Lizette Woodworth Reese

Start Free Trial

Faint Perfume

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In the following review of Wild Cherry, Monroe argues that while Reese's poems are effective, she too often relies on Victorian mannerisms.
SOURCE: “Faint Perfume,” in Poetry, Vol. 23, No. VI, March, 1924, pp. 341-42.

Soft scented poems are these, delicately frail and fine, sprung from a shy and isolated soul; an expression of wistfulness, of the ache of smothered emotions. They are carefully studied, they don’t try to say or do anything original; but they sing, with musical taste and precision, a clear pure little minor tune all in the same key.

Mostly they are simply written, and in modern diction, but Miss Reese should discard of yore from her vocabulary—a convenient rhyme, in five places at least, for door or floor, but worn to shreds long since, and moreover inexactly used in such a present-tense line as

As one who comes back to a house of yore.

In a few other details also one finds this poet yielding to Victorian temptations.

Some of the portraits are delicately sketched. “A Puritan Lady,” for example, after the first two ineffectual stanzas, gives a real picture:

Humble and high in one,
          Cool, certain, different,
She lasts; scarce saint, yet half a child,
          As hard, as innocent.
What grave long afternoons,
          What caged airs round her blown,
Stripped her of humor, left her bare
          As cloud, or wayside stone?—
Made her as clear a thing,
          In this slack world as plain,
As a white flower on a grave
          Or sharp sleet at a pane?

“Spring Ecstasy”, “To Love”, “Before the Look of You”—these and other poems are faint whiffs of faded perfume—a bit trite, perhaps, like pressed flowers. Here is To Love:

Take me and break me, Love;
          Make me into a thing
More memorable than a star,
          Or a tall flower in spring.
If this you will not do,
          Down to oblivion thrust;
Into a sleek forgotten grave
          Crumble me to dust!

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Lizette Woodworth Reese

Next

A Review of Wild Cherry

Loading...