Ideas for Group Discussions
In William Shatner's Man O' War, tension erupts as a revolutionary substance known as "smush" fuels disputes between the Martian colonists who harvest it and the Earthlings who rely on it.
Duel of Faces
1. Benton Hawkes exhibits a dual nature: the composed diplomat seen in public and the complex character revealed to readers. Delve into the contrasts between these two faces of our protagonist. Is this duality both credible and captivating?
The Essence of Smush
2. What is "smush" exactly? Envision this new dietary staple by describing its appearance, growth pattern, life cycle, methods of processing, and flavor.
Labor Struggles: Earth vs. Mars
3. The birth of labor unions in the United States was fraught with challenges, akin to the struggles depicted on Mars in Man O' War. Investigate some foundational facts about the IWW (International Workers of the World—the "Wobblies") and draw parallels to the fictional labor disputes on Mars.
Space Pirates: A Futuristic Menace
4. Chapters 12 through 14 describe daring space pirate attacks on a Mars-bound shuttle. What would be necessary for these outlaws to thrive within the novel’s context, and what does this imply about the broader future?
Heroes and Villains
5. Analyze the rivalry between Benton Hawkes and Michael Carri. What criteria determine the hero from the rogue in this scenario?
A Startling Introduction
6. The novel opens with a chilling scene where a resistance group is obliterated beneath the Martian surface. How does this scene's intensity stack up against similar portrayals of violence in science fiction cinema?
The Role of Dina Martel
7. Evaluate Dina Martel as a romantic figure. Does she embody the fierce modern heroine like Ripley from the "Alien" saga, or is she more of a conventional nurturing presence, or perhaps a blend of both?
Environmental Entanglements
8. Investigate how Earth's ecological issues are linked to the labor negotiations on Mars. Does the inception of a Martian embassy present a potential conflict for Benton Hawkes?
Symbolism of Meat
9. Examine how consuming meat serves as a metaphor or symbol within Man O' War.
Pioneering New Worlds
10. What qualities must one possess to become a colonist of distant worlds? Consider the personal traits and social skills required, along with the anticipated advantages.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.