Student Question
Identify the tragic and comic elements in The Metamorphosis.
Quick answer:
In The Metamorphosis, comic elements include Gregor's absurd transformation into an insect, his family's confusion, and Grete's ironic suggestion that Gregor should leave if he were truly himself. Tragic elements are evident in Gregor's stigmatization, fear, and lack of love from his family, symbolizing social and political powerlessness. The final tragic twist is Grete's empathy after Gregor's death and the family's superficial sense of freedom.
Kafka's novella is funny on a number of levels. First, Gregor's whole situation—his transformation into a giant insect—functions as a kind of broad joke, an example of hyperbole, or a metaphor made literal. Gregor isn't simply insignificant like an insect—he is an insect. His transformation has additional comic effect as he family struggles to understand what has happened to him and how to act. Grete's repudiation of Gregor-as-insect is a kind of final comic take on man's inhumanity to man (or brother, in this case): she argues that if the bug really were Gregor, it would have the sense to know it was not wanted and leave on its own!
The tragic implications of Gregor's case are equally clear. As a bug, he is stigmatized, feared, and unloved, even by his own family. If we understand his transformation as a kind of realization of his social and political powerlessness, then we can understand his fate as a bug to be the fate of all who share his disenfranchisement—a fate that ultimately destroys even the bonds of family.
An extra tragic twist lies in the empathy Grete expresses only after Gregor is dead: Look how thin he was," she says, recognizing the corpse of the bug as her brother. The end of the story—which suggests that the Samsas have a bright future now that Gregor is gone—also has a tragic air to it. While it is possible to read their sense of well being as another example of their insensitivity, on another level their eagerness to embrace the bourgeois life (now they can get a better apartment!) suggests that they are just as trapped and powerless as Gregor.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.