Discussion Topic

Modernism Themes and Characteristics

Summary:

Modernism, emerging in the late 19th century and peaking by World War II, is characterized by a break from tradition and established norms, emphasizing individualism, alienation, and subjectivity. Influenced by thinkers like Darwin and Freud, it responded to societal upheavals and technological advancements. Key themes include the search for meaning in a fragmented world, often expressed through experimental techniques like stream-of-consciousness. Prominent figures include Virginia Woolf, James Joyce, and T.S. Eliot, who critiqued modernity's emptiness and explored complex inner realities.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the themes and characteristics of Modernism?

In "The Case for the Ephemeral," G. K. Chesterton attacked both the idea and the name of Modernism, writing:

It is incomprehensible to me that any thinker can calmly call himself a modernist; he might as well call himself a Thursdayite.

Chesterton regards Modernism as shallow and snobbish in the same way that it is shallow and snobbish to look down on others because one has a newer car or more fashionable clothes than they do. An intellectual and artistic movement ought to have more to offer than being the most recent phenomenon, which, of course, Modernism no longer is.

While Modernism certainly has an element of snobbery in it, it is far from being the blind worship of progress Chesterton is criticizing. Modernity is clearly one of the principal themes of Modernism, but the great Modernist writers—including T. S. Eliot, Virginia Woolf, and James Joyce—are far from worshipping the modern age. On the contrary, they write very scathingly about modernity, constantly complaining that it is empty and vapid. The snobbish element of their attitude lies not in any pride at being up to date, but in their dislike of democracy as a central element of modernity.

In The Intellectuals and the Masses, John Carey argues that the obscurity and difficulty generally associated with Modernism are a direct result of this anti-democratic attitude. The advent of Modernism coincided with the rise of mass literacy, but the Modernists preferred an elite readership. James Joyce, Carey points out, even went so far as to write a book about the common man which no common man would be able to read.

Modernism is a paradoxical movement in many ways. It is certainly a reaction against Victorianism, but it is also a revolt against the twentieth century. Clement Greenberg, one of the foremost authorities on the movement, described Modernism in a 1979 lecture on the subject as the artist's response to an ongoing emergency. He continued:

Artists in all times, despite some appearances to the contrary, have sought aesthetic excellence. What singles Modernism out and gives it its place and identity more than anything else is its response to a heightened sense of threats to aesthetic value: threats from the social and material ambience, from the temper of the times, all conveyed through the demands of a new and open cultural market, middlebrow demands.

What Carey regards as snobbery, Greenberg sees as an ongoing quest for artistic excellence in an increasingly philistine and commercial atmosphere.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

It's hard to establish exactly when Modernism began, but most scholars argue that the Modernist period began in the late 19th century and reached the end of its height by World War II. Some of Modernism's most famous authors include Ernest Hemingway, Virginia Woolf, James Joyce, Ezra Pound, William Faulkner, T.S. Eliot, Gertrude Stein, and F. Scott Fitzgerald.

In many ways, Modernism was a response to the influx of the revolutionary ideas of thinkers such as Darwin, Freud, and Nietzsche. Altogether, these individuals presented ideas that deconstructed important traditional foundations of society, such as religion, ethics, sexuality, and even the identity of the individual. Additionally, the technological advancements and chaos of World War I caused the widespread doubt that humanity was actually progressing; indeed, after the unprecedented violence of the war, many people began to believe that human society was descending into turmoil and meaninglessness. 

The Modernist movement began in the capitals of Europe, and it was concerned with exploring themes of alienation and dislocation in society, and with the struggle to find meaning and identity in a rapidly changing world. Artistic techniques of the period include Impressionism, Cubism, stream of consciousness narrative and more, and, through these techniques, artists sought to explore the fragmentary, suddenly messy nature of modern life. In general, much of Modernism grapples with the sense that, with the loss of traditional values, some vital aspect of human society was also lost. As such, much of the art and literature produced during this period incorporates the sensation of wandering and searching for some kind of value. It's hardly surprising, therefore, that Stein referred to some of the most prominent Modernists as "the lost generation."

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the characteristics of the Modernism time period?

According to Trent Lorcher in "Lesson Plans: Modernism in Literature,"

Modernism is marked by a strong and intentional break with tradition. This break includes a strong reaction against established religious, political, and social views.

The Modernist movement began after the Realist movement. Some of the most prominent writers during this time period are William Faulkner, Robert Frost, T.S. Eliot, among many others.

The Realist movement reflected a writer's desire to present a story objectively, without any personal response to the material in the story. It was the relaying of the truth of a moment or series of actions without making a subjective judgment.

"There is not embellishment or interpretation... [literature of the Realism movement was] "purport[ed] to be undistorted by personal bias.

So where the Realist movement was guided by presenting literature without prejudicial assessments, the Modernists were not only interested in defying the approach to religious, political and social norms, but passed "judgment" on their subjects, rather than simply reporting, in a clinical or empirical way, what they had observed.

In other words, the Realist authors were more objective in their perceptions of the world, and the Modernists were more emotionally involved, and committed to questioning the conventions of what had been previously been assumed or "cleaned up" without question.

