Themes and Characters
Similar to John Bunyan’s allegorical work Pilgrim's Progress, where Christian encounters numerous obstacles on his journey from the City of Destruction to the Celestial City, Alcott’s novel follows the March sisters as they strive to overcome personal flaws and grow into “little women.” Sixteen-year-old Meg, overly concerned with her appearance and averse to work, learns to prioritize her family over dreams of luxury and glamour. Fifteen-year-old Jo, burdened by her fiery temper, is an adventurous, rebellious, and spirited girl who writes plays, poems, and short stories. She must learn to embody poise, grace, and patience. Thirteen-year-old Beth, a talented pianist, must work to overcome her shyness. Ten-year-old Amy, artistically gifted but impractical, needs to overcome her thoughtlessness and learn to help others.
At the conclusion of part 1, Father returns home on Christmas Day and assesses his daughters’ year-long efforts to emulate Christian in Pilgrim’s Progress. He is pleased with their progress. Meg has become less vain. Jo is more ladylike and composed. Beth, having recovered from scarlet fever, is gradually overcoming her shyness. Amy is less selfish and less preoccupied with her appearance.
Mr. March is absent during the first half of the novel, and even after his return, he remains a background presence. His influence is felt rather than seen. In his absence, Marmee manages the household and guides the girls through their challenges. She is selfless, dedicated to her family, and always available when needed. Like Jo, she has a temper but keeps it under control.
Living next door to the Marches are the wealthy Mr. Laurence and his grandson Theodore, known as “Laurie.” They bring much excitement and adventure into the lives of the March girls. Mr. Laurence, in his generosity, throws a Christmas party for the girls, gifts Beth a piano, and grants Jo access to his extensive library. His grandson, as wild and adventurous as Jo, is also studious and a lover of music. In part 2, Laurie proposes to Jo, is rejected, and later marries Amy.
While the novel highlights the importance of young people’s independence, it also celebrates the significance of family unity. Beth captures this theme when she expresses her greatest wish: “to stay home safe with Father and Mother, and help take care of the family. . . . I only wish we may all keep well and be together, nothing else.” Disaster often manifests as a threat to the family circle; Alcott addresses large-scale issues such as the Civil War by exploring the impact of Father’s absence on the March family.
Death is a constant threat, with numerous near-disasters hinting at Beth’s eventual passing in part 2. Early in the story, when Amy burns Jo's cherished manuscript of fairy tales, Jo nearly drowns her youngest sister in retaliation. Meanwhile, their father falls ill with pneumonia while serving away from home, prompting Marmee to leave and care for him. As the specter of death looms over the household, Jo remarks, “I feel as if there had been an earthquake,” and Meg adds, “it seems as if half the house was gone.” Although their father recovers, the family must still face the heartbreak of Beth’s death. These trials ultimately bring the family closer together, strengthening their bond.
Alcott explores three central themes in the novel: ambition, domesticity, and true love. After the first part’s publication, Alcott noted in her journal, “Girls write to ask who the little women marry, as if that was the only end and aim of a woman’s life. I won’t marry Jo to Laurie to please anyone.” Alcott, who modeled Jo after herself, was tempted to conclude part 2 with Jo remaining single. Caught between independence and familial obligations, ambition and self-sacrifice, Jo has mixed feelings about marriage. She finds it hard to “give up her own hopes, plans and desires, and cheerfully live for others.” However, she also realizes, “the life I wanted then seems selfish, lonely and cold.” After turning down Laurie’s marriage proposal, Jo compromises by marrying the “learned and good” Professor Friedrich “Fritz” Bhaer, an older German man. Despite his poverty, age, and foreign background, Fritz’s love for Jo helps him overcome these obstacles. He is a warm and supportive husband who encourages Jo to improve her writing. Eventually, Jo raises two children and assists her husband in running Plumfield, a school for boys.
But young as she was, Jo had learned that hearts, like flowers, cannot be rudely handled, but must open naturally.
In contrast, married life for John and Meg Brooke is quite different from what Meg experienced at home. Relying entirely on her husband’s income for all expenses, Meg sometimes acts impulsively. John does not help with household chores, except for disciplining their son. Meg's challenge is to overcome her submissiveness—a trait that has made her dependent and somewhat dowdy, living in a small cottage with her two children, isolated from the world. After Marmee reminds her that a strong marriage is built on mutual interests and responsibilities, Meg starts paying more attention to her appearance, keeps up with current events, and works towards creating an equal partnership in her marriage.
