Historical Context
The historical backdrop of Carson McCullers' "The Member of the Wedding" is intricately woven into the narrative fabric of the novel. Set towards the conclusion of World War II, the novel provides subtle yet poignant references to the global conflict and its pervasive impact on everyday life. Within this context, McCullers explores the southern gothic tradition, drawing on themes of isolation and existential searching, elements that she skillfully integrates into the lives of her characters.
World War II Influence
"The Member of the Wedding" unfolds against a setting that hints at the tail end of World War II. McCullers does not provide exact dates, but through dialogues and reflections, she situates the story historically. For instance, Berenice mentions to Frankie that the French were driving the Germans out of Paris, an event which happened on August 25, 1944. Similarly, Frankie’s musings about the summer coincide with historical events, recalling how General Patton was "chasing the Germans across France," and battles were simultaneously occurring in Russia and Saipan. These references suggest that the story occurs during the summer of 1944.
Frankie's brother, Jarvis, is stationed in Alaska, a detail that roots the narrative in specific wartime events. In 1942, the Japanese occupation of the Aleutian Islands created a stir in American consciousness as it brought the war closer to home. This psychological victory for the Japanese was countered by the Americans in a prolonged battle that lasted until 1943. Jarvis and his bride's plans to go to Luxembourg also reflect the period's geopolitical climate. Luxembourg, under Nazi occupation, was liberated by the Allies in September 1944, and American forces were subsequently stationed there to maintain peace. These historical markers provide a backdrop that informs the characters’ interactions and worldviews.
Frankie's experiences with the military illustrate the pervasive presence of war. An army base near her hometown makes soldiers a common sight for her. McCullers writes that in town, Frankie "browsed the counters of the ten-cent store, or sat on the front row of the Palace show, or hung around her father’s store, or stood on street corners watching soldiers." Her fascination with these uniformed men underscores her youthful naiveté, a fascination that nearly leads her into trouble when she ventures into a soldier's room.
Southern Gothic Elements
Carson McCullers is renowned for her contributions to the southern gothic literary tradition, a style characterized by its settings in the American South and its focus on eccentric and ostracized characters. Unlike traditional gothic tales set in foreboding castles and dark landscapes, southern gothic stories like McCullers' employ similar thematic elements—such as isolation and confusion—in more familiar locales. In "The Member of the Wedding," these southern gothic features are present through Frankie's interactions and perceptions, notably her fascination with the "freak show," which aligns with the bizarre and outcast elements typical of the genre.
Despite the similarities with other southern gothic works, McCullers' approach is distinct. She imbues her narratives with a deep empathy for her misfit characters. Unlike other authors in the genre, who might focus on the grotesque aspects, McCullers portrays her characters with tenderness and an understanding of their spiritual loneliness. As she once mentioned, the theme of spiritual isolation is central to her novels—a hallmark of the southern gothic tradition that is evident in "The Member of the Wedding." This sensitivity sets her apart from her contemporaries like Tennessee Williams, Flannery O’Connor, and William Faulkner, whose works are similarly steeped in the challenges of southern life but often with a different lens.
Through the lens of World War II and the southern gothic tradition, "The Member of the Wedding" emerges...
(This entire section contains 644 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
as a rich tapestry of historical and cultural nuances. McCullers crafts a narrative that not only reflects the broader societal changes of the era but also delves into the complexities of personal identity and belonging, making her work a timeless exploration of human experience.
Style and Technique
Carson McCullers, in her novel The Member of the Wedding, masterfully employs literary techniques such as similes and symbolism to create a rich and evocative narrative. She captures the inner world of a young girl named Frankie, who is on the brink of adolescence, using vivid language and deep allegorical elements. These techniques not only enhance the text’s visual and emotional appeal but also deepen the reader's understanding of Frankie’s turbulent journey from childhood to an uncertain adulthood.
Imaginative Similes
McCullers’s narrative style is distinguished by her use of imaginative and unexpected similes. These comparisons are not merely stylistic flourishes; they are integral to capturing the perspective of Frankie, a twelve-year-old girl who is trying to make sense of her changing world. For instance, when Frankie thinks of her brother, who has been away for a long time, McCullers writes, “Frankie had not seen her brother for a long, long time, and his face had become masked and changing, like a face seen under water.” This simile effectively captures the idea of memory’s fluidity, as seen through Frankie’s eyes.
Frankie’s world is one of both exploration and confusion, and McCullers uses similes to reflect this. When Frankie observes the Fat Lady at a freak show, she notices the woman’s fat, which “was like loose-powdered dough which she kept slapping and working with her hands.” This image, drawn from Frankie’s domestic experience, is vivid and tactile, evoking a sense of both fascination and repulsion. The simile not only illustrates Frankie’s imaginative mind but also ties her observations to her known world, as evidenced by a subsequent scene where Berenice and John Henry work with biscuit dough.
