Discussion Topic
The comedy of errors in Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream
Summary:
The comedy of errors in A Midsummer Night's Dream stems from mistaken identities, magical interventions, and romantic mix-ups. Characters fall in and out of love due to the mischievous actions of the fairy Puck and the magical flower, leading to humorous confusion and chaos before everything is resolved happily in the end.
How do events in Act 2 of A Midsummer Night's Dream contribute to its "comedy of errors" label?
Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream can be thought of as one of the quintessential comedies of error, as it involves hilarious love quarrels brought on by both mistaken identities and pure rotten luck.
In many ways, Act II can be viewed as the epicenter of this reputation, for it is in this part of the play that Oberon and his mischievous servant, Puck, make use of a love potion with disastrous results. Oberon orders Puck to use the potion, which causes a sleeping recipient to fall in love with the first person he or she sees upon waking, on Demetrius, who was last seen fleeing from an enamored Helena. Puck, however, mistakes Lysander for Demetrius, and this mistake causes Lysander to fall in love with Helena, an occurrence that understandably enrages Hermia, Lysander's real true love. Meanwhile, Oberon administers the same love potion to Titania, who later wakes up to...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
fall in love with the ridiculous (and donkey-headed) Bottom.
In short, Act II sets up the comedic activities for the rest of the play. Furthermore, all of this hilarity is based on errors, mistakes, and blunders enacted by truly buffoonish characters. For this reason, it is easy to see why the play is not only considered a comedy of errors, but also one of Shakespeare's most hilarious pieces.
What comedy of errors is in Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream?
A comedy of errors often includes mistaken identity. It can also refer to
mistakes made by foolish people.
One example of a comedy of error that we see in A Midsummer Night's
Dream is Puck mistaking Demetrius for Lysander. After Oberon witnesses
Demetrius being cruel to Helena in the woods, he orders Puck to use the magical
flower on Demterius in order to mend Helena's broken heart. However, neither
Oberon nor Puck realize that there are actually two Athenian couples in the
woods that night; hence, Oberon only tells Puck that he will "know the man / By
the Athenian garments he hath on" (II.i.269-270). Therefore, when Puck sees
whom he thinks is Helena lying so far away from whom he thinks is Demetrius, he
assumes that it is because Demetrius is being cruel to her, rather than that
she is trying to preserve her chastity. Puck decides that he has indeed found
the correct Athenian man and enchants his eyes using the magic flower. However,
Puck has mistaken Lysander for Demetrius instead. The result is that Lysander
awakens to see Helena and falls in love with her instead of continuing to love
Hermia. This comedy of error creates great distress among all four lovers, even
leading to a great fight in which Helena accuses both men plus Hermia of
mocking her.
We also see a comedy of error with respect to foolish mistakes the mechanicals
make. The mechanicals have visions of putting on a grand performance before the
duke on his wedding day; however, the reality is that they are too uneducated
and too unskilled to really put on the play they envision. Instead, they make
ridiculous decisions concerning the play, which turn their play from a tragedy
into a comedy. One foolish mistake is the decision to write a prologue to
inform the audience that no one is truly killed in the play, which will
especially appease the sensitive ladies in the audience. It is Bottom's idea to
write a prologue that "seem[s] to say we will do no harm with our swords, and
that Pyramus is not kill'd indeed" (III.i.16-17). This is especially ridiculous
because of course the audience of a play already knows that the things done in
a play are just for show. A second ridiculous idea Bottom has is to have an
actor play the part of a wall and to "hold his fingers thus" in order to form a
chink through which Pyramus and Thisbe discourse (64-65). This is ridiculous
because it not only looks ridiculous, but it is also possible to build a mobile
wall to use for the set. A third ridiculous idea that turns their tragedy into
a comedy is the idea to have a man play the part of the moon. This is
especially absurd because the actor comes on stage with, not only a lantern to
represent the moon, but also, inexplicably, a thorn bush and a dog. All of
these silly and foolish mistakes serve to turn their tragedy into a comedy,
thereby serving as comedies of error.