Discussion Topic

Barbara's rebellion against traditional feminine roles in Major Barbara

Summary:

Barbara's rebellion against traditional feminine roles in Major Barbara is evident in her rejection of a conventional domestic life. Instead of conforming to societal expectations of women, she dedicates herself to the Salvation Army, focusing on social and moral reform. Barbara's actions challenge the norms and highlight her commitment to her personal beliefs and independence.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Barbara rebel against traditional feminine roles in Major Barbara?

Barbara in this excellent play rebels in lots of ways against the traditional feminine roles imposed on her and against the class that she has been born into. Note how she is born into an upper class family. However, she dismisses her servant and lives very simply as part of being a member of the Salvation Army. Note too the way that she is put in contact with people that she would never have met if she hadn't left her family and social upbringing. The taciturn and stubborn Bill Walker is a classic example of the kind of potentially dangerous individual from the working class that Barbara is now putting herself in daily contact with. It is in this renunciation of the benefits available to her both as a woman and as a member of the upper class that constitute her rebellion, as she works among the poor and seeks to save their souls, rejecting the materialism and "evil" as she sees it of her father's work. Of course, the play represents her development as a character, chiefly focussing on her understanding of how the boundary lines between "good" and "evil" are often blurred.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The very title “Major Barbara” provides clues that Barbara is not a typical young woman. G. B. Shaw identifies her with a highly masculine, military leadership role and then reveals that her office is not actually military but in the realm of social service—an army that saves souls. Elite young women at the turn of the last century were expected to remain in the home, and while charitable works were acceptable, they were expected to be done through appropriate channels.

Barbara’s family has different expectations of her ideal role than the course she is following. Lady Britomart, her mother, travels in elite society, and her father, Mr. Undershaft, is a weapons manufacturer. Although Barbara is attached to a young man, Cusins, she spends her days with other men—and men who are far below her in social class, thus jeopardizing her reputation and future social status. She even rejects women’s proper clothing: when donning a ladylike outfit, “Do you think I can be happy in this vulgar silly dress? I! who have worn the uniform,” she exclaims.

Shaw was hyper-aware of the importance of money in British society, so he presents Barbara as rebelling through her initial determination to reject money itself as well as what she believes it stands for. Undershaft is Shaw’s mouthpiece for hard questions about upper-class reformers’ motivations. To Undershaft, “money is my religion.” Barbara’s devout actions position her as almost nun-like in her rejection of convention: “I escaped from the world into a paradise of enthusiasm and prayer and soul saving.” Ultimately, however noble her ambitions, they are inconsistent with expected social roles for young women of the time.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Major Barbara’s rebellion must be seen not only in light of the construction of the “new woman” as a rebellion against gender but also as a class rebellion.

The Salvation Army would have struck audiences of the period as an odd choice for an upper middle class girl, as dissent (in its sense as Protestantism not part of the Church of England) and evangelical religion were more associated with the lower middle classes. On the other hand, the Salvation  Army was among the first organizations in Britain (and first Christian organizations in the world) to have absolute gender equality through all its ranks. Thus in joining it, she enables herself to exist within a society far more equal than the wider one of her period.

Her independence and association with lower class men (unchaperoned) were also radical for her period,.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

References

Approved by eNotes Editorial