The Monkey's Paw Themes

The main themes in the "The Monkey's Paw" are fate, Orientalism, the supernatural, and death.

  • Fate: As Sergeant-Major Morris says, "Fate ruled people's lives," and those who interfere with fate suffer the consequences.
  • Orientalism and the supernatural: As a magical artifact from India, the monkey's paw takes on exotic, mystical qualities that draw on the old cliché of the East as an inherently supernatural place.
  • Death: First mentioned during Sergeant-Major Morris' tale of India, death goes on to provide the most horrifying images in the story as Mr. White's son rises from the dead, corpse bloodied and mangled.

Themes and Meanings

Download PDF Print Page Citation Share Link

Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 232

Sergeant-Major Morris’s remark that the monkey’s paw is intended to show people that fate rules their lives and that it is unwise to interfere with it is true. Judging by the sergeant-major’s testimony, both he and the first owner of the paw have chosen badly. When Mrs. White jokingly suggests, as she sets the table, that her husband might wish for three extra pairs of hands for her, Morris forcefully points out to Mr. White that if he must wish, he should wish for something sensible. Despite the fact that he does so, fate exacts a terrible retribution.

Illustration of PDF document

Download The Monkey's Paw Study Guide

Subscribe Now

The magnitude of this retribution is difficult to account for in conventional terms. After all, Mr. White wishes for a relatively insignificant sum of money and with little enthusiasm; he is far from being a greedy man. Traditional ghost stories tend to establish a comfortable balance between mortal transgression and supernatural retribution. “The Monkey’s Paw,” on the other hand, suggests that fate, whatever meaning one chooses to read into the word, operates beyond such familiar concepts as fairness and justice. The author refrains from comment, but his opening and closing scenes—a night “cold and wet” and a road “quiet and deserted”—suggest that humans may be at the mercy of an indifferent, if not actually malevolent, universe. It is these suggestions that render “The Monkey’s Paw” so chilling.

Themes

Download PDF Print Page Citation Share Link

Last Updated on August 19, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 858

Fate and Chance
In "The Monkey's Paw," Sergeant-Major Morris, an old family friend of the Whites, returns from India with tales of his exotic life and with a strange souvenir—a monkey's paw. This paw has had a spell put on it by a fakir (a holy man), he tells the Whites. Morris goes on to say that the fakir wanted to show that "fate ruled people's lives, and that those who interfered with it did so to their sorrow. He put a spell on it so that three separate men could each have three wishes from it."

As the story unfolds, author Jacobs provides many hints that, indeed, the monkey's paw does possess strange powers, and that tempting fate by making the three wishes is a grave mistake. First, the son, Herbert, asks Morris if he has made his three wishes, since he is in possession of the monkey's paw. '"I have,' he said, quietly, and his blotchy face whitened.

'"And did you really have the three wishes granted?' asked Mrs. White.

"I did,' said the sergeant-major, and his glass tapped against his strong teeth.''

The sergeant major will say nothing else of his own misfortunes, but he does tell the Whites that although he does not know what the first owner of the paw asked for in his first two wishes, ' 'the third was for death. That's how I got the paw."

Later that evening, Morris throws the paw on the fire, but Mr. White rescues it. Despite his friend's grave warnings, Mr. White makes a rather modest wish for 200 pounds, so that he may pay off the mortgage on his family's little house. And so, in spite of the original warning of the fakir, the story of the first owner of the monkey's paw, who wished for death at the end, and the warnings of their friend Morris, the Whites attempt to interfere with fate, with terrible consequences.

Morris has also told them that "the things happened so naturally that you might if you so wished attribute [events] to coincidence." This is, in fact, what happens in the story. A strange man appears at the Whites' door the very next morning. He tells them that their son Herbert has been killed in an accident at work, and while the company admits no liability, they would like to settle on the Whites a sum of 200 pounds, as compensation for Herbert's death.

Ten days after the funeral, Mrs. White, almost crazy with grief, forces her husband to make the second wish on the monkey's paw: to bring Herbert back to them. Nothing happens for several hours, but then there is a knock at the door, "It's my boy! It's Herbert!" the old lady cries. "I forgot it was two miles to the cemetery!"

Mr. White imagines his mangled son, risen after ten days in a grave, whose face was barely recognizable after the accident, standing at their door. To spare his wife this horrible sight, he makes the third and final wish on the paw: that Herbert go away.

By tempting fate, and wishing for money, the Whites lose something even more precious: their son, and their happy life as a family.

Human Condition
It is human nature to want what one cannot have, and to undervalue what one does possess. Another common truth about the human condition is that people's best qualities often turn out to be their worst: the characteristics that can save them on the one hand can be their undoing on the other. The downfall of the White family comes from tendencies within each of the Whites that are only natural.

For example, Mr. White, in his life a reasonable man, is reckless in small ways like in the chess game he plays with his son. He is skeptical about the power of the monkey's paw; he feels foolish wishing on it and discounts the many warnings he hears and sees about the dangers of using it. He does, however, make his wishes. In the end, his "sensible" wish for the mortgage money is his undoing. The fact that he has wished at all is enough to bring on the fakir's curse.

Mrs. White also carries the seed of her destruction in her own character. She is the picture of the ideal housewife at the time the story was written: a good housekeeper, devoted to her husband and son, happy to let the men in the household make the important decisions. In her great love for Herbert, her son—for which she can hardly be faulted—she seizes upon the idea of wishing him back from the dead. Normally quiet and demure, she exhorts Mr. White to wish Herbert back with such force that he cannot deny her, even against his better instincts.

Herbert himself is a good-natured young man, who teases his parents about the power of the monkey's paw. He, too, is skeptical. His joking is not mean; under the circumstances, it seems normal. However, we wonder whether he would have lost his life if he had been more respectful of these mysterious powers.

Unlock This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now.

  • 30,000+ book summaries
  • 20% study tools discount
  • Ad-free content
  • PDF downloads
  • 300,000+ answers
  • 5-star customer support
Start your 48-hour free trial
Previous

Summary

Next

Characters