Summary and Analysis: Chapter 2
New Characters
Pontius Pilate: The fifth Roman procurator of Judea.
Mark Ratslayer: A Roman centurion.
Yeshua: A philosopher who has been arrested by the Romans for potentially causing unrest.
Matthew Levi: One of Yeshua’s followers.
Joseph Kaifa: The high priest of the Jews and president of the Sanhedrin.
Hooded Man (also known as “Aphranius”): A man who meets Pilate; he is later revealed as the head of the Roman secret police in Judea.
Summary
The professor continues his story, which begins with Pontius Pilate, the
procurator of Judea, sitting in the “colonnade between the two wings of the
palace of Herod the Great” early in the morning on the day before Passover. The
weary Pilate is hounded by the smell of rose oil and must confirm the death
sentence the accused man, Yeshua, faces. Two legionnaires bring in Yeshua, who
is about 27 years old and dressed in an old chiton. Pilate begins interrogating
Yeshua but, angered at being called “good man” by him, orders the centurion
Mark Ratslayer to teach Yeshua a lesson. Mark Ratslayer whips Yeshua and tells
him to call Pilate solely by the name “Hegemon.” Yeshua returns to Pilate and
tells Pilate his name and that he comes from Gamala, which is in the north of
Judea. Yeshua lacks a permanent home, does not know who his parents are, and
has no family. Despite Pilate’s accusations, Yeshua denies calling for the
temple building to be destroyed. He also says Matthew Levi, a former tax
collector, ascribes false statements to Yeshua in his writings on his goatskin
parchment. Nonetheless, Matthew Levi is Yeshua’s faithful companion.
The sick Pontius Pilate briefly longs for poison, then asks Yeshua, “What is truth?” Yeshua responds by saying the truth is that Pilate is sick and thinks of death, but he adds, “[Y]our suffering will soon be over.” Yeshua tells Pilate to get out of his palace and go for a walk with him. Pilate orders his hands to be unbound, and as their conversation proceeds, Yeshua denies he is a physician and proclaims, “[T]here are no evil people in the world.” Pilate concludes that Yeshua is mentally ill and, instead of being executed, will be put under confinement at Pilate’s residence in Stratonian Caesarea on the Mediterranean Sea. After reading a document on Yeshua, Pilate’s skin turns brown, his eyes sink, and he has a vision of Yeshua’s head being replaced by the head of the former Roman emperor Tiberius. Pilate quickly thinks “I’m lost!” and “We’re lost!” He recovers and, looking sharply at Yeshua, asks him if he has said anything against the great Caesar. In response, Yeshua says that he told Judas of Kiriath, just before being arrested, that “all authority is violence over people,” and when the kingdom of truth and justice comes, authority will disappear.
An outraged Pilate confirms Yeshua’s death sentence. He orders two centuries of Roman soldiers to transport Yeshua, as well as two other condemned men, to Bald Mountain to be executed. They leave, and Pilate meets with the high priest of the Jews, Joseph Kaifa, and informs Kaifa of Yeshua’s confirmed death sentence. However, he gives Kaifa the option of releasing Yeshua or another prisoner, Bar-Rabban, in honor of the Passover feast. Kaifa says Bar-Rabban will be released. Kaifa and Pilate then dispute Kaifa’s decision and debate the general relations between Romans and Jews. They manage to reconcile though, and Pilate goes up to a platform to tell a crowd of Jews that Bar-Rabban is being released. The three condemned men are taken toward Bald Mountain and, at around 10 A.M., Pilate heads...
(This entire section contains 879 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
toward the gates that lead into the palace garden.
Analysis
The story of Yeshua and Pilate in Yershalaim, although clearly derived from the
Gospel accounts of Jesus’s life, departs from the Gospels in many ways,
especially in the long focus on Pilate. His weariness, agony, and authority
contrast with Yeshua’s humbleness, plain speech, and gentleness. Pilate’s
conversation with Yeshua is punctuated by Pilate’s vision of Tiberius’ sickly
head and a sense of being lost and living an agonizing immortality. Pilate’s
change after this vision is expressed in his vow to punish Yeshua with death
and his denial that “the kingdom of truth will come.” Pilate has chosen power
over truth, and after dismissing Yeshua he enters into negotiations of power
with Kaifa. Pilate proclaims to the public, in a theatrical show of power
disguised as mercy, that Bar-Rabban, not Yeshua, will be spared execution.
Nonetheless, Pilate is afraid up until the time the condemned men are removed
from his sight, and when his sense of anguish recurs, he is overwhelmed by
impotence. Pilate’s royal powers have done nothing to allay his weariness and
fear of death. He is trapped, and rather than prolong his talk with Yeshua, who
might have led him out of his trap, he has condemned Yeshua. Yeshua had pointed
out that his own hair did not come from Pilate, and Pilate responded by
threatening that he “can cut that hair”; in the same spirit, Pilate rejects the
arrival of the kingdom of truth and calls out “Criminal!” to his staff in a
weak voice “cracked with commanding.”