Discussion Topic

Humor and its role in social criticism in "The Miller's Tale" from The Canterbury Tales

Summary:

In "The Miller's Tale" from The Canterbury Tales, humor serves as a tool for social criticism by highlighting human follies and societal norms. Through bawdy and exaggerated scenarios, Chaucer critiques issues such as class distinctions, marital fidelity, and human gullibility, using humor to expose and mock the flaws and hypocrisies of medieval society.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the main sources of humour in "The Miller's Tale"?

The sources of humor in "The Miller's Tale" are bawdy, farcical, borderline scatological, and slapstick. 

We remember that the Miller has been drinking and that this colors his tale. His story displays bawdy humor because it deals with sex and nudity in a comic way. Alison and Nicholas trick Alison's elderly husband, John the carpenter, so that they can sleep together. It's farcical because it deals with over-the-top situations: how many men, like the carpenter, are really going to be convinced to spend the night dangling in a tub because they believe someone's prediction that the earth is about to be flooded again, as in Noah's day? While scatological humor deals with feces, we come very close with farts and anuses, as Absolon, Alison's would-be lover, is tricked into kissing her anus, and Absolon, for revenge, sticks a hot poker into Nicholas's anus after Nicholas farts in his...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

face. The humor isslapstick because it involves physical encounters and physical embarrassment: not only do buttocks play a strong role in the humor, John is laughed at by everyone and considered insane for thinking a flood is coming.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Miller and the Carpenter have words on the trip, so when the Miller's turn comes to tell his tale, his main character is a carpenter.  The Miller makes the carpenter rather dumb and gullible in the story to get at the Carpenter on the pilgrimmage.  In the story, the main humor is that the carpenter is being made a fool of by his own wife and her lover.  In order to get some alone time, the wife and her lover tell the carpenter that there will be a flood and that they must sleep in huge tubs secured to the roof so that when the flood comes, they can simply cut themselves loose and float safely away.  The carpenter climbs into his tub and quickly goes to sleep.  His wife and her lover run back to the bedroom for some alone time.  However, it is complicated by the fact that Allison (the wife) is also pursued by another man.  He serenade her at the window and begs for a kiss.  She tells him to close his eyes, and Allison's lover allows the serenading fool to kiss his backside through Allison's window. 

The whole story is full of deception, jealousy, lust, and lack of marital loyalty.  It is not a nice story, but amusing due to the idiocy involved.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Chaucer use humor for social criticisms in "The Miller's Tale" from The Canterbury Tales?

Geoffrey Chaucer uses humor frequently and in numerous ways to make social criticisms in his poem titled The Canterbury Tales. One of the tales, the one associated with the Miller, is especially funny and especially effective in its comic social satire.  Examples of the use of humor in this work include the following:

  •  In the "prologue" to the tale, the Miller is so drunk that he can barely sit on his horse. He is so much under the influence of alcohol that he speaks wildly, in a voice associated with madness, and refuses to show any respect to anyone else. He even takes God’s name in vain (3120-27). Chaucer thus humorously mocks drunkenness, pride, rudeness, and foolishness. Perhaps the most humorous moment of this whole episode occurs in lines 3136-38:

3136         "Now herkneth," quod the Millere, "alle and some!
                    "Now listen," said the Miller, "everyone!
3137         But first I make a protestacioun
                    But first I make a protestation
3138         That I am dronke; I knowe it by my soun.
                    That I am drunk; I know it by my sound.

The Miller, in other words, has just enough intelligence left to figure out that he is inebriated.

  • In the tale itself, Chaucer uses humor to mock crude sexual behavior, as when Nicholas grabs Alisoun by her “quente” (3276). Chaucer also mocks sexual desperation when Nicholas claims that he will “spille” if Alisoun doesn’t have sex with him (3278), and he satirizes irreligious vows when Nicholas claims that unless he does have sex with Alisoun, he will die, so “God me save!” (3281). The whole initial encounter between Nicholas and Alisoun is very funny because it is so very ironic. Each of them, for instance, refers to God and uses other religious terms while plotting the very unchristian act of adultery. Another especially humorous moment in this episode occurs when the Miller describes, in line 3304, how Nicholas says good-bye to Alisoun.  He

. . . thakked hire aboute the lendes weel . . .
                    . . . well patted her about the loins


Here and throughout the tale, there is a complete – and very funny – lack of subtlety in the descriptions of sexual misconduct. The Miller’s approving description of Nicholas’s behavior here helps make the Miller himself seem as ridiculously crude as the people he describes.  Chaucer thus implicitly mocks the anti-social, irreligious attitudes of both the Miller and the people the Miller depicts.

  • When Absolon is first described, his obsession with mere material possessions, especially rich clothing, is implicitly mocked, but then the Miller offers this final tidbit of funny information:

3337         But sooth to seyn, he was somdeel squaymous
                    But to say the truth, he was somewhat squeamish
3338         Of fartyng, and of speche daungerous.
                    About farting, and fastidious in his speech.

These lines, of course, ironically foreshadow the later farting the tale depicts, but here the reference to flatulence seems hilariously unexpected.

In these ways and many others, then, Chaucer in The Miller’s Tale uses humor to mock his characters and their variously bad social behaviors. Irony is the main feature of the humor he employs, but sheer bad taste (no pun intended) also contributes to the hilarity of this particular tale.

Approved by eNotes Editorial