Moreover, McCullers uses similes to convey the oppressive atmosphere in which Frankie finds herself. A sweltering afternoon is described as being “thick and sticky as hot syrup,” a comparison that not only conveys the physical discomfort of the heat but also symbolizes Frankie’s emotional state - a feeling of being trapped and overwhelmed. Similarly, when Frankie sees John Henry on his porch, the author writes, “John Henry was leaning against the banisters of his front porch, with a lighted window behind him, so that he looked like a little black paper doll on a piece of yellow paper.” This image underscores John Henry’s fragility and innocence, elements of childhood that Frankie is struggling to hold onto.
Rich Symbolism
Beyond similes, McCullers imbues The Member of the Wedding with rich symbolism that lends depth to Frankie's personal journey. The backdrop of World War II serves as a powerful allegory for Frankie’s inner conflict as she grapples with the transition from childhood to adulthood. In the novel’s opening, the depiction of war in her imagination is chaotic and overwhelming: "The world was cracked by the loud battles and turning a thousand miles a minute." This mirrors Frankie’s tumultuous emotions as she confronts the changes in her life.
Frankie’s fascination with the war, as described through her desire to donate blood, symbolizes her yearning to be part of something larger than herself. However, her understanding is immature; she does not grasp the true horrors of war. Her fascination with donating blood is more about her desire for connection and belonging in a world that feels increasingly alien to her. The war thus becomes a metaphor for her internal struggles, reflecting her fears and uncertainties about growing up and the pressures she feels from societal expectations.
Moreover, the characters surrounding Frankie symbolize different pathways and choices as she stands at the crossroads of her life. John Henry represents the innocence and simplicity of childhood that Frankie is reluctant to leave behind. Despite his youth, he is her playmate, embodying the past she both cherishes and feels pressured to abandon. In contrast, Berenice, the wise yet uneducated housekeeper, represents a more complex vision of womanhood. Her life, marked by hardship and resilience, both scares and inspires Frankie. Berenice’s unwavering optimism offers a beacon of hope and a possible direction for Frankie’s future, even as it underscores the challenges that lie ahead.
Through these literary techniques, McCullers crafts a moving and insightful portrayal of a young girl’s struggle to navigate the complexities of growing up. Similes vividly paint Frankie’s world, bringing her perceptions to life, while symbolism provides a profound commentary on her internal and external conflicts. Together, these techniques create a narrative that is both emotionally resonant and intellectually engaging, drawing readers into Frankie’s quest for identity and belonging.
Compare and Contrast
1942: In small towns, children entertain themselves by playing with friends and family members of similar ages. They frequently engage in outdoor activities such as softball, tag, and hide-and-seek. Other popular activities include performing skits, dressing up in funny costumes or adult clothing, exploring nearby trails, woods, or streams, and setting up lemonade or snow-cone stands to earn a bit of money.
Today: In both small towns and large cities, children and teenagers keep themselves entertained with television, videos, computers, video games, music, and books.
1942: Many middle-class white families employ African Americans for domestic work. Women often serve as housekeepers who also assist with raising children, becoming integral to the family dynamics. For many African-American women, like Berenice, this is the best employment opportunity available. Men are hired less frequently but might be paid for tasks such as home repairs, yard work, and chopping wood.
Today: Only the wealthiest families employ domestic servants, who can be of any race. While many people hire cleaning services, these relationships differ significantly from the live-in housekeeper arrangements of the past. African Americans have access to diverse job opportunities, and laws protect their rights to work in any field.
1942: Teenagers in small to medium-sized towns eagerly anticipate reaching an age where they can leave their hometowns to explore the broader world. Having grown up in communities where everyone knows each other, they are excited to meet new people and experience different things.
Today: Teenagers in small to medium-sized towns share the same feelings about their hometowns as those in the past. Modern media portray life beyond small-town boundaries as glamorous and thrilling, and the ability to connect with people worldwide through the Internet amplifies the urge to explore. Furthermore, larger cities often provide more opportunities for higher education, better career prospects, and higher salaries. Among teenagers, feeling bored and frustrated with their hometowns is often seen as sophisticated.
Setting
In the sultry expanse of a small, unnamed Georgia town lies the heart of Frankie Addams's world, a quintessentially southern setting that frames the transformative events of her youth. This town is more than just a backdrop; it is a character in its own right, shaping and reflecting the intricacies of Frankie's tumultuous transition from childhood to adolescence.
On a sweltering August weekend, Frankie wanders the familiar streets of her hometown, traversing spaces that mirror her internal journey. She visits her father's jewelry store, nestled just off the main street, a place that hints at stability but also underscores her feelings of confinement. Her journey takes her through Sugarville, the Black neighborhood where Berenice Sadie Brown, the Addams family's cook, resides. This area offers Frankie a glimpse into a world both distinct from and connected to her own. It is here she encounters the vibrant tapestry of human experience, a stark contrast to her own perceived limitations.
The Addams home on Grove Street stands as a testament to Frankie's life caught between two worlds. Inside this modest dwelling, the summer has been spent in the company of her young cousin, John Henry West, and Berenice. The kitchen, adorned with John Henry's drawings, serves as a stage for their card games and conversations—simple yet profound activities that echo Frankie's own uncertainties about growing up. Her sleeping-porch bedroom, intimate and stifling, encapsulates her sense of being trapped in childhood. With the novel's progression, change looms as Frankie's father decides to move the family to the town's outskirts, signaling a shift in her life's trajectory.
Winter Hill emerges as a potent symbol of Frankie's aspirations and the promise of adulthood. This is the site of her brother Jarvis's wedding to Janice Evans, an event that captures Frankie's yearning for liberation. In her eyes, the wedding represents a chance to escape her juvenile confines by joining the newlyweds on their honeymoon. However, this dream is cut short when her father intervenes, dragging her back to reality from the fantasy that Winter Hill represents. Much like the intense heat of her final childhood summer, Winter Hill embodies the allure and complexity of maturity, a tantalizing glimpse of what lies beyond the boundaries of her youth.
Media Adaptations
Encouraged by Tennessee Williams, McCullers transformed The Member of the Wedding into a stage play. It premiered on Broadway in 1950 and achieved great success, running for fourteen months with over five hundred performances. McCullers received several accolades for the play, including the New York Drama Critics Circle Award, the Donaldson Award for Best Drama of the Year, and the Gold Medal from the Theatre Club.
A film adaptation followed in 1952, produced by Columbia Pictures. This version secured a 1953 Academy Award nomination for Best Actress for Julie Harris, who portrayed Frankie. Additionally, Brandon de Wilde, who played John Henry, won a 1953 Special Golden Globe for Best Juvenile Actor.
The novel inspired two television movies. In 1982, it was performed on "NBC Live Theater," and in 1997, Hallmark Home Entertainment created a television movie featuring Anna Paquin as Frankie and Alfre Woodard as Berenice.
In 1987, DH Audio released an audio adaptation with Tammy Grimes as the narrator.
Bibliography and Further Reading
Sources
Brantley, Jennifer, “McCullers, (Lula) Carson,” in Feminist Writers,
St. James Press, 1996, pp. 319–20.
Dangerfield, George, Review, in Saturday Review of Literature, March 30, 1946.
Everson, Judith L., “Carson McCullers,” in Dictionary of Literary Biography Volume 173: American Novelists Since World War II, Gale Research, 1996, pp. 148–69.
Godden, Rumer, Review, in New York Herald Tribune Books, September 17, 1961.
Graver, Lawrence, “Carson McCullers,” in American Writers, Volume 2, Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1974.
Kapp, Isa, Review, in New York Times, March 24, 1946.
Kiernan, Robert F., “Carson McCullers,” in Concise Dictionary of American Literary Biography: The New Consciousness, 1941–1968, Gale Research, 1987, pp. 347–57.
McElroy, Lorie, “Carson McCullers,” in Authors and Artists for Young Adults, Vol. 21, The Gale Group, 1999, pp. 153–62.
Millichap, Joseph R., “McCullers, (Lula) Carson (Smith),” in St. James Guide to Young Adult Writers, St. James Press, 1999, pp. 565–67.
Moss, Joyce, and George Wilson, eds., “Carson McCullers: The Member of the Wedding,” in Literature and Its Times, Vol. 4, Gale Research, 1997.
Rubin, Louis D., Jr., “Carson McCullers: The Aesthetic of Pain,” in Virginia Quarterly Review, Vol. 53, No. 2, Spring 1977, pp. 265–83.
Torsney, Cheryl B., “Carson McCullers,” in Modern American Women Writers, Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1991.
Westling, Louise, “Carson McCullers’s Tomboys,” in Southern Humanities Review, Vol. 14, No. 4, Fall 1980, pp. 339–50.
Wilson, Edmund, Review, in New Yorker, March 30, 1946.
Further Reading
Andrews, William L., ed., The Literature of the American South: A Norton
Anthology, W. W. Norton & Co., 1997. Andrews compiles writings from
the American South spanning from the seventeenth century to today. This
collection includes poetry, sermons, short stories, songs, novel excerpts,
criticism, and non-fiction.
Carr, Virginia Spence, The Lonely Hunter: A Biography of Carson McCullers, Carroll & Graf, 1985. First released in 1975, this biography explores the tragic events and circumstances that shaped McCullers's life. Carr illustrates how these experiences influenced McCullers’s literary works.
McCullers, Carson, Collected Stories: Including “The Member of the Wedding” and “The Ballad of the Sad Cafe,” Houghton Mifflin, 1998. This volume contains McCullers’s shorter works, including the short novel The Member of the Wedding. Spanning over four hundred pages, this collection allows students of McCullers's writing to examine and compare the author’s creations.
O’Connor, Flannery, The Complete Stories, Noonday Press, 1996. Flannery O’Connor is a significant female writer in the southern literary tradition. While she wrote novels, she is renowned for her short stories, all compiled in this book.
Welty, Eudora, Collected Stories of Eudora Welty, Harcourt Brace, 1982. Eudora Welty is a prominent figure in the literature of the American South. She is primarily recognized for her short stories, and this collection provides a comprehensive introduction to her work.