Discussion Topic

The conflict and relationship between Marie and Sister Leopolda in Love Medicine


The conflict between Marie and Sister Leopolda in Love Medicine centers on power and control. Marie resents Sister Leopolda's harsh, abusive treatment and strives to assert her own strength and identity. Their relationship is marked by a struggle for dominance, with Marie ultimately seeking to transcend the Sister's oppressive influence and reclaim her sense of self-worth.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the conflict between Marie and Sister Leopolda in chapter 2 of Love Medicine?

Sister Leopolda is a bullying nun with a strong sense of Satan's presence. Marie gets into conflict with her during Sunday School and decides she wants to win against her, so she becomes a novice at the Sacred Heart convent where Sister Leopolda lives. She decides that if she can get to heaven first, she can keep Sister Leopolda out.

At the convent, the conflict between Sister Leopolda and Marie escalates. When Marie is retrieving a cup from under the stove, Sister Leopolda pours boiling water on her to free her from Satan. Sister Leopolda tries to rub balm on the burns, but Marie fights her and tries to push her in the oven. Sister Leopolda then stabs Marie with a fork and knocks her unconscious with a poker as the two vie for dominance.

Marie wins this battle. To cover up her abuse, Sister Leopolda passes off the fork stab wound in Marie's hand as a miraculous appearance of stigmata from heaven. The nuns are awed and view Marie as a saintly or godlike figure.

However, though Marie wins the fight to dominate her rival, she learns to feel pity for Sister Leopolda.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Chapter 2 of Love Medicine, what is Marie's relationship with Sister Leopolda?

In Louise Erdrich's novel, Love Medicine, Sister Leopolda and Marie have an unhealthy relationship: Sister Leopolda sees Marie as a soul the Devil craves, and she is physically and emotionally abusive toward Marie based on this assumption. Marie, who also believes the Devil wants her, as Sister clearly tells her, believes the only way to be victorious over Sister Leopolda is to beat her to Heaven.

As the story begins, Marie is in Sister's class. There is an incident there (Marie believes the Dark One is in the closet, and smiles); somehow Sister knows, and Marie ends up locked in the closet. This is when Marie decides how best to beat Sister. She and Sister have a discussion, and literally, Sister tells Marie that she has two choices: she can marry an Indian, give birth to his "brats" and "die like a dog," or she can "give herself to God."

However, in a more subversive way (based upon how Marie reacts to her words), Sister tells Marie she can have the Devil or love.

'He wants you,' she said. 'That's the difference. I give you love.'

Marie thinks to herself:

Love. The black hook. The spear singing through the mind. I saw that she had traced the Dark One to my heart and flushed him out into the open. So now my heart was an empty nest where she could lurk...Well, I was weak.

Marie stays at the convent for a several years. The battle between Sister and Marie rages. Eventually, however, Marie is able to place doubt in Sister's mind and heart. Sister is a crusader against "the Dark One." She fights the battle everyday, though the other sisters have long since doing so.

At one point, Sister pours  boiling water from the stove top onto Marie's back to drive the Devil out of her. Marie does not utter a sound, and strangely, when it is done, Marie tells Sister how hard she prayed, and Sister responds, saying, "My dear one, I know." Sister, with a twisted sense of "love," puts a salve on the girl's back, but Marie has finally had enough. She knows she must leave before she is completely broken. She yells at Sister,

'He was always in you,' I said. 'Even more than in me. He wanted you even more. And now he's got you. Get thee behind me!'

...[Sister Leopolda] was pretending nothing happened. But for the first time I had gotten through some chink she'd left in her darkness. Touched some doubt.

It is in this way that Marie plants a seed of doubt in Sister. Sister pushes Marie on, insisting that she help while Sister takes bread out of the oven. Enraged, Marie tries to shove Sister into the oven. Sister is saved at the last minute by the fork and poker she holds. With these, she stabs Marie in the hand, and knocks her in the head, into unconsciousness.

When Marie awakes, Sister has told the other nuns that Marie has the sign of the stigmata (wound of Christ at his crucifixion) on her, and all are surrounding Marie in prayer. Marie realizes that Sister has told the story to protect herself.

Marie knows she has won. And she is ready to make Sister pay. However, she looks at the beaten nun, aware of her personal "wrongness," "kneeling within the shambles of her love." Marie knows that there will be no girls abused by Sister Leopolda from this point on. Rather than collecting the debt she had planned to acquire for years of abuse, Marie can only see Sister with pity in her heart, and know now that she can leave.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on