Themes: Appearances and Reality
In "Miss Brill," Mansfield employs a stream-of-consciousness style to emphasize the stark contrast between appearances and reality through the protagonist's inner thoughts. At the beginning of the story, Miss Brill is disturbed by an elderly couple silently seated on a nearby bench, making it difficult for her to listen in on their lives. She doesn't realize that their silence reflects her own quiet life. Miss Brill also notices that the other park visitors are "odd, silent, nearly all old" and seem as if they "had just come from dark little rooms or even—even cupboards!" Ironically, she fails to recognize that she is one of these strange individuals living in a metaphorical cupboard. She observes an old woman wearing a fur hat, which she calls a "shabby ermine," likely purchased when the woman's hair was still yellow. When the woman raises her hand to her lips, Miss Brill compares it to a "tiny yellowish paw." While she ridicules this woman in her mind, she doesn't see the resemblance between the "ermine toque" and her own appearance. Later, Miss Brill envisions the park-goers as actors in a play and feels a connection with them: "We understand, we understand, she thought." However, this illusion is shattered when an attractive couple, whom she imagines as the hero and heroine, reveals through their conversation that they do not share this "appearance" of a theatrical production. Their harsh comments show they are not "members of the company" who "understand." They dismiss her as a "stupid old thing" with fur that resembles a "fried whiting." The play—a metaphor that momentarily gave Miss Brill a sense of clarity—exists solely in her imagination. This stark division between appearance and reality in "Miss Brill" highlights the story's theme of alienation, emphasizing how Miss Brill is isolated and disconnected from her surroundings.
Expert Q&A
What is ironic about Miss Brill's impressions of others in "Miss Brill"?
The most ironic part about Miss Brill's impressions of other people in the park in "Miss Brill" is that she observes them to feel like she belongs to the community, even though she is a reclusive outsider.
What is Miss Brill's self-image and her attitude towards herself?
What does Mansfield want us to learn from Miss Brill's false perception of reality?
Mansfield's "Miss Brill" teaches the importance of seeing oneself clearly and interacting authentically with one's environment. Miss Brill's false perception of reality is rooted in self-deception, as she imagines herself distinct from the mundane lives around her. However, her only real interaction is one of ridicule, highlighting her disconnect. The story suggests that genuine human connection is vital for understanding oneself and aligning one's self-image with reality.
Do Miss Brill's plaza observations sustain her?
Yes, Miss Brill's regular observations help her sustain herself, especially regarding her mental health, and give her something to look forward to.
Why does the "play" metaphor delight Miss Brill in the story?
Is Miss Brill a spectator or an actor, and how does her role influence your perception of her?
Miss Brill is both a spectator and an actor in the imaginary world she creates at the Sunday concerts. She acts by crafting illusions and engaging with her surroundings, such as speaking to her fur necklet. As a spectator, she observes the people around her, perceiving life as a play. Her dual role highlights her detachment from reality, and when her illusions are shattered by ridicule, she retreats to her lonely existence, emphasizing her vulnerability.
The symbolic significance and personification of the fur in "Miss Brill."
The fur in "Miss Brill" symbolizes Miss Brill's own feelings of isolation and her desire for connection. Personified as a companion, the fur reflects her emotional state and longing for warmth and companionship. When she puts it away at the end, it signifies her realization of her own loneliness and the harsh reality of her existence.
Miss Brill's perception of the world as a stage and her role within it
In "Miss Brill," the protagonist views the world as a stage and herself as an important actor within it. She imagines the people around her as fellow performers, believing that everyone has a role to play in this grand, communal performance. This perception allows her to feel connected and significant, masking her deep loneliness and isolation.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.