Amy continues to grapple with her tendency towards frivolity. In Europe, she and Laurie spend time together, both displaying their fashionable tastes, talents, and a penchant for laziness and flirtation. Amy engages in painting, while Laurie plays the piano. Upon their return from Europe, they reveal their romantic relationship.
Historical Context
The nineteenth century was a transformative era in American history, defined by profound social, economic, and philosophical shifts. Women played a critical role in both the domestic sphere and the broader societal reforms. Meanwhile, the Civil War and emerging cultural movements like transcendentalism further shaped the landscape, influencing everything from gender roles to educational practices.
The Role of Women in Nineteenth-Century America
In the domestic sphere, women of the nineteenth century were tasked with the demanding responsibility of maintaining households, creating comfortable environments for their families. Their daily routines were exhaustive, consisting of meal preparation, cleaning, laundry, and sewing, often without assistance. Daughters learned these essential household skills to prepare for their future roles as homemakers.
Women were also often unfairly held responsible for their family's external behavior, with societal blame sometimes falling on them if a male family member succumbed to vices like excessive drinking. Economic necessity occasionally forced women to seek work outside the home, despite limited opportunities. Employment options were generally confined to roles such as teaching or acting as companions, although a few ventured into creative avenues like writing, where they faced significant gender biases.
Philosophical and Social Reforms
Set against the backdrop of the Civil War, "Little Women" mirrors an era of intense philosophical and social change. In New England, transcendentalism emerged, championed by figures such as Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau, advocating for individualism and a deep spiritual connection to nature, while rejecting rigid religious doctrines.
Women increasingly participated in social reform through evangelical societies, actively promoting moral reform and abolitionism. This period also saw the rise of the women's rights movement, laying the foundation for future advancements in gender equality.
Education
Educational opportunities in nineteenth-century America were limited, with only a hundred public high schools by 1860 and sporadic attendance in elementary education. The focus was predominantly on rote memorization rather than critical thinking. Innovations in pedagogy, promoted by educators like Bronson Alcott, encouraged independent thought—a theme echoed in Louisa May Alcott's "Little Women."
Families dissatisfied with public schooling often opted for homeschooling or private tutors, as illustrated by Laurie’s tutor, John Brooke, in the novel. Educational opportunities, especially for girls, typically ended by mid-teenage years, reinforcing traditional gender roles.
The Civil War
The Civil War had a profound impact on American society. With over 600,000 soldiers dead and many more injured, the absence of men created a void in families. The war's economic strain was substantial, with the federal budget ballooning from $63 million in 1860 to over $6 billion by 1879, leaving a lasting national debt.
While the South faced economic devastation, affecting infrastructure and agriculture, the North saw economic growth, with wealth increasing by fifty percent from 1860 to 1870. As the nation attempted to reunite during Reconstruction, women temporarily expanded their roles, taking on responsibilities such as nursing and factory work, although these roles largely reverted post-war.
"Little Women" and its Legacy
"Little Women" stands as a classic of children's literature and an enduring example of domestic realism. Its appeal lies in its authentic depiction of the challenges faced by adolescents transitioning to adulthood, a journey fraught with trials and societal expectations. The character of Jo March, modeled after Alcott herself, epitomizes this struggle, rebelling against societal conformity while achieving success as a writer and, eventually, in her personal life.
The novel integrates elements of realism with the concerns of women post-Civil War, set within the tradition of girls’ literature alongside other notable women writers like Fanny Fern and Elizabeth Stuart Phelps. Alcott’s broader body of work, including her pseudonymously published stories, is foundational in feminist literature, portraying women who carve out independent careers while forming meaningful emotional connections.
Character Development and Social Commentary
In "Little Women," Alcott explores the growth and socialization of girls through the experiences of the four March sisters: Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy. Their progression from adolescence to adulthood underscores the importance of parental guidance and a stable domestic environment, promoting qualities like cheerfulness and selflessness to navigate the challenges of war and societal changes.
At the narrative's opening, the sisters express frustration over their financial constraints, revealing their desire for material comforts. However, through their mother's guidance, they learn the value of self-denial and community service, embodying virtues that sustain them through life's adversities.