As an example, William Faulker's "A Rose For Emily" lifts up the general norms of a Southern society not too long after the Civil War, especially in terms of a woman of the elite class; the developing plot exposes the mysteries and secrets of this woman that are unexpected by Faulkner's readers. Emily is not a woman above reproach, not a sophisticated, southern "rose:" she not only kills someone, but sleeps beside his dead corpse until her death. This shows how the author pushes the reader's perceptions and blows apart the social norms in the 1930s when it was printed.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

True to the modernist period, you will get a variety of answers and you will have to try to make sense of all that you get with it.  When Woolf writes, that "All human relations shifted," she is not kidding.  Modernism rooted itself in "shifting" what consciousness meant and what it was considered to be.  This becomes one of the critical elements of the Modernist time period.  The idea of how human beings see themselves was one of the critical elements of Modernism.  As opposed to seeing themselves as pioneers of a new era of technology, Modernist thinkers sought to examine how alienated the individual actually was.  While technology and rationality heralded a new future, Modernist thinkers sought to examine how individual identity is a tableau of all time periods, including, but not limited to, the past and future.  Time shifts around in the Modernist time period.  The figments and fragments of what was considered to be "truth" occupies the central importance of the Modernist thinker.  All the progress and advancement in the world could not offset World War I and the damage wrought in the process.  The decomposed nature of both bodies and truth became a critical theme in Modernism.  In the end, Modernists were the lone voices of shrill dissent in a period of conformist ascent.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the characteristics of Modernism in literature?

Asked and answered.  Go to Literature/Modernism for a full discussion, and see the scholarship of Irving Howe on this subject.  Thoroughly covered in previous answers.  The text below is repetition for your convenience: 

This term, which originally simply meant “art and literature of these times” was frozen into meaning  the period approximately between 1850 and 1914, when the term “post-modernism” was coined.  (It’s good to remember that these terms are coined after the fact, by critics and scholars, not by the actual artists.)  It differentiated the current artistic impulses from the Victorian, 19 century, Industrial age; its primary features were a rejection of classical and Romantic influences in favor of modern (then) notions of Reason, human psychology, social equalities, and creative license; a re-examination of artistic forms such as free verse, nonlinear plots, and non-rigid forms; and a celebration of individuality vs. group identification.  The term causes confusion because it embraces each movement as art progressed.  Postmodernism refers to art that is about itself: self-conscious art, art that deals with its own forms as a subject--example: Unamuno’s novel, “The Fog (La Niebla),” in which a character in the novel goes to Unamuno’s house and asks not to be killed off in the novel.  A central, seminal study by Irving Howe, “Modernism in Literature,” answers the question “What is Modernism” thoroughly.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the specific features of Modernism?

One of the critical elements of modernism is the belief that the guiding structures and principles that helped to define consciousness are no longer present.  This absence creates a void where individuals are left to fend for themselves in the search for meaning.  I think that this can be seen in writers like Yeats and Joyce.  When Yeats writes in "The Second Coming," that "the center cannot hold" and "things fall apart," he is expressing a critical sentiment of Modernism.  In this world, "the best lack all conviction and the worst are filled with passionate intensity."  What individuals were taught as to be true and valid are not actually so. Modernists were profoundly impacted by the First World War, a conflict where individuals were told to willingly sacrifice for nation and for honor and then were exposed to the most horrific of circumstances where tens of millions military and civilian deaths ruled the landscape, where nations were literally obliterated and villages razed for no tangible reason, and where millions of children were orphaned.  Individuals willingly sacrificed for nations and leaders, uncertain as to why.  The guiding narrative structure that helped to provide meaning to parents and grandparents were not able to articulate any reason to the children of this war.  When Joyce writes in a stream of consciousness style and does so in rejecting national, religious, and familial identity in the embrace of his own personal "non serviam credo," he does so because the defining structures, the existent plan, is no longer present.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the major characteristics of literary modernism?

Critics will say that the modernist movement in literature is actually best described as a period rather than an a cohesive artistic movement. However, we can certainly identify a number of common interests to the writers of the modernist period. It is this set of shared interests that has retroactively come to define the idea of literary modernism.

Modernist writing often emphasized formal experimentation as a means to express subjectivity and the variability of "truth" in narrative.

That humans are alienated from true knowledge of themselves is the implicit contention of the stream-of-consciousness form of narration.

Virginia Woolf and William Faulkner are two clear examples of these notions at work. Their novels are characterized by dense, highly original prose presented in conjunction within unconventional narrative structures, often using the stream-of-conscious narrative method. 

The notion of subjectivity as the cornerstone of human experience was also an aspect of modernist poetry. Poets created new forms of narrative poetry, utilized broken structures and incorporating juxtaposition of ideas, feelings and languages.

...they attempted to model the fragmented nature of minds and civilization in their narratives.

T.S. Eliot, Ezra Pound and William Carlos Williams are examples of poets who are now considered to be modernist poets. 

Beyond subjectivity of experience and ideas of the difficulty of truth, modernism demonstrated a personal relationship with the past that was often at odds with the growing trends of urbanization and industrialization. Themes relating to this emphasis on the individual's place in (and relationship to) history include alienation and Fruedian psychology.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial