Alienation and Loneliness
The Tyrone family is fractured, with each member feeling some degree of disconnection from the others. The most pronounced rift is between Tyrone and Jamie, where bitterness eclipses any lingering affection or respect. Jamie holds his father responsible for Mary's morphine dependency due to his perceived stinginess, while Tyrone struggles to forgive what he views as his son's fall into immorality. Their interactions are hardly cordial, and both are aware that their meetings often lead to habitual accusations, prompting them to avoid each other, especially when alcohol strips away their veneer of politeness.
Jamie also harbors a more nuanced and conflicted alienation towards Edmund. He confesses that he partly resents Edmund, driven by jealousy and an irrational association between Edmund's survival and their mother's dire circumstances.
Mary is the most isolated and estranged member of the family. Her struggle with addiction is deeply solitary, often beyond the others' understanding or empathy. She often speaks of her isolation, attributing much of it to Tyrone, blaming his acting career for their unsettled lifestyle. Under the influence of morphine, Mary escapes into an idealized past, distancing herself from the pain of her current reality.
Deception
At the beginning of the play, characters wear metaphorical masks to avoid confronting harsh truths. The family tries to protect Mary from the reality of Edmund's severe illness, while Mary clings to the comforting notion that his condition is nothing more than "a summer cold." She also attempts to hide her return to drug use with weak justifications, deepening the family's sense of betrayal. Deception even touches on minor issues, like Jamie's efforts to water down his father's whiskey or Tyrone's covert trips to get whiskey from the servants.
Even more touching are the self-delusions, where characters deceive themselves. Mary's retreat into her past is clearly an illusion, a romanticized yet soothing distortion of reality. Even Jamie, despite his cynicism and honesty, fools himself in his pursuit of redemption through alcohol and promiscuity.
God and Religion
Tyrone is deeply concerned about his sons turning away from their Catholic faith, which is a fundamental aspect of their "shanty Irish" heritage. His grievances over their departure from religion lead to Jamie's sarcastic remark that Tyrone, too, is a lapsed Catholic—a fact Tyrone begrudgingly acknowledges. Despite this, Tyrone insists that he still has faith in God, unlike his sons. He is especially worried about Edmund's lack of faith and his pessimistic view of life, blaming it on the dark, atheistic poetry and philosophy that Edmund has been reading.
Guilt and Innocence
Mary's drug-induced journey into her past acts as a refuge from her guilt, helping her regain a sense of innocence and renewed faith. Likewise, the other Tyrones strive to ease their own guilt and shame. Jamie tries to achieve redemption by confessing his envy toward Edmund, while Tyrone attempts to justify his stinginess by blaming it on his poor childhood. The play's tragic theme highlights that innocence cannot be genuinely regained; each character must bear their guilt and suffering, even as they approach death.
Loyalty
The devotion of the three Tyrone men to Mary has diminished because of her continuous inability to heal. However, their emotions of anger, hurt, and disappointment reveal their profound affection for her. This mutual loyalty is the glue that holds the family together and accounts for why Jamie and Tyrone endure each other's presence.
Memory and Reminiscence
Mary isn't the only one haunted by regrets from the past. Tyrone is plagued by memories of his destitute upbringing and his father's desertion, which ultimately led to his suicide. In a moment of self-pity, he mourns the loss of the opportunity to become a renowned Shakespearean actor,...
(This entire section contains 62 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
having instead chosen a financially lucrative but creatively unsatisfying role in a popular melodrama.
Moral Corruption
The family's reaction to Mary's drug addiction reveals their belief that addiction is a sign of weak moral character. The public exposure of her addiction is seen as more harmful to the family's reputation than Jamie's shameful actions, like drinking, gambling, and womanizing. In candid moments, Tyrone admits that morphine is a poison and that Mary is unable to manage her addiction, yet the moral stigma remains. Jamie's moral deterioration, tempered by his affection for his brother and mother, is regarded as less of a social disgrace, even by Tyrone.