While "Little Women" reflects the social norms of the nineteenth century as prescribed in family advice manuals, feminist critics since the 1970s have reconsidered its depiction of domestic values and self-denial. Alcott’s nuanced portrayal of Jo’s character as a symbol of independence subverts traditional domestic roles, encouraging women to pursue careers over marriage.
Subtle Social Critiques
Though politically active, Alcott chose to portray a largely harmonious domestic world in "Little Women," with only subtle references to larger social issues such as women’s suffrage, abolition, and educational reform. Modern critics have highlighted Alcott’s underlying critique of women’s relegation to domestic roles, with Jo March’s determined pursuit of independence serving as a powerful counter-narrative.
Alcott's later works further expand on these themes, with Jo advising young women to seek careers, thus reinforcing the novel’s complex interplay between individual creativity and social expectations.
Expert Q&A
How does the Civil War feature in Little Women and why isn't it prominent?
The Civil War in Little Women is present but not prominent, mainly depicted through Mr. March's service as a chaplain. Alcott chose to focus on the domestic lives of the March sisters, emphasizing home life over war to appeal to readers and ensure commercial success. The war serves as a backdrop, highlighting the girls' personal growth and struggles in their father's absence.
Setting
Little Women is a cherished literary piece set against the backdrop of a New England town during the 1860s, drawing inspiration from Concord, Massachusetts. The novel intricately portrays the lives of the March sisters, revealing their internal conflicts and societal challenges as they strive to reconcile their ambitions with traditional domestic roles. Through its rich narrative, the book traverses various physical and emotional landscapes, illustrating a vivid tapestry of growth, resilience, and familial bonds.
March Home
The heart of the March family narrative beats within their modest home in a quaint northern city, reminiscent of Orchard House where Louisa May Alcott herself grew up. Although the house is threadbare, it exudes a sense of warmth and comfort. Due to Mr. March's financial setbacks stemming from his altruism, the family leads a frugal life. The sisters, alongside their mother, frequently gather around the fireplace, a place of solace where stories unfold and bonds deepen. The stark contrast between the Marches' humble abode and the destitute living conditions of the German immigrants, the Hummels, whom they aid on Christmas Day, highlights themes of generosity and community.
Contrasts with Gardiner and Moffat Houses
In contrast to the March home, the residences of the social-climbing Gardiners and Moffats reflect opulence and ambition. At a Gardiner party, Jo encounters Theodore Laurence, known as Laurie, forging a friendship that traverses class boundaries. The Moffat residence, dubbed "Vanity Fair," unveils societal pressures when Meg overhears Mrs. Moffat's insinuations about her mother’s alleged matrimonial scheming. These scenes provide a lens into the complexities of social class and expectations in 19th century America.
Laurence Mansion
Adjacent to the Marches’ home lies the grand Laurence mansion, a symbol of wealth and benevolence. Initially unfamiliar to the March girls, the mansion becomes a frequent retreat after Jo's introduction to Laurie. With its conservatory of rare plants, grand piano that captivates Beth, and a library that lures Jo, the mansion embodies the richness of human values beyond material wealth. The mansion's allure lies not just in its grandeur, but in the warmth and kindness of Grandfather Laurence and Laurie, who welcome the girls into their world.
Great Aunt March’s House
A daily ritual finds Jo at the residence of her father’s aunt, attending to the eccentric and often irritable elderly woman. This house, steeped in history with its vast library belonging to the deceased husband of Great Aunt March, becomes a sanctuary for Jo, who reads fervently while her aunt naps. The library's eclectic collection offers Jo a respite and a window to worlds beyond her own. In a twist of fate, Jo inherits this house, envisioning it as a school for boys, thus aligning with her aspirations for independence and education.
New York City
Seeking distance from Laurie’s affections, Jo ventures to New York City, where she resides in a bustling rooming house. It is here she encounters Professor Bhaer, whose presence marks the beginning of a new chapter in her life. Their engagement signifies Jo’s personal growth and the broadening of her horizons in a city alive with opportunity.
