Compare three themes in Night and Catching Fire.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

At first glance, this seems like an odd comparison; however, the two books have a lot in common when thematically compared. Both books have a strong thematic emphasis on loyalty. Catching Fire explores loyalty through a variety of ways in that loyalty exists between Katniss and family as well as between various combatants. Night also shows loyalty as important through the way that families cling to staying together as much as possible. That is why it is so heartbreaking to watch the prison camp systematically destroy these bonds and loyalty between family members.

Two other themes that exist between both books are violence and mortality. These two themes come hand in hand because the violence directly leads to the deaths of major characters. The violence is similar in both books as well because the violence exists as a form of control. The Nazis use violence to control the prisoners and put them in a state of perpetual fear, and that isn't much different than how the Capitol rules all of the districts.

Another theme that exists in both books is the theme of confinement and oppression. Night explores this theme through showing readers what a concentration camp was like. It was a place ruled by violence and fear, and tied with that was the general feeling that one group of people is better than another group of people. This is how the Capitol maintains its place of power over all of the districts. The people are so oppressed that they are actually forced to send young people to the games to fight to the death. The games themselves are also confining in that there are physical boundaries that don't allow contestants to simply flee.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Government control is one of the dominant themes in both Night and Catching Fire.  Collins creates a government that is despotic and tyrannical.  President Snow operates without any checks or limitations to his power.  The government that demands that the Hunger Games are played out is representative of its tyranny.  In much the same way, Wiesel presents a Nazi government that has no institutional checks to its control.  The horror that is brought out in the Holocaust has no limitations because government control is unchecked.  In both settings, government control over individuals is unlimited and profound, constituting the very reason why people in both works suffer under an unresponsive and uncaring government.

Both Night and Catching Fire depict a world of cruelty.  The 74th Hunger Games was an exercise in cruelty. The success in the Hunger Games lies in ensuring that people watch at the suffering of the contestants. President Snow makes it a point to tell Katniss that he was not happy with how she undermined the last Hunger Games. Essentially, cruelty and suffering becomes the reason why people watch the Hunger Games. The establishment of the 75th Hunger Games in Catching Fire is another way in which the cruelty is evident. The only accepted outcome will be the death of its participants in the most agonizing way possible.  In the Holocaust, Wiesel displays a world where cruelty and suffering are evident in all aspects of existence. Eliezer's degradation as well as the others around him is rooted in exerting cruelty on another human being. The Holocaust itself embodies the theme of cruelty and the individual events that Eliezer details with events such as Moshe the Beadle, Madame Schachter, Idek the Kapo, the small boy whose neck was too small for the noose, or Rabbi Eliahu's son abandoning his father.

Another theme that both works share is the theme of survival.  Peeta and Katniss study previous games in order to enhance their chance of survival.  Each of them wants to survive.  Katniss is clear about her desire to want Peeta to survive, who in turn wants Katniss to survive.  Eliezer's narrative is defined by what he must do to survive.  Survival becomes his primary motivation.  In both works, survival is carved out through inhumane conditions and the most horrific of realities.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial