Me Talk Pretty One Day

by David Sedaris

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Analysis of Literary Devices, Writing Style, Context, Purpose, Tone, Audience Connection, and Subject in "Me Talk Pretty One Day"

Summary:

David Sedaris's Me Talk Pretty One Day employs humor, irony, and self-deprecation as key literary devices. His conversational writing style engages readers, reflecting his experiences learning French. The context is his personal journey, aimed at a broad audience, with the purpose of entertaining and reflecting on language learning. The tone is humorous yet reflective, fostering a strong connection with readers through relatable struggles.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What literary devices are used in the essay "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

David Sedaris uses different literary devices throughout the opening piece in his essay collection Me Talk Pretty One Day. The literary device he employs most often and hilariously is the metaphor. By equating two literally different but theoretically analogous ideas or objects, Sedaris presents the absurdity of his French language class.

Upon meeting his younger, more fashionable classmates—many returning and already familiar with each other and the French language—Sedaris feels like “Pa Kettle trapped backstage at a fashion show.” Pa Kettle is a backward, hill-billy comic character who moves to a wildly incongruous modern house. Similarly, “fish-out-of-water” Sedaris fits into the classroom as well as Pa Kettle would blend in at a fashion show. “Fashion show” is an especially appropriate metaphor for the classroom since the school is located in Paris.

Sedaris and his classmates are thrown into the French immersion environment like babies tossed into water to learn how to swim:

it’s everybody into the language pool, sink or swim. The teacher marched in, deeply tanned from a recent vacation.

Provided no support, the students desperately try to stay afloat (or at least not drown) under the tutelage of the merciless teacher. The instructor just marches in and immediately starts speaking in French, seeming not to care if her students understand her (or drown). “Deeply tanned,” she is experienced, confident, intimidating, and weathered.

Sedaris also uses metaphors to poke fun at his fellow students’ appearance. One classmate named Anna has “front teeth the size of tombstones.” After being ridiculed by the teacher, Anna sheepishly moves her “rabbity mouth [and] huffed for breath.”

While Anna seems vulnerable and a bit comical with a buck-toothed, bunny-like appearance, the instructor is a hungry predator. As she questions and embarrasses more students, Sedaris portrays her as a ravenous lion:

The teacher licked her lips, revealing a hint of the saucebox we would later come to know. She crouched low for her attack.

She may be a “saucebox” or saucy, impudent person; nonetheless, actions like licking her lips and crouching “low for her attack” make her appear more like a feral cat ready to pounce on her next mouth-watering meal. This description foreshadows her later behavior:

We didn’t know it then, but the coming months would teach us what it was like to spend time in the presence of a wild animal, something completely unpredictable.

Another humorous metaphor is Sedaris’s comparison of the students persecuted people trying to escape from a tyrant. He finds a bit of solace in he and his classmates’ mutual “misery-loves-company” situation. One day,

huddled in the hallways and making the most of our pathetic French, my fellow students and I engaged in the sort of conversation commonly overhead in refugee camps.

The teacher has become a despot and the students are powerless victims who are unjustly mistreated and who try (but are not able) to flee the volatile situation in which they are trapped—her classroom. Instead, all they are able to do is commiserate and cluster in the hallway outside of her classroom; the hallway is their refuge or “camp.”

Interestingly, when Sedaris finally understands the teacher’s insult, he switches to the literary device of the simile. One day, the teacher snarls at him,

Every day spent with you is like having a cesarean section.

She compares her experience dealing with him to a major, grisly, painful, scarring, and often last-resort surgical procedure. Yet he rejoices because for the first time, he understands her. In some ways, a simile can be more clear than a metaphor; instead of meshing two disparate ideas or items together (or substituting one for the other) like a metaphor does, a simile states the connection between the two different ideas or items. Similarly, the French language and its meaning become more clear to Sedaris.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the writing style in "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

David Sedaris’s Me Talk Pretty One Day is a collection of essays which together tell the story of a part of Sedaris’s life—not necessarily a point in time, but a theme. The essays are written in a sarcastic, sardonic tone. Although everything that he writes is true from his viewpoint, the writing style makes it clear that we are reading one very specific point of view that perhaps another character or person in his life would not share. Sedaris has a sharp eye and a concise way of describing things. Although his stories are witty and tend to make his readers laugh out loud, there is something so true about each story that you can’t help but be surprised, entertained, and challenged (and even sometimes depressed) by what he writes. Part of the allure of a Sedaris story is the way in which he conveys ugly truths in an engaging way.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the context, author's purpose, style, and tone of "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

Sedaris writes in an understated but satiric tone while observing the people surrounding him, their conformity to social norms, and their attempts to force those norms upon others.

His purpose, from the opening of Me Talk Pretty One Day, is to show that authority figures have used indirect methods of stigmatizing otherness. Two episodes can be cited to illustrate this dynamic.

In the 1960s, speech class was a kind of mechanism by which children (although Sedaris mentions only boys in this context, girls were subjected to it as well) were singled out as different and, in some sense, deficient because of the way they talked. In Sedaris's school, Miss Samson, the speech teacher, is likened to an FBI agent making an arrest when she comes into the classroom and singles him out. Though his writing is wry and low-key, Sedaris's style uses metaphor and hyperbole to get his point across. The subtext of the episode is that boys who are suspected of being gay (or potentially so) are identified by lisping or some other alleged abnormality of speech.

These attempts to enforce conformity are contextualized in the outwardly benign milieu of a middle-class upbringing, typical of the time and yet alienating to someone such as Sedaris, who feels from an early point that he's different and is being singled out. His descriptions are ironic, since the people tasked with enforcing conformity have some aspect of otherness themselves. Miss Samson feels herself a failure as a speech teacher. The guitar teacher, Mister Mancini, is a little person. Sedaris witnesses a scene at the mall where Mancini is laughed at by some boys, yet when Sedaris behaves in what is considered an "inappropriate" way by singing a jingle from a TV commercial, Mancini himself upbraids Sedaris, telling him, "I'm not into that scene." Again, a behavior is being identified as characteristic of gay people without this being stated openly.

Two themes identifiable here are indirection and deflection. Criticism of boys who don't seem "normal" is done in a way that veils the actual reason for it. At the same time, some people who themselves are "different," such as Mancini, often try to deflect attention from themselves by criticizing others for allegedly non-conformist behavior, as Mancini does to the young Sedaris.

A small stylistic point, but a significant one, is that "Mister" is always written out for Mancini rather than given its usual abbreviated form. The effect is to further satirize an authority figure, a member of the establishment enforcing the conformity that was considered so vital at that time and unfortunately, in many quarters, still is.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the context, author's purpose, style, and tone of "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

David Sedaris describes himself in the first sentence of "Me Talk Pretty One Day" as returning to school at the age of forty-one. He clarifies this statement in the following paragraph by saying that he has moved to Paris to learn French and is taking classes at the Alliance Française. The context, therefore, is a school in a foreign country in which all the pupils are adults; but the author, as a beginner, has to some extent regressed to childhood. He recalls his time at school, but there is a sense in which he has regressed even farther back than this, since he is learning to speak.

Sedaris's purpose, apart from entertaining readers, is to explore and make them think about such issues as education, communication, and belonging. He also examines the power dynamics of the classroom, in which the teacher is a recognizable type: the sadist who uses students as target practice for her feeble attempts at sarcasm. The author's own lightly ironic tone becomes more waspish when he is pointing out the teacher's heavy-hand responses to her students' struggles to communicate. Much of the comedy in Sedaris's tone comes from the contrast between his elegant, whimsical use of the English language, and the broken attempts at French (translated into broken English, to create a greater contrast). As Sedaris shows, learning is largely dependent on memory, particularly for adults, and the essay makes the reader remember what it is like to learn a language, as well as conveying the message that humor and camaraderie can be found even in difficult experiences.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the context, author's purpose, style, and tone of "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

The context of “Me Talk Pretty One Day” relates to the fact that author David Sedaris has just moved to Paris with his boyfriend but has little prior knowledge of the French language. The essay relates to his difficulties in picking up the language and acclimatizing to a new home and culture.

His purpose is to convey the challenges and results of learning a new language. It emphasizes the importance of making the effort to learn the language if you move to a new place. He makes the point that being able to understand the basics of what someone is saying to you in a new language does not mean that you can now speak the language. Language, like everything else, is acquired in small steps.

The style and tone of this essay are humorous and self-deprecating, which makes Sedaris’s writing inviting to the reader. As an example, he compares himself to his young, attractive classmates by commenting that he feels “not unlike Pa Kettle trapped backstage after a fashion show.” One does not need to understand the cultural references of that phrase to have a chuckle at how out of place Sedaris clearly felt.

As to the question of what you have learned from this essay, your answer will be subjective. From my perspective, it is a lesson in the value of hard work. Sedaris began to become more comfortable with the language of his new home after he committed to working hard at mastering it.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the context, author's purpose, style, and tone of "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

In his essay “Me Talk Pretty One Day,” David Sedaris uses a humorous, and occasionally sarcastic, tone to describe his experience learning French in Paris. The context for this essay is that he had just moved to Paris with his boyfriend but needed to learn the native language. He mentions that he had taken French classes in New York before coming to Paris, but in France, the class is less competitive than in New York.

Sedaris seems to have a few purposes in this essay. One prominent thing he aims to do is underline the struggles and benefits of learning a new language. Consider how he ends the essay explaining that when he responded to the teacher, “the world opened up.” Here, we see that learning French gave him confidence and the ability to communicate with more people. However, his response to the teacher still used incorrect grammar. Sedaris thus ends by using his humorous tone and poking fun at the way learning a new skill comes with both joy and embarrassment.

You will of course have learned your own lessons from this essay, and there is no right or wrong answer to what you have learned. Yet someone reading this essay is likely prompted to reflect on the nature of new experiences. This simultaneous experience of embarrassment and progress is not necessarily limited to learning a new language. Consider how Sedaris’s tough relationship with the teacher motivated him to study four hours each night. The way his struggles motivated him could be a lesson to anyone considering learning a new skill.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does the author connect with the target audience in "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

There is a wide variety of potential audiences that David Sedaris might have been trying to reach. One aspect of the essay is that it is so engaging in its universal applicability. Everyone has had the experience of entering a new situation and having to adjust to it. Frequently this adjustment involves the use of language, whether it be a foreign language or verbal and nonverbal codes within one’s native language.

One of the main techniques that Sedaris uses is humor in order to emphasize the most common elements of the situation. The author’s humor is often derived from irony or sarcasm in the language; while he sometimes exaggerates (use of hyperbole), he often relies on understatement.

One nearly universal component of his experience is the classroom situation. Sedaris emphasizes how the students built solidarity through their opposition to the teacher, which was based in their shared belief in the teacher’s dislike—whether of each student as an individual or of students as a general category. Even though Sedaris initially felt misplaced in comparison to the other students, he formed a bond with them in defense of what they saw as the teacher’s aggressive behavior.

Sedaris also focuses on his individual experience to encourage the reader’s empathy, suggesting that he was the least popular, and possibly the least gifted, student.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does the author connect with the target audience in "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

In his humorous essay about learning to speak French, David Sedaris locates his experiences in a place familiar to most people: a classroom. Focusing the essay’s action in a classroom provides a connection that is meaningful for most people. Although most Americans have never lived in Paris as he did, Sedaris connects the specific situation of being an American in France with the larger question of being a newcomer in a strange place. David reveals that his reason for moving to France was personal in that he accompanied his partner, Hugh, whose work took him there.

Sedaris concentrates on his experience with other students in the French language class, which include getting used to a very demanding and critical teacher. Even though Sedaris is an adult and many readers will never have lived in a foreign country or learned a new language, most people have been in an uncomfortable class situation or encountered a difficult teacher. He presents his fellow students and himself sharing the burden of trying to learn in an atmosphere that is not conducive to learning.

From the beginning, Sedaris uses humor to establish a light tone but also to convey that the subject has a serious side. He adopts a self-deprecating attitude, showing that he sees his fellow students as cooler than he is by making fun of his own clothing. Humor is also derived from his interpretation of the language textbook, which is for children, as a symbol of his discomfort in the new situation.

The reader can empathize with his initial sensation of feeling different from the other students, in this case primarily because of age. The teacher’s harshness has a negative effect on Sedaris’s confidence in learning. This difficulty adds a serious element to the story, and is likely to stimulate readers’ memories of challenging material or instructors from their own schools. Similarly, the way that he bonds with other students in opposition to the teacher may well be part of the readers’ experiences.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the subject of "Me Talk Pretty One Day"?

The subject of David Sedaris's essay “Me Talk Pretty One Day” is the challenge of learning a second language. When Sedaris moves to Paris, his French is limited at best, and he worries about being able to communicate in his new home. Therefore, he begins a French language class and a series of struggles that he presents in a highly humorous way.

Sedaris's teacher is insulting and erratic, and she seems to take a special dislike to Sedaris. She criticizes all the students harshly but resents Sedaris's humor especially. Sedaris becomes more and more insecure about his French even though he and the other students try to console and help each other. In fact, these students must draw together even more against the abuse of their teacher, and they do not compete against each other.

One day, in the middle of a string of abuse from his teacher, Sedaris has a revelation. He understands everything she says. He still cannot speak French very well, but he has made enough progress to at least know what other people are saying in French. Sedaris experiences a strange joy and asks his teacher to keep on talking.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on