Themes: The Ubiquity of Secrets
“The Minister’s Black Veil” centers around a single mystery and metaphor: the black veil that Reverend Mr. Hooper unexpectedly begins to wear one Sunday morning. From the beginning, the black veil appears to represent a secret, but the nature and scope of that secret is only made clear at the end.
Initially, the village of Milford cannot understand Mr. Hooper’s donning of the veil, and when an embassy of villagers visits him to raise the matter, they are speechless, for the veil is “the symbol of a fearful secret between him and them.” At this stage, it is assumed that the veil marks some personal sin on Mr. Hooper’s behalf. When Elizabeth visits, she intimates that the village has begun to spread rumors about some scandalous sin—likely of a licentious nature—which Mr. Hooper has committed and feels compelled to conceal. But in the story’s penultimate paragraph, Mr. Hooper, on his deathbed, clarifies the symbolism of the veil: it represents the secrets which each man withholds and which causes him to “vainly shrink from the eye of his Creator.” In Mr. Hooper’s final words, he claims to see “on every visage a black veil!” Indeed, the subject of the story is not one particular secret but secretiveness in general.
For Mr. Hooper, secretiveness is a spiritual matter. In the first sermon he delivers, he discusses “those sad mysteries which we hide from our nearest and dearest.” The broad relevance of this theme is apparent in the congregation’s universal response to Mr. Hooper’s word; each congregant feels that Mr. Hooper has “discovered their hoarded iniquity of deed or thought.” One of the paradoxes of the story lies in the fact that Mr. Hooper’s veiled appearance and sermons are received by the villagers with fear and bewilderment, and yet his message is ultimately positive and straightforward: to reveal one’s mind and soul to others. But the story suggests that, straightforward as this message may be, the secretiveness it resists is ubiquitous.
Expert Q&A
In "The Minister's Black Veil," what does Mr. Hooper mean by "There is an hour to come when all of us shall cast aside our veils"?
Mr. Hooper's statement about casting aside veils refers to the Christian belief in the final judgment, when all hidden motives and actions will be revealed before God. Until that time, he feels compelled to wear the veil as a symbol of secret sin and is bound by a vow not to remove it. This decision isolates him, causing loneliness and fear, yet he remains committed to his symbolic act.
What do Father Hooper's final words reveal about his reasons for wearing the veil in "The Minister's Black Veil"?
In "The Minister's Black Veil," Father Hooper's final words disclose that his possible reason for wearing the black veil was to remind himself and others of his sinfulness. With his last breath, he says, "I look around me, and, lo! on every visage a Black Veil!" This is an indication that both he and the people surrounding his deathbed are all inveterate sinners. The difference, however, is that he at least is acknowledging his sins.
What reason did Father Hooper give on his deathbed for people's fear of him?
On his deathbed, Father Hooper explained that people feared him because of the black veil he wore, which symbolized humanity's hidden sins. He highlighted the irony that people avoided him due to the veil, not realizing it represented their own secret sinful natures. Hooper suggested that everyone wears a metaphorical veil to hide their sins from each other and God, and his physical veil merely exposed this universal truth.
How does the veil affect Mr. Hooper's preaching and Elizabeth's response?
The veil enhances Mr. Hooper's preaching, making his sermons profoundly impactful and causing the congregation to feel deeply moved and uncomfortable. Elizabeth, initially unafraid, asks Hooper to remove the veil and explain its significance. When he refuses to do so, she becomes upset, as Hooper chooses the veil over a life of happiness with her. Ultimately, Hooper dies alone, suggesting the veil's isolating effect.
Why doesn't anyone directly ask Mr. Hooper about his veil?
No one will ask Mr. Hooper a direct question about his veil, as the veil separates Hooper from those around him, seeming like "the symbol of a fearful secret between him and them." When a group attempts to discuss the veil with Mr. Hooper, they shrink "uneasily" from his glance and decide to put the matter off. The mysteriousness of Hooper's motive in wearing the veil intensifies this sense of separation, making communication between them impossible.
What inference can be drawn from the minister's final words in "The Minister's Black Veil: A Parable"?
"Why do you tremble at me alone?...I look around me, and , lo! On every visage a black veil!"
Why won't the Minister remove his veil for Elizabeth in "The Minister's Black Veil"?
The Minister refuses to remove his veil for Elizabeth because he views it as a symbol and a personal vow. He tells Elizabeth that the veil separates him from the world and must remain, even from her. This decision reflects his awareness of his own sins and a desire to avoid hypocrisy. The veil symbolizes the metaphorical barriers of sin that separate individuals from each other and from God.
In "The Minister's Black Veil," does the veil separate Mr. Hooper from the villagers? Does he desire this separation?
The veil in "The Minister's Black Veil" indeed separates Mr. Hooper from the villagers, creating a physical and emotional barrier. It prevents eye contact and instills a sense of dread, making him seem ominous and repulsive. This separation is intensified by rumors of his secret sin. Although Mr. Hooper feels lonely and frightened by this isolation, he believes he must wear the veil, highlighting the theme of inevitable isolation despite a desire for connection.
How does Hawthorne develop the symbolism of the veil throughout the story?
Hawthorne develops the symbolism of the veil by gradually revealing its connection to secret sin and societal alienation. Initially, the veil isolates Mr. Hooper and suggests an association with hidden fears. Through interactions, particularly with Elizabeth, it becomes linked to sorrow and guilt. By the story's end, Mr. Hooper explicitly connects the veil to the universal human tendency to hide sin, emphasizing its role as a symbol of concealed transgressions and internal agony.
What sin do the townspeople commit in response to the minister's veil?
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.