A Modest Proposal Themes
The main themes in A Modest Proposal are the humanity of the poor, the narrowness of reason, and suffering and greed.
- The humanity of the poor: Swift’s central satirical strategy frames Ireland’s poor as mere economic data. The purpose of the essay, then, is to make evident that the poor are in fact human beings.
- The narrowness of reason: Swift’s ironic adherence to reason reveals the failures of pure reasoning without a set of ethical principles to guide it.
- Suffering and greed: The essay makes explicit the connection between the suffering of the poor and the greed of the rich.
Themes: All Themes
Themes: The Humanity of the Poor
In Swift’s satirical 1729 essay A Modest Proposal, the narrator is a conceited and clueless economist who proposes to solve Ireland’s famine by the consumption of infants. Swift’s reprehensible narrator serves a key rhetorical purpose. The narrator’s eponymous “modest proposal”—solving poverty through cannibalism—is meant to appall readers. In creating this narrator and this proposal, Swift is using hyperboleand irony to send a...
(Read more)Themes: The Narrowness of Reason
Swift’s narrator focuses minutely on facts and figures about the poor. There is a careful reasoning behind the narrator’s opinions, but his reasoning—unguided by ethics—leads to vile conclusions. For example, he calculates the cost of fattening up and raising a poor infant until the age of one, when it can be sold to be prepared as a delicacy to be served at rich people’s tables. He carefully calculates the profit to be expected but entirely...
(Read more)Themes: Suffering and Greed
Swift traces the link between suffering and greed in this essay. He achieves this through an ironic framing of his clueless narrator, who is indifferent to the suffering of the poor. To him, they are merely a problem for the well-to-do. The Irish poor are starving, unemployed, and desperate, with almost no hope of a better situation. The narrator, for whom morals are subordinate to economic calculations, highlights the plight of the poor,...
(Read more)Themes: Solutions to Poverty
One of Swift’s central ideas in this essay is that there are real solutions to the problems of poverty. He did not write this essay for his own amusement or because he agreed that it was a good idea to sell, kill, and eat human infants. A clergyman who felt anger and anguish over the plight of the poor, Swift composed the essay out of a deep frustration with the lack of response from people with power to what he perceived as a humanitarian crisis...
(Read more)Themes: Satire
Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" is a masterful example of satire, using irony, exaggeration, and humor to critique English exploitation of Ireland. Swift adopts the persona of a rational scientist to propose the absurd idea of selling Irish children as food, mocking the dehumanizing attitudes of English Protestants towards Irish Catholics. Through vivid imagery and ironic language, Swift highlights the dire conditions of the Irish poor and...
(Read more)Themes: Social Critique
Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" is a powerful social critique that uses satire to address the severe economic and social issues in 18th-century Ireland. Through exaggerated solutions and a seemingly rational narrator, Swift highlights the indifference of the ruling classes towards the plight of the poor. His proposal to solve poverty by eating children is a shocking metaphor for the exploitation and dehumanization faced by the Irish under...
(Read more)Expert Q&A
Exploring Themes and Essay Topics in Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal"
Jonathan Swift's satirical essay "A Modest Proposal" critiques British exploitation of the Irish by suggesting the absurd solution of selling impoverished Irish infants as food for the wealthy. This proposal highlights the dehumanizing treatment of the Irish and aims to provoke outrage and reflection on more humane solutions to poverty. Swift anticipates objections to his proposal, using them to mock the lack of practical measures to address Irish poverty. The speaker's alignment with British imperialists is ironic, as Swift's true sympathies lie with the oppressed Irish.
Exploring the Themes and Underlying Meanings in "A Modest Proposal" Through Its Various Elements
"A Modest Proposal" uses satire to critique the British exploitation of Ireland. Swift's ironic suggestion of eating children to solve poverty highlights the inhumanity of British policies. By exaggerating the proposal, Swift underscores the dire situation in Ireland and criticizes both British colonialism and the indifferent attitudes of the wealthy. The essay exposes the moral failings and social injustices of the time.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.