Religious Themes
The Lord of the Rings stands as a fascinating example of Christian literature, despite containing no explicit mentions of Christianity or religion at large. Both critics and J.R.R. Tolkien himself have emphasized its Christian essence, with Tolkien noting that its Catholic character was initially unconscious but became intentional during revisions. Set in a pre-Christian era, the narrative avoids Christian anachronisms and juxtaposes pagan references with universal spiritual truths.
Christian and Pagan Harmony
Tolkien's approach echoes that of his favorite Old English writer, the Beowulf poet, who addressed the integration of Christian and pagan elements in his work. While some critics deemed Beowulf a discordant blend of these ideas, Tolkien argued in his essay "Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics" that the Christian poet recognized the resonance between heroic, pagan legends and Christian ideals. Rather than directly commenting on this tension, Tolkien showcased shared virtues spanning both cultures in his characters, allowing them to naturally embody these traits without overt narration.
Virtues in Contrast
A prime illustration of these virtues appears in the contrasting characters of Denethor, steward of Gondor, and Théoden, king of Rohan. Denethor, who succumbs to despair and succumbs to suicide, reflects a stark lack of hope, a virtue valued in both Christian theology and Germanic paganism. Meanwhile, Théoden embraces the hopelessness of battle to demonstrate his unwavering courage. Surpassing both men, Samwise Gamgee embodies a transcendent hope as he realizes through song that despite Sauron's darkness, the sun persists unseen. This moment encapsulates what Christian theology calls grace and Tolkien referred to as "eucatastrophe," a sudden turn towards joy.
A Sacramental View of Nature
Tolkien's work also showcases a "sacramental" view of nature, an idea particularly resonant with Catholic theology. Unlike traditions that perceive the physical world as a spiritual hindrance, Tolkien saw nature as elevating the spirit. Nature in his narrative acts similarly to sacraments, serving as a tangible reality pointing towards an unseen spiritual truth. This view permeates the narrative, enriching the story's spiritual dimensions.
The Clarity of Good Versus Evil
Perhaps most evidently reflective of Tolkien's faith is the stark division between good and evil in The Lord of the Rings, a common target for criticism. Critics like Edwin Muir and Edmund Wilson contended that a twentieth-century audience demanded a more nuanced moral perspective, one filled with gray areas rather than clear dichotomies. However, the widespread appeal of Tolkien's work suggests a deep resonance with readers, who embrace the clear moral vision he offers.
Through its allegorical depth and spiritual themes, The Lord of the Rings presents a compelling narrative that, while devoid of direct religious references, profoundly engages with Christian ideals. By exploring universal virtues and moral clarity, Tolkien's epic transcends its temporal setting, offering insights that resonate with both religious and secular audiences alike.
The Ring: Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely
In the 1880s, Lord Acton famously remarked, "Power Corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely." When Sam implores Galadriel, saying, "I think my master was right. I wish you'd take his ring. You'd put things to rights. You'd make some folk pay for their dirty work," Galadriel responds, "I would—That is how it would begin, but it would not stop at that, alas!" Although many earlier thinkers might have concurred, such a stark and definitive perspective on the inherent dangers of power could only arise as humanity gained the ability to not only control but potentially destroy themselves and the entire planet. The Ring represents the desire for power, existing solely for domination. It corrupts, creating a rift between the wearer and their true essence, as well as with everyone else, no matter how beloved. Tolkien...
(This entire section contains 155 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
illustrates this corruption through the language of addiction, where everything is sacrificed to the insatiable thirst for the Ring/Power.
Providence
Early in Lord of the Rings, Gandalf attempts to explain the Ring to Frodo by saying: "It was the strangest event in the entire history of the Ring so far: Bilbo's arrival, just at that time, and putting his hand on it, blindly, in the dark...There was more than one power at work...The Ring was trying to get back to its master. When its master was awake once more and sending out his dark thought...Behind that, there was something else at work, beyond any design of the Ring-maker. I can put it no plainer than by saying that Bilbo was meant to find the Ring and not its maker." Critics often point out the lack of explicit religious elements or references to God in Lord of the Rings. However, a sense of providence permeates the story—a benevolent force guiding events and individual choices, both positive and (ironically) negative, to lead to the Ring's destruction and Sauron's defeat. This providence doesn’t guarantee a perfect ending, as it relies on the actions of the speaking peoples, leaving them to face the repercussions of their decisions, yet it does not abandon them. Elves, men, dwarves, Ents, and Hobbits must take action, but providence ensures their efforts are not in vain. The victory of good may not restore everything that was lost or preserve all that was saved. However, it does prevent a far greater, unimaginable evil.
