Examining Walsh's Theory

1. How robust is Walsh's assertion that the Royster brothers force-fed Poe alcohol when examined closely? What solid proof does Walsh offer to bolster this segment of his narrative concerning Poe's demise? Does he craft a compelling argument?

Considering a Full Biography

2. Would crafting a comprehensive biography of Poe, interwoven with Walsh's justification for believing Poe was murdered, have been more effective or perhaps less so?

A Sensational Revelation

3. The revelation that Poe was allegedly murdered, with his murderers unmasked, should send shockwaves through Poe enthusiasts. What reasons might lead some to contest Walsh's conclusions?

Silence and Secrets

4. Why might those privy to the truth choose to remain silent? In what areas does Walsh fail to convincingly address this lack of disclosure?

From Book to Screen

5. Could Midnight Dreary be effectively adapted for the silver screen? Would the conclusion leave viewers feeling gratified?

Elmira Shelton's Silence

6. What might Elmira Shelton's reticence about Poe, save for a few instances, reveal about her disposition?

Elmira's Sacrifice

7. What could drive Elmira Shelton to risk most of her fortune to wed Poe?

Omitting the Scandal

8. Why does Walsh overlook the sensational anecdotes of Poe's alleged drug use, philandering, and hallucinations, which thrive in popular retellings of Poe's existence?

Parallels with Mystery Novels

9. What traits do Midnight Dreary and classic mystery novels share? Does it follow a similar narrative framework? Are there parallels in the methods used to cultivate suspense?