Marvin Bell

Start Free Trial

Analysis

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The dominant themes and motivations of Marvin Bell’s poetry perhaps can be best understood by hearing him speak of his own work. Discussing his personal aesthetic, he told Wayne Dodd and Stanley Plumly in an Ohio Review interview,I would like to write poetry which finds salvation in the physical world and the here and now and which defines the soul, if you will, in terms of emotional depth, and that emotional depth in terms of the physical world and the world of human relationships.

Indeed, Bell is a poet of the family and the relationships within. He writes of his father, his wives, his sons, and himself in a dynamic interaction of love and loss, accomplishment, and fear of alienation. These are subjects that demand maturity and constant evaluation. Bell’s oeuvre highlights his ability to understand the durability of the human heart. As a son of a Jew who immigrated from Ukraine, Bell writes of distance and reconciliation between people, often touching on his complex relationship to his heritage.

While concern with the self and its relationships provides a focal point in Bell’s early poetry, many of his poems have crystallized around a reflection on the self in relation to nature, evident in collections such as Stars Which See, Stars Which Do Not See. Growing up among farmers, Bell has always felt nature to be an integral part of his life. The rural life that so fascinated other writers during the 1960’s back-to-nature movement was not Bell’s inspiration. Rather, nature forms a critical backdrop for events and relationships in his life, and in that sense, he says, “I am interested in allowing nature to have the place in my poems that it always had in my life.”

Bell further notes thatcontemporary American poetry has been tiresome in its discovery of the individual self, over and over and over, and its discovery of emotions that, indeed, we all have: loneliness, fear, despair, ennui. . . . I think it can get tiresome when the discovery of such emotions is more or less all the content there is to a poem. I think, as I may not always have thought, that the only way out of the self is to concentrate on others and on things outside the self.

Thus, Bell has evolved his ability to perceive and praise small wonders in a quiet and reserved fashion and, as one critic noted, “has found within his own voice that American voice, and with it the ability to write convincingly about the smallest details of a personal history.”

A Probable Volume of Dreams

“An Afterword to My Father,” which ironically begins A Probable Volume of Dreams, is a fairly typical early Bell poem. The “probable” part of the book’s title and the placement of an “afterword” at the beginning of a poem reflect Bell’s characteristic ambiguity and uncertainty.

     Not so much “enough,”     there is more to be done,     yes, and to be done with.     You were the sun and moon.     Now darkness loves me;     the lights come on.

Here Bell uses cliches, an allusion (“done”) to Donne, and metaphors (father as sun and moon). What remains to be “done” must also be “done with,” moved beyond. The father, a recurrent image in Bell’s poems, was the poet’s source of light; the darkness that follows the father’s death now provides light, but what is illumined is not stated, nor is it necessarily positive.

Escape into You

Escape into You chronicles the breaking up of a marriage and a poet’s gradual coming to terms not only with a wife and sons but...

(This entire section contains 1503 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

also with himself. As Arthur Oberg puts it, the poems describe “a poetic self that is still learning to bury the dead and to walk among the living.” “Homage to the Runner,” also the title of a column Bell wrote, is about running, one of Bell’s athletic outlets, but also about poetry and how poetry affects others. Running and poetry both involve “pain,” and “the love of form is a black occasion/ through which some light must show/ in a hundred years of commitment.” While there is “some light,” the occasion is “black.” The runner and poet “ache” to end the race and poem, which begin in darkness, but there “is no finish; you can stop [running or writing] for no one,” not even family, as much as you care for them.

Residue of Song

Residue of Song contains thirteen poems to Bell’s father and concerns loneliness. “Residue of Song” begins by stating that “you were writing a long poem, yes,/ about marriage, called ’On Loneliness.’” Like the “probable” in his A Probable Volume of Dreams, the “residue” also undercuts its subject matter. In fact, in “Residue of Dreams” “you” decide not to write the poem. In Bell’s poem it is the speaker who is the lonely one as he describes a woman’s egotism and violence and his callous responses to her; but, as is usually the case with Bell, the poem ends in bittersweet acceptance of the “residue” in a relationship:

 Your cries, for ecstatic madness, are not sadder than some things. From the residue of song, I have barely said my love  again, as if for the last time, believing that you will leave me.

The use of “barely” and “as if” is part of Bell’s tendency to qualify, to undercut, and to leave meaning implied but not defined.

Stars Which See, Stars Which Do Not See

Stars Which See, Stars Which Do Not See contains poems about Dorothy, Bell’s wife, but also includes several poems about poetry. In his “To a Solitary Reader,” an allusion to William Wordsworth’s poem about the solitary reaper, Bell discusses the development of his poetry: “If once he slept with Donne/ (happily) now he sleeps/ with Williams/ the old Williams.” Bell thereby indicates his movement from John Donne’s metaphysical style to William Carlos Williams’s stress on a poem being, rather than meaning. The remainder of the poem distinguishes between “memory,” which is what we “are” in the sense that “they/ think they know us,” and what our “being” is, that which is inexplicable, without meaning. The poem concludes, “Time’s determinant./ Once I knew you.” Bell leaves behind certainty and memory and instead embraces the idea that nothing can be “known.”

These Green-Going-to-Yellow

In the title poem of These Green-Going-to Yellow the poet states, “I’m raising the emotional ante” by attempting to align himself with nature, particularly the leaves of a gingko tree someone planted in New York City. The poem concerns people’s perspectives on life and asks if they really see beauty. Of course, the answer is “no.” People look down “not to look up” and “look at the middles of things.” Comfortable with mediocrity, like the seasons, people go from green to yellow, age like autumn, and lose their creative powers. Bell declares that people’s perspective would be different “if we truly thought that we were gods.” This line denies people even an erroneous presumption about their place in the universe, but in his acceptance of the situation Bell somehow remains “green.” He has said, “I started out green and I intended to remain so.”

The Book of the Dead Man and Ardor

In the Dead Man poems in The Book of the Dead Man and Ardor, Bell moves in a new direction, adopting a persona or mask that he often denies but on at least one occasion accepts: “He was my particular and my universal./ I leave it to the future to say why.” The Dead Man has enabled Bell to erase distinctions such as the one between life and death. In “About the Dead Man” the poet writes, “He [the Dead Man] thinks himself alive because he has no future.” Statements like this, especially when they are preceded by and followed by other seemingly unrelated statements, would appear to be incredibly complicated, but Bell asserts that they are complex, rather than complicated. Complexity, for him, is “the fabric of life and the character of emotion.” In his poetry things “connect,” even if the connections are not always apparent to the reader.

The “Baby Hamlet” poem in this section embodies Bell’s ideas about complexity, which requires “a fusion of many elements, some of them seemingly disparate, even contradictory.” Hamlet’s indecision is fused with the world’s indecision, its “hopeless pacifism” and the “Platonic ideal carried to its logical inconclusion.” According to Bell, “It doesn’t seem a stretch to me to parallel Hamlet’s indecision with the world’s reluctance to act early and decisively against the Nazis.” After all, “events occur while waiting for the news./ Or stuck in moral neutral.”

Loading...