Mercy and Pity
In Lord of the Rings, pity encompasses understanding, compassion, and a moral obligation to alleviate suffering rather than cause it. It is closely connected to empathy, differing from the contemporary view of pity, which frequently includes a touch of scorn. Acts of mercy, motivated by compassionate pity, are integral to the overarching divine plan. Characters such as Bilbo, Frodo, and Sam repeatedly spare Gollum out of pity. Ultimately, this act of mercy does not save Gollum, who remains trapped by evil, but instead saves those who have extended mercy to him.
Death and Deathlessness
Although many readers and critics concentrate on the notion of power's complete corruption, Tolkien himself remarked that Lord of the Rings primarily explores themes of mortality and immortality. This focus often surprises even the most attentive readers of the series, yet it becomes more evident when considering the broader history of Middle Earth. The recurring theme is the contrast between the nearly immortal elves and mortal beings such as men, dwarves, and hobbits. Sauron's initial temptation of men preys on their fear of the unknown and jealousy of the elves' eternal life. The pursuit of immortality leads to the ruin of Númenor, the island kingdom in the western sea, and an obsession with death and lineage results in the sparse population of Minas Tirith. Tolkien describes death as a "gift," suggesting it is a natural passage from the world to the presence of its creator. This theme's importance becomes clearer in Tolkien's broader works, especially in the Silmarillion and The Book of Lost Tales. Middle Earth's landscape is often portrayed in terms of loss, change, and decay, highlighting the world's fleeting nature. The contrast between the immortal, unchanging elves and the transient world accentuates their ambiguous and uncertain position, alluding to the "long defeat" mentioned by Galadriel.
Moral Absolutes
Tolkien frequently faces criticism for his portrayal of events in stark black-and-white terms. Yet, as the trilogy unfolds, it becomes clear that while moral absolutes lay the groundwork for actions, they do not enforce rigid, unchanging behaviors. These absolutes act as benchmarks for characters as they deliberate over various 'right actions.' Both Merry and Pippin swear oaths of loyalty but intentionally break them to pursue a greater good. As Rosebury observed, "it is precisely these kinds of departure from a facile and predictable structuring of ethical action which exemplify the work's moral subtlety and openness to contingency." Tolkien depicts his characters as having moral imperfections and intellectual limitations. Even Gandalf is portrayed with a deep sense of human flaw. Tolkien's most wise characters retain their wisdom by balancing their limited knowledge. Frodo demonstrates this when he quotes the saying, "Go not to the elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes." The elf Gildor replies, "Elves seldom give unguarded advice for advice is a dangerous gift, even from the wise to the wise, and all courses may run ill."
Confronting the Power of Evil
The central theme of The Lord of the Rings highlights the necessity of confronting the power of evil. Tolkien demonstrates that nobody is immune to its influence. Everyone, regardless of their strength, is susceptible to corruption. Throughout the tale, characters who have been steadfast defenders of good in Middle-earth succumb to corruption—Saruman, Boromir, and Theoden. Even Gandalf, arguably the most virtuous and powerful member of the fellowship, refuses to take the ring, fearing it would corrupt him. Frodo also comes alarmingly close to disaster and is ultimately rescued from failure by an external force. Gollum, who consistently acts with malevolent intent throughout the book, inadvertently (or perhaps providentially) saves the day by biting off Frodo's ring finger and falling into the Cracks of Doom with it. Gollum's actions and their beneficial outcome can be seen as either a stroke of luck or divine intervention; Tolkien does not provide a clear explanation of his purpose. Regardless, the reader must come to terms with the fact that Frodo, despite his remarkable heroism—making him one of the most heroic figures in modern literature—could not ultimately resist the corrupting influence of true evil. In the end, it did corrupt him.