Search for Self
In Long Day's Journey into Night, Edmund serves as O'Neill's alter ego and is the primary seeker of truth. Mary and Tyrone both escape into their pasts—Mary reminisces about her days in the convent, while Tyrone recalls a point in his acting career when he could have prioritized artistic integrity over monetary success. Edmund, who is just beginning his journey as a poet and journalist, looks toward a future where he might capture the fleeting inner peace he occasionally finds at sea. The alternative for him is to follow in the footsteps of Jamie, his self-destructive counterpart, on a path that leads to spiritual decay.
Wealth and Poverty
In Long Day's Journey into Night, Tyrone consistently confirms Jamie's disdainful accusations of his penny-pinching nature. Jamie calls him Old Gaspard, highlighting Tyrone's obsession with costs and his perpetual search for the cheapest options. Whether it's buying land, cigars, or cars, hiring staff, or choosing a doctor, Tyrone always associates quality with a bargain price.
Sometimes, Tyrone's stinginess borders on the comedic. He can't resist boasting about his minor savings at the market and often complains about the electric company profiting off him as he wanders through the house, turning off lights in empty rooms. Yet, there is a genuine sadness because some family problems arise from Tyrone's misguided priorities, which he occasionally admits. Jamie frequently reminds him that his reluctance to hire a competent doctor contributed to Mary's addiction. Jamie also worries that Tyrone will choose a low-cost sanatorium for Edmund and repeatedly warns his father against this.
In a convoluted way, Tyrone seeks understanding—or even forgiveness—by recounting his difficult upbringing in an Irish immigrant family abandoned by his father. His fear of ending up in poverty is real, rooted in those harsh days when he worked twelve-hour shifts in a machine shop to support his family. Despite this, Tyrone struggles to gain his sons' empathy. While Edmund suggests he understands his father better, both sons are weary of his stories and remain largely unmoved by his past; they are more concerned with the effects of Tyrone's frugality than its origins.
Family and Inherited Suffering
Eugene O’Neill has composed a lyric of lamentation, in rhythms of agonizing pain, about a ravaged family that not only mirrors his own but also bears on the condition of all mankind. This is a family tied together not only by resentment, guilt, betrayal, and recrimination but also by compassion and love. As in Henrik Ibsen’s plays, the present and past blend in a search—never fully satisfied—for the source of the misfortunes that afflict the blighted house of the Tyrones. Each Tyrone is somehow, but not solely, responsible for his or her wretchedness. A tainted legacy contaminates generation after generation. Edmund’s attempted suicide, prior to the action proper, parallels the actual suicide of Tyrone’s father, just as his tuberculosis apes the illness from which Mary’s father died. Alcoholism courses through three generations. Each protagonist may be partly responsible for his or her fate, because of emotional cowardice or self-deception, but each protagonist is primarily a victim of his fate, whether inherited or inherent in the hellish mystery called life.
The Influence of Heredity and Environment
Mary’s words carry O’Neill’s message at several crucial moments. Having chastised Jamie for sneering at his father, she then reflects:But I suppose life has made him like that, and he can’t help it. None of us can help the things life has done to us. They’re done before you realize it, and once they’re done they make you do other things until at last everything comes between you and what you’d like to be, and you’ve lost your true self forever.
O’Neill’s perspective is largely naturalistic: Man is usually the puppet of his heredity and environment, a pawn of nature’s order, or of chaos. Again, Mary’s words sum up this view: Defending Jamie against an attack by Edmund, she says, “It’s wrong to blame your brother. He can’t help being what the past has made him. Any more than your father can. Or you. Or I.”
Universal Family and Human Nature
That the Tyrones try to understand their weaknesses, that they pity as well as blame one another, that they alternate their rages with forgiving tenderness makes their experiences not only subjective but also representative and heroic. Their search for causes that remain ultimately unknowable, their defeated dreams and inevitable guilts, their need both to confront and to evade reality, and above all their bewilderment in the face of Job-like suffering constitutes them a universal family. Though isolated in their fog-blanketed house, they stand for every loving-hating family that wounds and consoles its members, enmeshed in the tragic net of human nature’s contradictions.