wonders whether he isn’t fooling himself.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.