Europe
Amy’s European journey marks an essential rite of passage, symbolizing the March sisters' transition into adulthood. Accompanied by a wealthy aunt, Amy sojourns through southern France and Switzerland, honing her artistic skills. Amidst the picturesque European backdrop, Laurie and Amy’s romance blossoms, culminating in marriage—a testament to their maturation and the enduring bonds of family. Their journey abroad reflects the expansive and transformative experiences that shape the sisters’ lives, echoing the novel’s themes of growth and self-discovery.
Expert Q&A
When and where is Little Women set?
Little Women is set in rural New England, likely Concord, Massachusetts, during the early 1860s, amidst the American Civil War. The story begins around Christmas in either 1861 or 1862, with the March family's father serving as a chaplain in the war. The narrative spans several years, capturing significant events and travels, including trips to Europe and New York City, but ultimately returns to the family's home in New England.
Who are the members of the Pickwick Club in Little Women and where do they meet?
The Pickwick Club in "Little Women" consists of the March sisters: Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy, who assume characters from Charles Dickens's The Pickwick Papers. Meg is Samuel Pickwick, Jo is Augustus Snodgrass, Beth is Tracy Tupman, and Amy is Nathaniel Winkle. They later include their neighbor Laurie as Sam Weller. The club meets in the garret, the attic of the March house, where they set up a table and chairs for their gatherings.
Compare the houses of Laurie and the March family in Little Women.
The March family's home is lively and filled with the activities of four girls and their mother, despite having little money. Their love and faith compensate for their lack of wealth. In contrast, Laurie lives with his wealthy grandfather in a materially rich but lonely environment. Laurie envies the March family's camaraderie and often joins in their adventures, sharing his possessions while respecting their desire for independence.
Style and Technique
Little Women stands as a seminal work in the tradition of the "family novel," akin to the works of Jane Austen, marking a distinct evolution in the realm of nineteenth-century literature. Louisa May Alcott's narrative weaves the familiar threads of domestic ideology with a fresh focus on realism and nuanced character development. By taking inspiration from the likes of John Bunyan and Charles Dickens, Alcott crafts a story that is both reflective of its time and groundbreaking in its portrayal of strong, independent female characters.
The Domestic Novel Tradition
The roots of Little Women can be traced to the rich tradition of family novels, prominently established by Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice in 1813. As the popularity of novels written by and for women burgeoned in the nineteenth century, authors like Susan Warner and Charlotte Yonge captured the imaginations of readers with their sentimental domestic narratives. These novels typically presented characters as paragons of virtue whose lives served as moral blueprints for readers. Jo March, the protagonist of Little Women, is depicted reading Warner’s The Wide, Wide World and Yonge’s The Heir of Redclyffe, both prominent works from this tradition.
Realism and Secularism
While Alcott’s work reflects the domestic novel's moral undertones, it distinguishes itself through a commitment to realism and secular themes. Critics note that Alcott deliberately departs from the idealized role models that characterized earlier books. By integrating more realistic and secular characterizations, Little Women alters the fabric of the children’s moral tale, a tradition that drew heavily from instructional works like Jacob Abbott’s The Young Christian and John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress. These earlier works presented a clear moral framework within which protagonists navigated challenges.
Influence of Bunyan’s Allegory
The moral and allegorical undercurrents in Little Women are largely inspired by Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress. Alcott’s novel opens with an epigraph from this religious allegory, setting the tone for the moral journey of the March sisters. As the story unfolds, the sisters confront personal faults—anger, vanity, and sloth—mirroring the spiritual burdens depicted in Bunyan’s work. The chapter titles, such as "Beth Finds the Palace Beautiful" and "Jo Meets Apollyon," directly echo Bunyan's themes, reinforcing the allegorical framework within which the characters evolve.
Character Development and Literary Influences
Unlike Bunyan’s singular religious focus, Alcott’s characters display a rich tapestry of depth and individuality. Jo March emerges as a multifaceted young woman whose journey of "pilgrim’s progress" intertwines with her struggles against societal norms. Alcott’s depiction is not only a reflection of Bunyan’s allegory but also a nod to Charles Dickens, whose influence permeates the pages of Little Women. The March girls' secret club, "The P. C. and the P. O.," is a homage to Dickens’s The Pickwick Papers, while their charitable acts echo the themes of generosity and transformation in A Christmas Carol. Alcott’s narrative style, characterized by its humor and straightforward dialogue, further owes a debt to Dickens’s storytelling techniques.
Episodic Structure and Narrative Cohesion
Structured in an episodic manner, Little Women presents individual chapters that highlight the distinct journeys of each sister. Despite the episodic nature, the novel’s cohesion is maintained through the recurring theme of overcoming personal burdens and the sisters' collective maturation into "little women." This theme of personal growth is poignantly illustrated in the novel’s conclusion, as the sisters gather at Jo’s school to reflect on their progress. The scene encapsulates the structural unity that Alcott envisioned, drawing on the allegorical journey toward a "Celestial City" of personal fulfillment and moral integrity.
Alcott's Broader Literary Influences
Beyond the obvious influences, Alcott’s work reflects a broad spectrum of literary interests. She was profoundly influenced by the writings of the Brontë sisters, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Oliver Goldsmith, Goethe, and Shakespeare. These influences are evident in the dramatic scenes she crafts, enabling her to depict a realistic and engaging narrative. Alcott’s ability to intertwine traditional allegorical elements with contemporary literary techniques showcases her as a pioneer in the evolution of young adult literature.
Bibliography
- Brophy, Brigid. "A Masterpiece, and Dreadful." New York Times Book Review, January 17, 1965, pp. 1, 44.
- Burrows, Alvina Treut. “A Critical Study of Little Women.” Elementary English, Vol. 37, May 1960, pp. 285–292.
- Cogan, Frances B. All American Girls: The Ideal of Real Womanhood in Mid-Nineteenth Century America. University of Georgia Press, 1989.
- Chesterton, G. K. “Louisa Alcott.” In A Handful of Authors: Essays on Books and Writers. Sheed and Ward, 1953, pp. 163–67.
- Curtis, David. “Little Women: A Reconsideration.” Elementary English, Vol. 45, November 1968, pp. 878–879.
- Elbert, Sarah. A Hunger for Home: Louisa May Alcott and “Little Women.” Temple University Press, 1984.
- Fetterley, Judith. “Little Women: Alcott’s Civil War.” Feminist Studies, Vol. 5, No. 2, Summer 1979, pp. 369–83.
- Gabin, Jane S. “Little Women: Overview.” In Reference Guide to American Literature, 3rd edition. St. James Press, 1994.
- Janeway, Elizabeth. “Meg, Jo, Beth, Amy, and Louisa.” In Only Connect: Readings on Children’s Literature, edited by Sheila Egoff, G. T. Stubbs, and L. F. Ashley. Oxford University Press, 1969, pp. 286, 288, 290.
- Jefferson, Margo. “Books of the Times: Little Women, Growing Up Then and Now.” New York Times, December 21, 1994.
- Lurie, Alison. “She Had It All.” New York Review of Books, March 2, 1995, pp. 3–5.
- MacDonald, Ruth K. Louisa May Alcott. Boston: Twayne, 1983.
- Meyerson, Joel, and Madeleine B. Stern, eds. The Selected Letters of Louisa May Alcott: A Life of the Creator of “Little Women”. University of Georgia Press, 1995.
- Moss, Joyce, and George Wilson, eds. Literature and Its Times: Profiles of 300 Notable Literary Works and the Historical Events That Influenced Them, Vol. 2: Civil Wars to Frontier Societies (1800–1880s). The Gale Group, 1997.
- Payne, Alma J. Louisa May Alcott: A Reference Guide. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1980.
- Review of Little Women. Harper’s New Monthly Magazine, Vol. 39, August 1869, pp. 455–56.
- Review of Little Women. Nation, Vol. 7, No. 173, October 22, 1868, p. 335.
- Russ, Lavinia. “Not To Be Read on Sunday.” Horn Book, Vol. 44, 1968, pp. 521–526.
- Saxton, Martha. Louisa May: A Modern Biography of Louisa May Alcott. Houghton Mifflin, 1977.
- Stern, Madeleine B. “Louisa May Alcott: An Appraisal.” New England Quarterly, Vol. 22, No. 4, December 1949, pp. 475–98.
- Stern, Madeleine B. Critical Essays on Louisa May Alcott. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1984.
- Stern, Madeleine B., ed. Behind a Mask: The Unknown Thrillers of Louisa May Alcott. William Morrow, 1997.
- Showalter, Elaine. Sister’s Choice: Tradition and Change in American Women’s Writing. Clarendon Press (Oxford), 1991, pp. 42–64.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.