Student Question
How do you identify the central argument in a non-fiction novel?
Quick answer:
To identify the central argument in nonfiction, first ensure the work is indeed nonfiction, as novels are inherently fictional. Nonfiction can include biographies or histories, which may not always present arguments. In argumentative nonfiction, the central argument is typically introduced at the beginning and reiterated in the conclusion. It is the main point supported by evidence throughout the text. Look for this central point to understand the author's primary argument.
This question is somewhat puzzling as there is actually no such thing as a non-fiction novel. A novel is defined as a long work of imaginative literature written in prose. Thus all novels are fiction, even if they include some realistic or historical elements.
A work of nonfiction is not a novel. Instead, it is based on facts or events that really happened. While some genres of non-fiction, such as biography or history, may have narrative components, because they are real rather than fictional, they are not novels.
Thus a work can be either nonfiction or a novel but not both.
Some works have arguments and some do not. Novels and biographies are both narratives which tell stories rather than works which argue a specific point. Sometimes writers will tell stories to create sympathy for a point of view. For example, Black Beauty is a poignant tale evoking sympathy for mistreated horses, but most narratives are stories rather than arguments.
For works of non-fiction, some have arguments and some don't. For example, a physics textbook or a field guide to birds or a book on how to use a computer just organizes information rather than arguing something.
Argumentative or persuasive books are written to make a point or to argue something or to urge people to act a certain way. They usually set out their main arguments in the introduction and recapitulate them in their conclusions. You can identify the main argument of a book by looking for the central point that all the other evidence in the book supports.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.