Manette Salomon

by Edmond de Goncourt, Jules de Goncourt

Start Free Trial

Critical Overview

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Set against the vibrant backdrop of mid-19th century Paris, Manette Salomon offers a vivid exploration of the dynamic and often tumultuous world of artists. Written by the brothers Edmond and Jules de Goncourt, the novel draws heavily from their personal experiences both as critics and practitioners within the art scene. Through a diverse cast of characters, they examine the contrasting forces that shape an artist's life, delving into themes of creativity, personal ambition, and societal influence.

The Artistic Archetypes

The Goncourts embed their narrative with a rich tapestry of artist archetypes, each embodying distinct aspects of the artistic persona. Langibout, an elder statesman of the art world, represents the traditionalist approach, being a product of officially sponsored schools. He stands in stark contrast to the fledgling artists he mentors, his stature casting a long shadow over their burgeoning careers. Garnotelle, on the other hand, serves as a satirical portrayal of the academic artist, whose formulaic approach to art stems from his modest origins and lack of formal training. Although he finds success as a portraitist in fashionable society, his arrogance and pretension are palpable.

In Anatole Bazoche, the Goncourts capture the quintessential dreamer, an artist more enamored with the idea of artistic life than the discipline it demands. His ambitious attempt to create a grand allegory of democracy and progress results in a disastrous tableau, dominated by a misplaced figure of Christ. Ultimately, Anatole’s journey leads him to abandon both art and the bohemian lifestyle, following the death of his playful alter ego, a monkey named Vermilion, and seek solace in a more stable existence as an assistant zookeeper.

By contrast, Crescent epitomizes the successful artist who balances talent and personal stability, untainted by the corrupting influences of civilization. His supportive wife manages their domestic affairs, allowing him to focus on his craft without the burden of familial responsibilities. Unlike Manette, Crescent’s wife aids rather than hinders his artistic journey, highlighting a harmonious integration of personal and artistic aspirations—a theme that resonates with the Goncourts’ advocacy for celibacy as the ideal state for an artist.

Coriolis: The Tormented Protagonist

At the heart of Manette Salomon lies the figure of Coriolis, whose internal struggle between personal desire and artistic ambition drives the narrative. Possessing genuine talent and an immense capacity for hard work, Coriolis embarks on a quest for artistic purity. His travels across the Continent lead him to a novel painting technique reminiscent of Impressionism, emphasizing natural observation and the interplay of light and color over intellectual abstraction. In Coriolis’s quest for absolute beauty, the Goncourts encapsulate the emotional intensity and urgency inherent in the artistic endeavor.

The introduction of Manette Salomon marks a turning point in Coriolis’s life, as she initially appears as the embodiment of beauty and muse-like inspiration. However, their relationship quickly devolves, with Manette’s transformation into a wife and mother revealing a different, more materialistic side that ultimately derails Coriolis’s artistic vision. As Manette pursues financial gain and social status, Coriolis’s creative spirit diminishes, illustrating the Goncourts’ theme of a woman’s maternal impulse clashing with, and eventually overpowering, man’s artistic drive.

The Illusion of Beauty and the Nature of Art

The narrative arc of Manette Salomon presents a poignant exploration of artistic creation, juxtaposing the pursuit of eternal beauty with the fickle nature of popular taste. As Coriolis’s story unfolds, the Goncourts delve into the tension between reality and illusion, both in personal identity and artistic expression. They suggest that while true beauty exists, it is often obscured by ephemeral trends and societal expectations, rendering any definitive explanation of beauty as illusory.

The disintegration of Coriolis’s...

(This entire section contains 834 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

personal and artistic life culminates in a powerful depiction of existential despair, rife with motifs of decline and fragmentation. The novel’s closing scenes are dominated by images of winter and nightfall, reflecting Coriolis’s longing for escape from a world that no longer holds promise or solace. Through this portrayal, the Goncourts underscore the tragic nature of the artist’s endeavor to capture the ideal—a pursuit fraught with insurmountable challenges.

Literary Techniques and Cultural Context

The Goncourts’ fusion of literature and painting is evident in their narrative style, which mirrors Impressionist techniques through its nuanced attention to tonal variation and detail. Manette Salomon vividly captures the zeitgeist of mid-19th century Paris, portraying the artistic rivalry between the line-focused "Ingrists" and the colorists. As advocates for anti-academic art, the brothers celebrate a return to naturalism, positioning their characters within the broader context of artistic movements and societal changes.

While the novel’s caricatures of Jewish characters and its critique of women’s influence over men reflect the prejudices of its time, its enduring value lies in its detailed depiction of the artistic landscape and the individual’s struggle to transcend mundane reality through pure art. In blending humor, satire, and acute social observation, the Goncourts craft a compelling narrative that resonates with the complexities of artistic life and creation.

Previous

Characters

Loading...