Themes: Trust and Deceit
The dialogue between Malcolm and Macduff in act 4, scene 3 is rather long and is often cut in performance. Read in full, however, the conversation is a masterly study in the initial manoeuvers between two men, each of whom has every reason not to trust the other. Malcolm tells a plethora of outrageous lies to see how Macduff will react and only begins to trust his fellow countryman after observing Macduff’s genuine horror and despair at the appalling picture the prince paints of his own character.
Malcolm has had to learn deceit quickly. When their father Duncan is murdered, Malcolm and Donalbain both realize that one of the thanes around them is likely guilty of the murder, and that they are both in grave danger. They will either be accused of the crime (which is what, in fact, happens) or they will be killed next. There is no one around them whom they can trust, and their only option is to flee. Lady Macduff, abandoned by her husband, is in a similar predicament, except that she has nowhere to go.
The straightforward, trusting nature of such characters as Duncan, Lady Macduff, and Banquo marks them out as victims in a play filled with duplicity. Lady Macbeth is continually urging her husband to be more deceitful, a lesson he seems to have learned quite thoroughly by the end of the play. Even in the midst of his own deceit and treachery, however, Macbeth continues to believe in the witches—despite all obvious clues that they are malicious figures—because he wants to believe what they have told him. It is only immediately before his death that he realizes how they have deceived him. The irony here is that the witches are one of the few characters in the play that are exactly what they seem: hideous and evil. The noble Banquo recognizes this and immediately treats them with contempt. It is only because Macbeth is already somewhat corrupt, even upon his first appearance in the play, that he is willing to place his trust in such obviously malign figures.
Expert Q&A
What does "there's daggers in men's smiles" mean in Macbeth?
In Act 2, Scene 3 of Shakespeare's Macbeth, the phrase "there's daggers in men's smiles" is used by Donalbain to suggest that their father's killer could be hiding behind a friendly facade. The phrase implies that even those who seem friendly and trustworthy can harbor harmful intentions. This realization prompts Donalbain and his brother Malcolm to flee Scotland, fearing they might be next in line for assassination.
In Macbeth, what do the old man and Ross discuss, and what theme is revealed?
In Shakespeare's Macbeth, Ross and the old man discuss the unsettling events in nature that have occurred since King Duncan's murder. These unusual occurrences, such as the falcon being killed by an owl and the king's horses turning wild, reflect the unnatural act of murder committed by Macbeth. This conversation underscores the play's theme of the disruptive nature of evil, emphasizing how such an unnatural act can disturb the natural world.
What does the following quotation from Macbeth mean: "The eye wink at the hand yet let that be. Which the eye fears when it is done, to see."
In the mentioned quote from Macbeth, Macbeth expresses his desire for his evil intentions to remain hidden, even from himself. Upon learning Malcolm is to succeed King Duncan, Macbeth decides to take whatever steps necessary to become king. He wishes his eye not to see his hand's actions, acknowledging the potential regret over his future deeds. Yet, he seeks success in his dark ambition.
Are there any quotes about trust in Macbeth?
Several quotes in Macbeth relate to trust. Macbeth's trust in the witches is evident in act 1, scene 3, when he says, "Stay, you imperfect speakers, tell me more," and in act 3, scene 4, when he states, "More shall they speak, for now I am bent to know." Additionally, Malcolm tests Macduff's trustworthiness in act 4, scene 3, ultimately declaring, "Macduff, this noble passion... hath from my soul Wiped the black scruples."
What is ironic about Duncan and Banquo's speeches approaching Macbeth's castle?
The irony in Duncan and Banquo's speeches as they approach Macbeth's castle lies in their description of it as a welcoming and pleasant place, using words like "sweet," "loved," and "delicate." In reality, the castle is dangerous, as Duncan will soon be murdered there by Macbeth. This contrast highlights the theme that appearances can be deceiving.
How does the porter's statement about drink being an equivocator relate to Macbeth's situation?
The porter's statement about drink being an equivocator relates to Macbeth's situation by illustrating how equivocation misleads and deceives. Just as alcohol provokes desire but hinders performance, Macbeth misleads others by concealing his true intentions. He falsely blames King Duncan's sons for murder and pretends friendship with Banquo while plotting his death. Macbeth's increasing desperation for power leads him to become a shameless equivocator, manipulating others to maintain his rule.
Deception in Macbeth
In Shakespeare's Macbeth, the theme of deception is central, exemplified by the line "False face must hide what the false heart doth know." This reflects the contrast between appearance and reality, beginning with the witches' paradox "Fair is foul, and foul is fair." Lady Macbeth advises Macbeth to appear innocent while hiding deadly intentions, a strategy they both employ to murder King Duncan. Deception continues as Macbeth feigns loyalty while plotting further murders, ultimately leading to his downfall when the witches' prophecies are revealed as misleading.
What roles do the witches in Macbeth play in relation to Coleridge’s remark that they can tempt the tempters?
The three witches in Macbeth serve to advise the audience of upcoming events through their prophecy, set an ominous tone for the drama, and tempt the protagonist to fulfill his evil ambitions. Coleridge suggests that the witches have no direct power over Macbeth and are only able to tempt him to murder because of his inherently evil character.
Appearance vs. Reality in Macbeth
In Shakespeare's Macbeth, the theme of appearance versus reality is encapsulated in Lady Macbeth's advice to "look like the innocent flower, but be the serpent under it." This means to appear innocent while hiding malicious intent, a strategy she urges Macbeth to adopt to deceive King Duncan during his visit. The Macbeths' castle, seemingly welcoming, is actually a site of betrayal and murder. This theme highlights the deceptive nature of appearances, as seen in Duncan's misplaced trust, leading to his downfall.
Exploring Loyalty and Betrayal in Macbeth
Loyalty and betrayal are central themes in Macbeth. Macbeth's betrayal of King Duncan, motivated by ambition and spurred by Lady Macbeth, contrasts with the loyalty shown by characters like Banquo and Macduff. This dichotomy highlights the destructive consequences of betrayal and the moral integrity of those who remain loyal, ultimately leading to Macbeth's downfall.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
Themes: The Corrupting Effects of Ambition
Themes: Supernatural Intervention in Human Affairs
