The Man with the Golden Arm

by Nelson Algren

Start Free Trial

Literary Techniques

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Algren's most enduring technique is rooted in the tradition of classic realistic fiction, vividly portraying the gritty details of slum life. His narratives include scenes of drug deals, card games, boxing matches, and other settings that embody a world of winners and losers. These include the dimly lit barroom of the Tug & Maul, the grimy tenement shared by Frankie, Zosh, Molly O, Violet, and Old Husband, Nifty Louie's hideout where Frankie gets "fixed," the police station in front of Captain Bednar's desk, the jail where Frankie serves time for theft, and the ever-present streets, alleys, and doorsteps of Chicago.

Equally significant is Algren's remarkable talent for dialogue, capturing a specific style of speech—quick wit, storytelling, and scams—exemplified by Frankie's constant chatter while dealing cards. Algren constructs his own mythology of urban life, complete with heroic figures, slang, sayings, and folk wisdom. Most striking, however, is Algren's distinctive humor, which is subtle and understated, reveling in wordplay like "moral warpitude" and twists on formal language, particularly legal jargon, that mock conventional euphemisms. Beyond the humor in his language, Algren crafts situations that are comically absurd, such as the love triangle involving Violet, Old Husband, and Sparrow; Sparrow's kidnapping of Rumdum, the beer-drinking mascot; and the theft of a bag of underwear that lands Frankie in jail.

Beneath the comedic themes lie darker, tragic elements, such as the murder of Nifty Louie; the decayed, subhuman figure of Blind Pig, who ends up with Louie's money and his job as a pusher; and the defeated, hopeless existence of Molly Novotny, along with lives consumed by destruction and self-destruction. Familiar imagery, like the El train twisting its steel girders across the city, serves as an apt metaphor for human life, rushing forward but going nowhere, mirroring the ups and downs of merry-go-rounds, roller coasters, the highs of addiction, and the agony of withdrawal. This realistic detail is juxtaposed with a romantic lyricism, an elegiac tone used by the narrator to celebrate fleeting moments of joy and humanity and to convey the pathos experienced by the characters, even if they rarely acknowledge it.

Social Concerns

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In this novel set against the backdrop of Chicago street life, the Midwestern city serves as a symbol for the American experience, embodying a system where individuals must choose between being victims or victimizing others. Algren paints a picture of alienation, exploitation, and degradation experienced by marginalized people, delving into the well-known naturalistic themes of fate versus choice, struggle versus defeat, and success versus failure. However, unlike the common narratives of Social Darwinism and the Protestant Ethic often found in popular literature, Algren's depiction celebrates those who fail, trapped in the uniquely American cycle of success and failure. This cycle represents the "special American guilt" of owning nothing "in a land where ownership and virtue are one." His critique of the Horatio Alger myth, which suggests that anyone can succeed through determination, hard work, and a bit of luck, pushes the conversation further by blending classic American realism with the allure of irreverent humor, captivating comic and dramatic characters, and vibrant low-life settings.

Algren's depiction of a white ethnic ghetto highlights the clash between vulnerable, displaced traditional communities and an indifferent, dehumanized system of social control. His Midwestern landscape connects American readers with their immigrant heritage and the experiences of "outsiders" in WASP culture, particularly the Eastern European and Mediterranean immigrants whose inner lives remain foreign in a nation focused on the work ethic and wary of introspection. Michael Novak refers to these individuals as the "silent people" or "white ethnics." For Algren, a third-generation descendant of Jewish, Swedish,...

(This entire section contains 652 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

and German immigrants, ethnicity means not fitting into the social machine, being marginalized, alienated, and exploited, detached from the mainstream, and stripped of power and identity.

The criminal underworld, a longstanding theme in American popular fiction, is depicted here with a depth that transcends the typical good-versus-evil narrative, highlighting social issues rooted in societal structures. "The Man with the Golden Arm" is perhaps most infamous for bringing a detailed, graphic portrayal of drug use to American readers. Frankie Machine, burdened by a "thirty-five pound monkey" on his back—a term coined by Algren to describe his morphine addiction stemming from a war injury—illustrates how Frankie is victimized both by society, represented by Nifty Louie the pusher, and by himself, as his addiction brings fleeting happiness and heightens the guilt that dominates his life.

Drugs also serve as a fitting metaphor for mid-20th century commercial capitalism, with Louie creating and fulfilling the demand for his products. Urban dwellers, no longer functioning as workers or producers, become unemployed consumers, driven by advertising, commercialism, and consumer culture through the "rutted tunnels that lead between the advertising agency and the bank." Algren's hustlers, reflecting respectable businessmen, engage in the same practices of sales, commodities, and consumption.

Algren's portrayal of what he termed the "usurpation of man over man" is made more intricate by his examination of the mutual victimization and exploitation present in gender relationships. While his settings of barrooms, boxing arenas, racetracks, and prisons are distinctly male-dominated, women serve to ease the constant rivalry and one-upmanship among men. Men and women come together not out of passion, but to fulfill a shared need for warmth and care—needs that the outside world either denies or exploits. Simultaneously, Algren is among the writers who delve deeply into the issues of sexual violence, with the battered woman being a recurring figure in his narratives, and the sexual exploitation inherent in prostitution.

Algren's focus on the downtrodden persists in his pervasive depiction of the total victimization of individuals by society, exemplified by the police, criminals, and the prison system. This system serves as a mechanism for the ultimate form of human degradation: capital punishment. The prison scenes in "The Man with the Golden Arm" are part of a broader depiction of those convicted in Southern prison farms, small-town jails, and on death row, making a compelling case for the dignity of human life that capital punishment denies.

Literary Precedents

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Algren undeniably belongs to the realm of traditional literary realism, alongside figures like Theodore Dreiser and Stephen Crane. However, he is most closely associated with Walt Whitman, who embraced a democratic vision that included both the "conquered and slain" as well as the victors, and Carl Sandburg, known as the poet of Chicago. Algren's comedic style, ironic wit, and his approach to dialogue and portrayal of marginalized characters also link him to Mark Twain and the Midwestern stories of riverboat fighters, eye-gouging wrestlers, con artists, and gamblers. Exploring the European roots of his realism and urban settings reveals influences from Villon, Zola, and Baudelaire. Philosophically, Algren echoes Jean-Paul Sartre's No Exit (1944), especially in depicting human relationships where individuals simultaneously consume and desire to be consumed, striving for connection with others while seeking independence.

Algren pioneered the vivid portrayal of city life found in novels like William S. Burroughs's Naked Lunch (1959). His work also shares a connection with nonfiction writers who documented the urban working class, such as Mike Royko and Studs Terkel.

Setting

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Set in a gritty, turbulent neighborhood of Chicago, "The Man with the Golden Arm" immerses readers in a world dominated by vice and desperation. The narrative revolves around Francis Majcinek, known as Frankie Machine, who navigates the perilous streets of this community. The settings within the novel serve as both literal and metaphorical prisons, reflecting the inescapable cycles of addiction and guilt that entrap its characters.

Division Street

Division Street forms the heart of the novel's setting, a violent and crime-infested area of Chicago where illegal activities are a part of daily life. Drugs, alcohol, gambling, and theft permeate the fabric of this community. It is here that Frankie Machine, the protagonist, earns his moniker "the man with the golden arm" due to his adeptness as a card dealer at Club Safari, a notorious gambling den. The inspiration for Division Street comes from Chicago’s real Wabansia Street, reflecting author Nelson Algren's firsthand experiences in a similarly gritty environment.

Club Safari

Club Safari is more than just a nightclub; it is a microcosm of Division Street's moral decay. Within its walls, Frankie deals cards in clandestine games, while Nifty Louie dispenses drugs to the local addicts, ensuring their dependency grows. For Frankie, the club is simultaneously a source of income and the anchor of his addiction, drawing him deeper into a life he cannot escape. This duality underscores the entrapment faced by many in the neighborhood, where livelihood and vice are inextricably linked.

Division Arms Hotel

The Division Arms Hotel serves as Frankie's residence, a place characterized by emotional and physical confinement. He shares this space with his wife, Sophie, who manipulates him through deceit and guilt. Her psychosomatic ailments and false claims of disability bind Frankie in a marriage built on manipulation, with Sophie tightening the emotional "knot" to ensure his continued captivity. This setting represents a personal prison, where relationships are fraught with tension and deception.

Tug and Maul Bar

The Tug and Maul Bar is aptly described as a zoolike establishment where the neighborhood’s most colorful, and often unsavory, characters gather. Among its patrons is Blind Pig, or Piggy-O, a particularly odious figure who embodies the raw, animalistic nature of the environment. This bar serves as a social hub for exchanging local news and gossip, yet it also highlights the bestial instincts that prevail among its clientele.

Jail

Jail becomes an ironic sanctuary for Frankie, offering a reprieve from the relentless grip of Division Street's influences. Within its "iron sanctuary," Frankie momentarily escapes the demands of his addiction, though at the cost of his freedom. The jail's confines, marked as "deadlock" cells, symbolize both physical and psychological entrapment, as time itself feels stalled with clocks permanently reading twelve o'clock. This stasis mirrors Frankie's ongoing struggle against his dependency.

After his release, Frankie attempts to resist returning to drugs, but the pressures are insurmountable. With police investigator Record Head Bednar suspecting him of Louie's murder, Frankie's freedom is tenuous. Bednar’s manipulations, using Piggy-O to incriminate Frankie and his friend Sparrow on a drug charge, demonstrate the inescapable net tightening around him. Despite his brief freedom, Frankie is ultimately betrayed by Sparrow's coerced confession, signifying the futility of their resistance in the face of systemic oppression.

The relentless pursuit by authorities and betrayal by those he trusts culminates in Frankie's tragic demise. Fleeing from the law, he finds solace in the loyal Molly but ultimately succumbs to his fate. In a final act of despair, Frankie is wounded by a symbolic strike to the heel—a nod to the mythical Achilles—before taking his own life. His suffocation signifies the ultimate enclosure and entrapment, drawing a poignant close to a tale of perpetual struggle against insurmountable odds.

Adaptations

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"The Man with the Golden Arm" became a sensational box office success in 1950. Its notoriety was heightened by initially being denied approval by the Production Code due to its depiction of drug use and related paraphernalia. Directed by Otto Preminger and produced for United Artists, the film received negative reviews. Nelson Algren, the author, believed the movie misused his story's rights and served mainly as a platform for its lead actor, Frank Sinatra, who portrayed Frankie Machine. Due to financial constraints, Algren had to abandon his lawsuit, ultimately receiving just $15,000 for the film rights.

Janet Polansky

Previous

Critical Essays

Loading...