Critical Evaluation

Download PDF Print Page Citation Share Link

Last Updated on May 6, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 878

It was with Manhattan Transfer, his third published novel, that John Dos Passos made his first experiments in attempting in a novel to depict an entire society, that of a city that for him embodied the best and worst of American culture. The techniques he began using in this work came to fruition in the trilogy entitled U.S.A. (1937). Both Manhattan Transfer and U.S.A. use the same stripped, staccato style in their narrative passages, and the earlier work foreshadows the later trilogy in its rapid, abrupt shifts among a large and varied cast of characters. The speed of modern life is reflected not only in the style but also in those shifts, and the vividly colorful imagery adds to the effect.

Illustration of PDF document

Download Manhattan Transfer Study Guide

Subscribe Now

Manhattan Transfer also prefigures U.S.A. in telling the stories of many characters while lacking a central plot. Such characters as Ellen Thatcher, Jimmy Herf, and George Baldwin receive more attention than others, but the novel can hardly be said to have a main protagonist. In fact, the central character is New York City. When Jimmy Herf escapes the clutches of the city at the end, he presumably saves his soul by heading for the hinterlands, but he leaves behind forever the city that made his life worth living.

Like other novels that intend to portray entire societies, Manhattan Transfer contains characters from many different economic and social levels (although it reflects the time of its creation in failing to include any African Americans among its major figures). The family that adopts Jimmy Herf is distinctly rich and upper class, and Herf’s uncle, Jeff Merivale, and other members of that family are very disappointed when as a young man he adopts the profession of newspaper reporter, a line of work much less prestigious than banking or law. It is even worse that Jimmy socializes with theater people and such “riffraff” and with Joe Harland, whom the Merivales no longer acknowledge as a relation.

In the story of Gus and Nellie McNiel, Dos Passos focuses attention on the laboring class and the political life of the city. The railroad accident that the lawyer George Baldwin turns into a modest fortune for Gus enables the onetime milkman to become a minor elected official and to set himself up as a friend of working men and women. Joe O’Keefe, the union organizer, provides another point of view on the struggles between labor and management.

The strongest thread holding the novel together is the story of Ellen Thatcher. Her birth is the focus of the early part of the novel, and her romances and marriages link such diverse characters as Jimmy Herf, the wealthy theatrical backer Harry Goldweiser, her first husband John Oglethorpe, and the lawyer George Baldwin. In his portrayal of Ellen and her activities, Dos Passos is also able to show the realities of the supposedly glamorous world of the theater. When after a series of ill-fated marriages and romances Ellen marries Jimmy Herf in Europe and returns to this country with him and their baby, Dos Passos is able to repudiate the conventional fictional happy ending. For this marriage is no more successful than the preceding ones, and when Jimmy leaves for the hinterlands, he leaves behind his wife and child as well as his career.

Another important aspect of...

(The entire section contains 878 words.)

Unlock This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this Manhattan Transfer study guide. You'll get access to all of the Manhattan Transfer content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

  • Summary
  • Themes
  • Characters
  • Critical Essays
  • Analysis
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial