The Merchant of Venice Cover Image

The Merchant of Venice

by William Shakespeare

Start Free Trial

Student Question

Why has Shylock and Jessica's father-daughter relationship failed in The Merchant Of Venice?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The father/daughter relationship of Shylock and Jessica has failed on two levels that are most important to Shylock: religious and monetary. In addition, this relationship has also failed on the level of respect.

  • Religious

Jessica elopes with Lorenzo and converts to Christianity.

In Act II, Scene 4, Jessica tells Launcelot, the clown, that she is sorry that he is going to leave her father because she, too, is departing since it is "hell."

Farewell, good Launcelot.
Alack, what heinous sin is it in me
To be ashamed to be my father's child!
But though I am a daughter to his blood,
I am not to his manners. (2.4.15-19)

Jessica runs away after her father goes to supper, ironically, with a "prodigal Christian." When Shylock learns of this, he exclaims,

My daughter! O my ducats! O my daughter! 
Fled with a Christian! O my Christian ducats! (2.8.15-16)

However, while Jessica has converted and become a Christian, she does not act in a Christian manner as she wastes the money and jewels that she has taken from Shylock.

  • Monetary

Shylock's equating of his money with his daughter in the exclamation he makes when he discovers that Jessica is gone may be part of the reason that Jessica has run away. Shylock is very upset because Jessica has taken his jewels, as well, and evidently gone on a spree of spending his money and trading his jewels. In particular, Shylock is livid about Jessica's having traded for a monkey a keepsake ring that Shylock bought for her mother.

  • Respect

Having costumed herself and fled the house while her father is gone, Jessica further displays a total lack of respect for her father when she squanders the fortune she has taken by going on a type of shopping spree. She trades jewels for things that are not worth them, and she squanders money.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In The Merchant of Venice, how does Shakespeare portray Shylock and Jessica's father-daughter relationship?

The relationship between Shylock and his daughter Jessica is one that is never clearly spelled out in The Merchant of Venice. We know that Jessica says to Launcelot that their house is "hell." We know that Jessica says she is not a daughter to Shylock's "manners" and the she wants to "end this strife." But "strife" is not defined; most people think it refers to discord between Shylock and Jessica.

As to Shylock, we know that he speaks decently to Jessica. When he comes home and is out of sorts because he had a trying day with Antonio at the marketplace; he is losing his servant; he has to go out to dinner; and there is a Christian celebration in the street, he speaks calmly with her without showing any kind of temper toward her. Granted, he calls to her because she isn't immediately present, but this cannot constitute ill-natured yelling. He is snappish with his defecting servant, though.

A reasonable conclusion is that "this strife" is not strife between Jessica and Shylock but the strife any Jew is subjected to: given unequal status, restricted movement in society and continual disparagement and persecution. By this reading, "his manners" would refer to Shylock's devoted adherence to his ethnicity and his religion, both of which make him a Jew.

Their relationship is complicated even more because Jessica runs off with a Christian to begin living with the freedom of a Christian life-style, like spending 80 ducats in one spot in one night, and fashions herself a dowry. Recall that dowries were an integral part of a marriage contract until recent history; women were not welcomed in a marriage unless they could add something to the financial prospects of the couple. So Jessica steals what she believes her just dowry would be.

In summary, the father-daughter relationship between Shylock and Jessica seems to be sound on the person-to-person level but they part ways on the ideological level. Jessica doesn't want to remain a Jewish outcast whose life options are restricted and constrained, whereas Shylock clings devotedly to his religion and ethnicity and, therefore, to his position as an outcast. In fact, Shylock turns the tables and casts out the Christians. this is illustrated when he tells Jessica to protect his house and keep the sounds of the Christian celebration out of his house.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial