How would you describe the character of Miss Brill in "Miss Brill"?

Quick answer:

Miss Brill is a lonely spinster who enjoys the beauty of nature and people-watching. She is naïve, sensitive, and selfless, but she does not really recognize her emotions.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

It is hard not to feel incredibly sorry for the character of Miss Brill in this excellent short story. We are told that she teaches English and that she also reads the newspaper to an "invalid old gentleman" four times each week. However, without a doubt, the highlight of her week is going each Sunday at the same time to listen to the band in the Jardins Publiques--the public gardens. This is clearly an important event for her, as she takes great care in the way that she dresses. This time of the week is so important for her because she loves watching the other people in the gardens and listening in on their conversations:

She had become really quite expert, she thought, at listening as though she didn't listen, at sitting in other people's lives just for a minute while they talked round her.

It is this "sitting in other people's lives" that is the central attraction, as we can infer that Miss Brill has no "life" of her own to "sit" in, and therefore she is reduced to living other people's lives vicariously through such trips to distract her from the emptiness of her own life. As she observes more and more, she imagines that the scene before her is like a "play" in which she too has a part and is significant. However, this dream of hers is punctured rather suddenly and rudely when a couple that she imagines to be "the hero and heroine, of course, just arrived from his father's yacht" make fun of her and send her back home to her "cupboard" of a room in tears.

Miss Brill therefore is a single woman who is profoundly lonely and isolated, and goes to the gardens each week to savour something of the life that she herself has never experienced. Although she tries to forget the empty reality of her existence by elaborate illusions and fantasies designed to give her significance and meaning, and link her in with others, at the end of the tale she is forced to confront her shadow of a life.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Sketch the character of Miss Brill.

Characterization is a detailed description of a character’s physical and personality traits.  You have chosen an excellent story to ask about characterization, because this story is a perfect example of indirect characterization, which is the process of describing a character indirectly through the character’s thoughts and actions, rather than telling us directly about the character.

We know several things about Miss Brill from her visit to the park.  First of all, we know that she is a people watcher.  She enjoys watching people as if they were a show.  We also know that she cares about people.  She is a teacher, which is a service profession, and she reads newspapers to old people.  Both seem to indicate she is selfless and giving. 

Miss Brill is also a bit naïve.  She is unmarried, thus the miss, and she doesn’t seem to have any romantic relationships.  She gets so caught up in watching the people, especially the young couple on the bench next to her, that she forgets that this is real life and she is eavesdropping.  She means no harm though. She lives largely in her head.

Miss Brill is sensitive, but she does not really recognize the emotion.  She loves her park, she loves watching people, and she loves her necklet almost to the point of imaging it has feelings.  When she is ridiculed, she does not really internalize the emotion and recognize that she is, indeed, sad.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Sketch the character of Miss Brill.

Ms. Brill is a expatriate British teacher living in France, presumably a spinter, who lives in isolation with the exception of sporadic visits to an elderly friend to whom she reads. Her visits to the park on Sunday, and her connection to the fur necklette she wears make you realize that she is alone in the world, with not much to do, since she has spent her life in isolation, consoling herself with the simplicity of park visits, and observing people.

Due to her lack of social interaction, she has internalized a world of her own, where she gives roles to each of the strangers she sees in the street, perhaps as an attempt to connect with them in some internal way as she is unable to do so physically.

She is obviously not happy with her life, though she makes herself believe that she is. This is documented in the way she metaphorically shows how her fake necklette, which she is so proud of, is "crying" as she puts it back it its isolated box. She was crying too, internally, as she put it away since she felt (through the mockery of other park visitors) that she may not be at all welcomed in the world. Maybe, she feels, she must remain alone. It is her reality.

Ms. Brill is the epitome of the human being hungry for connections and communication. She is incapable of changing her situation, so she succumbed to it. Her nature is undeniably a call for help, but nobody seems to listen.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Sketch the character of Miss Brill.

Miss Brill is an English teacher, presumably to middle or secondary school students.  By all accounts, she is good at her profession.  Teaching occupies a great deal of her life, not because of a particular passion or zeal but more because there is little else in it.  The weekends, in particular Sunday, allow her to indulge in her once a week routine of taking out a prized and revered fur necklet and sitting in the park and, essentially, engage in people watching.  Her engagement in this activity allows her to believe that she is an integral and essential part of this community setting.  She believes that band plays music that she enjoys, that the people in the park are empty without her presence each and every Sunday, and with her fur, represents the center of this small communitarian universe.  Within this setting is a strong sense of denial of reality, for she is committed to the power of her self imposed illusion.  Her connection to this world is an illusion, and Miss Brill's inability to distinguish between what is real and what is in her mind represents a great deal of this character.  In Miss Brill, the reader sees how dreams and illusions can be both motivating, but also painful, as one is crushed under their weight.  Certainly, Miss Brill, as she blames the fur for the climax of the story, seems to be pinned under such a burden.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Sketch the character of Miss Brill.

For starters, give a physical description of the character. She's middle aged and thinks that she is well dressed and fashionable. This initial presentation of her is merely a facade and we learn that she is a rather tired and deluded character.

Another area to look at is her clothing and what this represents about her. Her personality is directly reflected by what she wears and her internal dialogue shows us that Miss Brill verges on arrogant.

By the end of the story, she realises that she is far from a glamorous player in the game of life, rather she is insulted by a young couple who look down upon her. She is dull and alone.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on