Themes: Consequences
In "The Monkey's Paw," the theme of consequences is central to the narrative. The story serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of greed and the unforeseen repercussions of interfering with fate. The White family comes into possession of a cursed monkey's paw that grants three wishes, but each wish carries unintended and tragic consequences. This theme is reinforced through the experiences of the characters and the moral lesson that unfolds.
The story begins with the Whites wishing for financial security by asking for their house to be paid off. While their wish is granted, it comes at the cost of their son Herbert's life. This tragic outcome highlights the story's moral about the dangers of unchecked desires. The Whites' failure to recognize the potential harm of their wishes underscores the theme of consequences. Their initial wish results in a devastating loss, illustrating that desires fulfilled through unnatural means can lead to sorrow.
The Whites' second wish, to bring their son back to life, further emphasizes the theme. Despite the warning from Sergeant-Major Morris about the paw's dark magic, the Whites persist in their desires. This wish results in a terrifying situation, as they hear a knock on the door, presumably from their resurrected son. The consequences of their actions become clear, as their wishes only bring more misery and fear. This reinforces the idea that interfering with fate leads to deep sadness and regret.
The monkey's paw itself is an instrument of dark magic, designed to bring misery to those who use it for personal gain. The previous owners, including Sergeant-Major Morris, experienced severe consequences from their wishes. The Whites' inability to heed these warnings and their continued use of the paw demonstrate the inevitable suffering that comes from tampering with fate. The story's moral is encapsulated in the fakir's intention to show that fate rules people's lives and that interference only causes sorrow. As the tale unfolds, the Whites learn this lesson the hard way, illustrating the profound consequences of their actions.
Expert Q&A
What lesson does Fakir intend to teach in "The Monkey's Paw"?
The fakir in "The Monkey's Paw" intended to teach that fate governs people's lives and attempting to alter it leads to sorrow. Through the cursed monkey's paw, which grants three wishes with dire consequences, the story illustrates the dangers of interfering with fate. The Whites' tragic experience, especially Mr. White's wish for money resulting in his son's death, reinforces the lesson that desires can have unintended and harmful outcomes, emphasizing the adage "Be careful what you wish for."
Why does the sergeant major in "The Monkey's Paw" suggest, "Better let it burn"?
Sergeant Major Morris suggests "Better let it burn" because he knows the monkey's paw brings misfortune. Having experienced its consequences, he warns the Whites that the paw's wishes come with tragic outcomes, as a fakir enchanted it to demonstrate that people should not interfere with fate. Morris throws the paw into the fire to destroy it, hoping to prevent the Whites from experiencing the same calamities he witnessed.
How do Mrs. White's attitude and circumstances contribute to the problem at the end of the story?
Mrs. White's deep attachment to her son and her grief over his death drive the story's climax. Her strong bond with her son makes her desperate enough to use the monkey's paw to wish for his return, despite her husband's reluctance and her lack of awareness about his mangled state. This decision, rooted in emotional turmoil and isolation, contributes to the suspenseful and tragic conclusion of the story.
Why isn't The Monkey's Paw a desirable gift?
The monkey's paw is not a desirable gift because it is associated with unintended consequences and uncertainty. It is not given as a gift but rather passed from person to person, often with negative outcomes. The story suggests that while wishes made on the paw appear to come true, they may be coincidental or lead to unforeseen tragedies. This ambiguity and the potential for harm make it an undesirable item to possess.
Wishes and Consequences in "The Monkey's Paw"
In "The Monkey's Paw," the Whites make three wishes, each with dire consequences. The first wish for 200 pounds results in their son Herbert's death in a work accident, with the compensation matching the wished amount. The second wish, driven by grief, is for Herbert to return to life, leading to a terrifying knocking at their door, implying his reanimated corpse. The third wish, implied but not explicitly stated, likely reverses the second, as the knocking ceases and the door reveals nothing. The story highlights the peril of interfering with fate.
Could Mr. and Mrs. White's second wish in "The Monkey's Paw" have had a better outcome if phrased differently?
In "The Monkey's Paw," altering the phrasing of the second wish likely wouldn't have improved the outcome due to the paw's malevolent nature. The dark magic inherent in the paw was designed to bring misery to those who used it, as emphasized by previous owners' tragic experiences. Even if Herbert had been wished back whole, the paw's curse would have ensured another misfortune, illustrating the theme that tampering with fate leads to sorrow.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
