abstract illustration of several people and items: a woman wading through a river, a Native American man in traditional headdress, bottles of alcohol, a sedan, a basketball, and a pair of eyes

The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven

by Sherman Alexie

Start Free Trial

Summary and Analysis: Distances and Imagining the Reservation

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

New Characters

Tremble Dancer: an Urban Indian who is the love interest of the narrator in the first story.

Summary

“Distances” is the story that Thomas tells during the bus ride to the state penitentiary after his trial. It is a visionary tale of an apocalypse that kills the majority of the white population and spares much of the Native American community. The narrator imagines that this event is the result of a Ghost Dance—an attempt to bring back the ancestors and old times—that finally worked.

The action begins with the survivors’ destruction of anything, from houses to appliances, that reminds them of white culture. The narrator is a \"Skin,\" or a resident of the Reservation, in love with an \"Urban\" woman, a former city-dweller now afflicted by disease. Tribal life is divided amongst these new groups; although all Indians live together on reservations now, marriage and breeding between the two tribes is prohibited to prevent the spread of the mysterious Urban illness.

The struggle for survival is complicated not only by the loss of technology but also by the severity of the weather; the climate has changed so that days are hotter, and nights, colder. The narrator tells of daily activities in this environment. The bodies of the dead are burned on old football fields; he holds his sick lover within the privacy that a surviving tree affords them. A house is burned where the narrator spies a picture of Jesus Christ; he cries when he remembers the experience of watching television in dreams.

The tale closes with the return of the \"Others,\" the ancient Native American ancestors. These people defeat the survivors. Tremble Dancer is impregnated by them. She dies soon thereafter while bearing a child in the form of a salmon. The narrator holds a transistor radio, a forbidden object, in his hands in the final scene. He waits for it to work and listens to the sound of his breath.

“Imagining the Reservation” takes the thought experiment begun in “Distances” one step further. It is a philosophical story that demonstrates the power that imagination might have to alter the lives of Native Americans.

The unnamed narrator of this story poses a series of questions. Each question places cultural power now possessed by whites in the hands of Native Americans. He wonders how life would be different if his people, instead of whites, had invented the A-bomb, started Christianity, or arrived in the Americas in the fifteenth century.

These propositions are followed by a story of survival. The narrator recalls being locked in a freezer while working at a convenience store; he lived through the ordeal by remembering the story of man who died in a malfunctioning freezer. The irony is that the victim willed himself to death by simply imagining that it was too cold to survive. This cautionary tale demonstrates the effects that imagination can have on the body and spirit. It thus offers proof for the equation that appears in the text of story itself: “survival = anger × imagination.” Examples of stories are offered in support of this equation.

The story concludes as the narrator wishes that his people might reclaim the culture that degrades their histories and communities. He calls for new belief in the kind of magic needed to restore faith in a future radically different from the present.

Analysis

In these stories, Alexie seeks a reversal of cultural values that might lead to equal recognition of and respect for American Indian traditions and lives. “Distances” seeks a solution in an apocalypse that destroys whites and the ways of life they...

(This entire section contains 797 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

have created; “Imagining the Reservation” looks for answers in the reevaluation of popular white culture at it stands today.

The narrator of each story faces serious obstacles to the success of these visions. In “Distances,” he must contend with a new system of domination that relegates the Urban refugees to subservience in Skin society. In “Imagining the Reservation,” he must convince a skeptical tribe that imagination indeed offers powerful tools for survival.

In either case, the danger is that anger and despair will overshadow the struggle for equality and justice. If society were dismantled, the tribes might abuse the new power granted to them. If the culture is unchanged, on the other hand, his people might lose the ability to imagine a different future.

Alexie suggests that the most promising path can be found by following a distinct formula: “Survival = anger × imagination.” Native Americans must be angry enough to desire change and imaginative enough to create beneficial solutions. Only those solutions that offer belief in outcomes that seem unlikely—like “water that mends broken bones and stor[ies] that put wood in the fireplace” will provide a future that is different from, and better than, the present.

Previous

Summary and Analysis: All I Wanted to Do Was Dance and The Trial of Thomas Builds-the-Fire

Next

Summary and Analysis: Jesus Christ’s Half-Brother is Alive and Well on the Spokane Indian Reservation, The Approximate Size of my Favorite Tumor and Somebody Kept Saying Powwow

Loading...