The novel is set in Scotland during a period of rebellion and violence, making it beneficial to explore the history of the two uprisings, particularly the one in 1745. Modern readers might be surprised to discover how many people of that era supported the Stuart cause and believed in its eventual success. Such a historical investigation can also shed light on the confusion and unpredictability of the time, which Stevenson attempts to organize in his narrative.

1. Considering the family dynamics, does the conflict between the Durie brothers appear believable? Is it plausible for one brother to turn so drastically against the other?

2. Is Alison Graeme's character developed enough to justify the intense feelings the brothers have for her?

3. Does Secundra Dass contribute anything beyond his obvious role in the plot? For instance, does his presence enhance any tonal aspects of the story?

4. Are James Durie's piratical actions, particularly those involving Captain Teach (whom Mackellar clarifies is not the infamous Blackbeard), truly pertinent to the storyline, or are they simply amusing distractions? Do they shed any light on Durie's character?

5. Douglas Gifford supports Stevenson's use of Mackellar as a narrative device, countering critics who consider it weak. Do you believe this perspective is justified?

6. Does the Scottish setting come across as detailed enough to convey the somber atmosphere Stevenson intended? What more could have been done, considering some scholars argue there is a lack of detailed description?

7. Do you feel any sympathy for James Durie, given his choice to fight for a cause he deemed just and the significant hardships he endures?

8. Which element of the text stands out as the most remarkable: themes, plot, setting, characterization, or style? Do these components integrate effectively throughout the novel?