Ideas for Group Discussions
The idea of dinosaurs existing today fascinates people of all ages. These ancient creatures, some of which grew to massive sizes, once roamed the entire planet, including its oceans. Looking back, The Lost World can be seen as a pioneer of stories about prehistoric creatures inhabiting the modern world. Conan Doyle's core concept was that a region cut off from the rest of the world might have escaped the evolutionary changes that led to species extinction through natural selection. The Amazonian jungles were even less explored in the early 20th century than they are now, a time when large parts of the globe were still uncharted. In this mysterious jungle, Conan Doyle envisioned a grand mesa uplifted during the age of dinosaurs, remaining almost completely isolated for millions of years.
Though the story is imaginative, it was crafted before Conan Doyle's shift to spiritualism; at that time, he was a rationalist who greatly valued scientific thought. One reason the novel succeeds is likely because of Conan Doyle's deep respect for scientific research. The satire of foolish, quarrelsome, and back-stabbing scientists might not be as effective if Conan Doyle did not believe that science was crucial enough that the misconduct of scientists could hinder human progress. Additionally, his ideas about evolution and his symbolic depictions of advanced species replacing primitive ones might not hold as well if he did not accept natural selection as a scientific truth.
When discussing The Lost World, readers can explore the novel from multiple perspectives, each enhancing their understanding and enjoyment of the story. One enjoyable approach is to embrace the book's humor. It is intended to be funny, parodying a genre of literature for young readers known as "boys' books," which had become absurd with its exaggerated tales of violence and adventure. How many layers of humor exist in the book? Observe the slapstick violence, the witty dialogue, the mockery of self-importance, and the satire of unwise scientific practices. How deep is this humor? What does it reveal about Conan Doyle's intentions?
Another way to analyze The Lost World is by considering it a book of ideas. H. G. Wells had already shown that there was a significant audience eager for compelling stories that explored intriguing concepts. By the time The Lost World was released, readers had journeyed with Wells and Verne, among others, to distant futures, the moon, and enigmatic regions of the earth's uncharted areas; they had even encountered hostile extraterrestrials. In these early science fiction tales, the focus was often on ideas rather than characters and plot. For instance, Wells's The Time Machine (1895) delves into the concept of time as a fourth dimension. In The Lost World, Conan Doyle explores themes of evolution, the scientific method, and society's treatment of science and scientists. How relevant are his ideas today? Are his views on evolution outdated? Do any of his critiques or observations still resonate in modern life?
Another effective approach to discussing the novel is to compare it with more recent dinosaur stories. Edgar Rice Burroughs's The Land That Time Forgot (1924), which includes the short novels "The Land That Time Forgot," "The People That Time Forgot," and "Out of Time's Abyss," serves as an excellent comparison. Burroughs also speculates on evolution and employs his own symbolism to illustrate the development of new species. Which book aligns more closely with contemporary scientific perspectives on evolution? Which one better addresses the logical challenges of scientific thought? A lighter approach could involve discussing which book features the best depictions of prehistoric animals, the most thrilling scenarios, or the most engaging characters....
(This entire section contains 1123 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
Which novel better integrates its characters into the setting? This comparative method can be applied to many dinosaur-themed fictional works. EvenJurassic Park (1990) is a suitable candidate. It similarly isolates dinosaurs from the rest of the world, includes scientists who are in over their heads, and offers suspenseful action with colossal creatures from another era, some of which pose threats to humans. How does Crichton's scientific justification for the presence of dinosaurs in the modern world compare to Conan Doyle's? Are there any shared character archetypes between the novels? For dinosaur enthusiasts, The Lost World provides ample material for hours of discussion on favorite tales of dinosaurs existing in the present day.
1. Is Challenger a commendable figure? Would you want scientists to emulate his behavior?
2. Conan Doyle was fond of practical jokes. One of his favorite pranks involved dressing up as Challenger, complete with a fake beard, and surprising his friends with unannounced visits, fully immersing himself in the character. The Lost World includes photographs of Conan Doyle and his friends dressed as characters from the novel. How convincing is Conan Doyle's disguise? Does his apparent fondness for the character shed light on any events in the story?
3. Today's society is more sensitive to the portrayal of ethnic groups compared to the era in which Conan Doyle lived. How accurate are his depictions of the Indians? Are there elements in his portrayal of Indians or other characters, like the ape-men, that might be considered objectionable?
4. What are the most compelling ideas presented in the novel? What makes these ideas intriguing? Are any of them provocative or controversial?
5. What is the most humorous moment in the novel?
6. At the beginning of the novel, Conan Doyle faces the challenge of getting his young protagonist from England to South America. What techniques does he use to accomplish this? What are your thoughts on the use of the map as a plot device? Does it feel awkward or seamless?
7. How well are the prehistoric creatures described in the novel? Which ones are particularly vivid, and which ones are too vague?
8. In today's world, the Earth has been extensively mapped, with satellites providing even more detailed information, such as uncovering ancient riverbeds beneath the Sahara. If The Lost World were to be written today, where would it need to be set? What changes would be necessary to accommodate modern cartography? Use your imagination to answer these questions, just as Conan Doyle did when he navigated the limitations of his own time and audience. There are solutions to these questions! Have fun exploring them!
9. Many readers have favorite dinosaur stories. Poll your group to see if enough members have read such tales, and if so, have them share their favorite novels or short stories featuring dinosaurs. How does The Lost World compare to these other works?
10. The Lost World contains both pointed satire and broad humor. Which element is more emphasized in the novel, the satire or the comedy? What does Conan Doyle seem to want his readers to take away from the novel—a sense of the absurd aspects of science and scientists, or simply the enjoyment of a rollicking good time?
