tablesetting complete with forks, knives, and spoons, and a baby on the plate in the center above the words "A Modest Proposal"

A Modest Proposal

by Jonathan Swift

Start Free Trial

Themes: Suffering and Greed

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Swift traces the link between suffering and greed in this essay. He achieves this through an ironic framing of his clueless narrator, who is indifferent to the suffering of the poor. To him, they are merely a problem for the well-to-do. The Irish poor are starving, unemployed, and desperate, with almost no hope of a better situation. The narrator, for whom morals are subordinate to economic calculations, highlights the plight of the poor, because, to his mind, it buttresses his case for cannibalism. The descriptions of poor people’s sufferings are also an important part of Swift’s broader thesis: he wants readers to know how the Irish poor are suffering and not to have these facts downplayed.

The narrator explicitly connects Irish poverty to the actions of the rich. He states that the children of the poor, if they became a salable commodity, could be used as collateral against debt and taken by landlords as repayment; the landlords have already “seized” all the cattle and crops of the poor. The narrator comments that landlords have not “one degree of mercy towards their tenants.” The narrator makes a statement that from his point of view is sincere. He suggests that the price of the children to eaten will be expensive (“dear”) but is

therefore very proper for landlords, who, as they have already devoured most of the parents, seem to have the best title to the children.

Swift makes it clear that if the landlords had been less greedy, the poor would not be suffering so completely as they do. Thus the problem of poverty in Ireland is not the fault of the poor, but of the rich, who have for too long extracted too much from subjects with no power to fight back.

Expert Q&A

I need to create my own 'Modest Proposal' inspired by Swift's work. What political, economic, or social issues could I address with a satirical and unfeasible solution?

So far I've looked at: State Pension Shortfalls in the United States, Federal health care spending, Federal entitlement spending, Global Warming, The Unsustainable Welfare States of France or Britain, Income Inequality in the US, Homelessness.

To craft a satirical "Modest Proposal," consider addressing issues like state pension shortfalls or income inequality with absurd solutions. For pensions, propose mandatory retirement euthanasia to solve funding problems. For income inequality, suggest a 100% income tax with equal redistribution. These highlight the absurdity of extreme solutions to complex issues. Alternatively, tackle global warming by requiring everyone to live like the Amish, foregoing modern conveniences to reduce carbon emissions. These ideas mimic Swift's irony and exaggeration.

What harm have the absentee landlords done to their tenants in "A Modest Proposal"?

The narrator argues that the English landlords have behaved without mercy toward their tenants and should be punished by the Irish.

What human fault is Swift highlighting in "A Modest Proposal"?

Jonathan Swift highlights human faults such as greed, callousness, and the prioritization of economic theory over humanity in "A Modest Proposal." Through satire, Swift criticizes the English for exploiting and mistreating the Irish, emphasizing their indifference to human suffering in favor of wealth. His mock proposal to consume Irish children underscores the absurdity of neglecting humane solutions to poverty, urging readers to recognize the inhumanity of such attitudes.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: The Narrowness of Reason

Next

Themes: Solutions to Poverty

Loading...