Themes: Alienation
The price Reverend Mr. Hooper pays for his decision to wear the black veil is alienation. This alienation is forced upon him by his fellow villagers, who shun him for his inexplicable and terrifying transformation, but it is also self-imposed.
One of the paradoxes of the story is that the village of Milford reacts to Mr. Hooper’s donning of the black veil with a combination of ostracization and intense scrutiny. This is illustrated in the first scene of the story, when Mr. Hooper approaches the meeting-house for the Sunday church service. As he enters, the congregation is “astir,” with everyone “bustling” about and craning their necks to stare at him. After the service, the congregants rush out of the meeting-house in relief, gathering to speak of Mr. Hooper in hushed or jovial tones. But as Mr. Hooper approaches them, he is met only with “strange and bewildered looks,” and, unusually, nobody invites him to dinner. The village never entirely adapts to Mr. Hooper’s change, forever viewing him with a combination of suspicion, fear, and awed respect.
To some extent, Mr. Hooper’s alienation is his own choice. By challenging the village with the spectacle of the black veil, which “obscurely typifies” the secretiveness of the human soul, Mr. Hooper has chosen to stand apart from their society. The greatest loss Mr. Hooper suffers in the name of the veil is his beloved, Elizabeth. When she demands that he remove the veil, he replies, “Never! It cannot be!” At this, Elizabeth leaves him, ending their relationship. For Mr. Hooper, to be alienated by Elizabeth is more painful than to be alienated by his fellow villagers, and as she leaves, he cries out
Oh, you know not how lonely I am, and how frightened to be alone behind my black veil! Do not leave me in this obscurity forever.
Although it is never clear why Mr. Hooper takes on the cause of the black veil with such avidity, it is evident that he feels inexorably called to wear the veil—even at the cost of utter alienation.
Expert Q&A
What does the narrator mean by calling the human heart the saddest of all prisons?
The narrator describes the human heart as the "saddest of all prisons" to highlight how individuals isolate themselves by hiding their secret sins. This metaphor suggests that people are trapped in their own hearts, alienating themselves from others due to fear of judgment. By wearing a black veil, Mr. Hooper symbolizes this self-imposed separation, as he bravely acknowledges his sins, unlike others who hide theirs, thus deepening their isolation.
What is the reaction of the parishioners to the minister's black veil?
The parishioners react to the minister's black veil with astonishment, fear, and discomfort, feeling unnerved and confused by his altered appearance. They speculate about his motivations and feel a disquieting of their consciences. Over time, Mr. Hooper becomes alienated, losing personal relationships, yet gains power over sinners, who feel he understands their hidden sins. Despite this, he remains isolated and refuses to remove the veil, even as he dies, symbolizing the mystery of hidden sins.
In "The Minister's Black Veil," was Mr. Hooper right to refuse Elizabeth's request to remove his veil?
Mr. Hooper was justified in refusing Elizabeth's request to remove his veil because it represented a serious vow and symbolized universal human sin. His decision was not made lightly and was integral to his identity and religious conviction. The veil's symbolism required consistency, even at the cost of personal relationships, like with Elizabeth. Despite public pressure and personal challenges, Hooper remained steadfast in his commitment to wearing the veil.
The theme of isolation in "The Minister's Black Veil."
The theme of isolation in "The Minister's Black Veil" is depicted through Reverend Hooper's choice to wear the black veil, which alienates him from his community and loved ones. The veil symbolizes hidden sins and the barriers they create between individuals, leading to Hooper's emotional and social isolation despite his physical presence among others.
Why does Mr. Hooper in "The Minister's Black Veil" choose loneliness over happiness with Elizabeth?
Mr. Hooper in "The Minister's Black Veil" chooses loneliness over happiness with Elizabeth to fulfill a deeper mission. His enigmatic decision may symbolize the hidden sins and hypocrisy of humanity, suggesting a commitment to a moral or spiritual calling. Various theories suggest he seeks self-sacrifice, reflects Hawthorne's own eccentricities, or experiences a psychological drive for a significant personal milestone. His actions prioritize this profound message over personal happiness.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
