Discussion Topic
Crafting a monologue for the doctor in Macbeth
Summary:
To craft a monologue for the doctor in Macbeth, focus on his observations of Lady Macbeth's sleepwalking and guilt. Highlight his internal conflict over witnessing her mental deterioration and his helplessness to cure her. Emphasize the themes of guilt, mental anguish, and the limits of medical knowledge in the face of psychological torment.
What is a monologue in Macbeth?
Macbeth delivers a dramatic monologue at the end of act 2, scene 1, just as he is about to go through with the murder of King Duncan, Macbeth's own relative, friend, and guest. In this monologue, Macbeth actually hallucinates a dagger, clean at first, which then turns bloody, foreshadowing the way in which he plans to commit regicide. The speech shows the extent of the stress this action puts on Macbeth: it isn't easy for him, and he feels guilty. Even he recognizes that the hallucination seems to be the effect of his "heat-oppressed brain" (2.1.51). In the end, he resolves to stick to the plan, and he leaves the stage to murder the king.
Another dramatic monologue is delivered by Macbeth in the middle of act 3, scene 1, just after he has said goodbye to his (former) best friend and comrade-in-arms, Banquo , who plans to...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
travel away from the palace for the day. In this speech, Macbeth reveals his motives for getting rid of Banquo, how he fears Banquo's "royalty of nature," his "dauntless[ness]," and "wisdom" (3.1.54, 57, 58). Finally, Macbeth reveals the thing that makes him the most angry: that the Weird Sisters said Banquo would father kings. Macbeth feels that it is Banquo's fault, then, that his own crown will be "fruitless" and "barren," that he will not pass his throne on to his own children, and most importantly, that his heinous actions will only serve to benefit Banquo's issue rather than his own (3.1.66, 67).
Macbeth contains several monologues throughout the five acts of the play. The first significant monologue by Macbeth occurs in Act One, scene seven and begins with "If it were done, when 'tis done, then 'twere well" (1). Macbeth begins his lengthy speech inside the castle, as he debates the possibility of murdering King Duncan.
This soliloquy is an important moment in Act One, because it reveals Macbeth's inner turmoil and indecision; he knows that the assassination would be a simple matter if he could only be sure that the act would not result in a chain of terrible consequences. In the end of the soliloquy, Macbeth concludes that his biggest motive for the murder would be his own ambition.
How can you write a monologue for the doctor in Shakespeare's Macbeth?
In addition to what other contributors have already stated, I would further suggest that, if you are asked to write a monologue for the doctor, you think carefully in terms of the larger context in which this monologue would be set. At what point, within the course of this play, would this monologue take place, and, within that context, what would we expect to be on the doctor's mind at this point in time?
Even in the doctor's case (minor character though he is), within the context of that fictional world, we must assume he has a larger character arc of his own (even if we see only a very small portion of it). Thus, if you write a monologue which would precede the events of act 5, scene 1, before he has witnessed Lady Macbeth's madness, he would have a very different perspective than were it to be set after that point. Likewise, if the monologue was set during the height of the battle between Macbeth's forces and Malcolm's, you would have to expect his mindset would be very different.
First, by this point, he would have witnessed Lady Macbeth's madness, and thus, he would have gained an awareness of Dunsinane's dark history. Moreover, at this point he would also be in a situation of very real uncertainty, both as far as it relates Scotland's future but also with potential danger to himself. Finally, if you were to set this monologue immediately after the battle had been won and order had been restored—or in a still more distant future, with the doctor recollecting on this past history from a point of far greater distance—that too would imply a very different context and would need to be written accordingly.
To conclude, it might be worth keeping in mind that monologues have a dramatic component to them and are inevitably impacted by the events and context which would surround them at any particular point within the course of the play.
If you were to write a monologue from the doctor's perspective, it would be vital to include his most important insights. These insights come when he first observes Lady Macbeth to be sleepwalking in Act 5, Scene 1. He has come at the request of her gentlewoman who has seen her repeating the same disturbing motions and the same disturbing words for many nights now.
Having heard Lady Macbeth ask, "who would have thought the old man / to have so much in him?" and "The Thane of Fife had a wife. Where is / she now? What, will these hands ne'er be clean?" he realizes that her "heart is sorely charged" (5.1.41-42, 44-45, 56-57). It does not take a doctor to gather that Lady Macbeth has some terrible weight on her conscience; her gentlewoman has already ascertained as much. The doctor realizes that "This disease is beyond [his] practice" (5.1.62). In other words, he knows that Lady Macbeth does not require a physician, as it is not a physical ailment from which she suffers; she could make better use of a priest because her trouble is clearly spiritual. Moreover, the doctor says that "Unnatural deeds / do breed unnatural troubles. Infected minds / to their deaf pillows will discharge their secrets" (5.1.75-77). He recognizes that the only thing that could have distressed her so greatly is something that goes strongly against her conscience because people who are disturbed by these kinds of troubles will always talk in their sleep. Any monologue of the doctor's should absolutely make reference to all of these revelations.