AI Fact-Check

Why was the speaker in Tony Hoagland's poem "Why I Like the Hospital" in a bad mood, and what happened in the lift?

AI Generated Answer

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I'm afraid there seems to be a misunderstanding. "Why I Like the Hospital" by Tony Hoagland is not a known poem. It is possible that the title or the author has been mistaken. I would be glad to help if you could provide me with the correct information.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The AI-generated answer is response is incorrect. "Why I Like the Hospital" by American poet Tony Hoagland is indeed a known poem.

The speaker is in a bad mood when he enters the hospital because his trip from the parking garage to the hospital’s interior is tense and impersonal. Already deflated after navigating a probably crowded and dark underground parking garage, the speaker takes a lift to reach the hospital’s main entrance. When he enters the lift, no one is talking. The passengers

riding wordlessly on the elevator with the other customers,

staring at the closed beige doors like a prison wall.

Most likely visiting an ill loved one (or sick himself), the speaker feels no comfort or shared humanity within the lift. Everyone is disconnected and silent. People may be feeling emotion—e.g., fear, sadness, anticipation—but no one feels free to express emotion.

Then again, why would they? The “other customers” may all be strangers and thus supress their emotions out of a sense of decorum. The speaker’s cynical reference to other people as customers—instead of patients or visitors—emphasizes the capitalistic nature of healthcare in the U.S.

Like robots, everyone stands facing the “beige” elevator doors, which offer no personality or vitality. When the doors close, they trap the occupants like prisoners in a lifeless enclosed space.

In contrast to the garage lift, the speaker prefers the hospital's interior because it is more colorful and filled with humanity. Instead of being a confined box of repression, the hospital “grants permission for pathos”. The speaker sees and hears patients of different ages actually displaying emotion—sadness, frustration, love, “helplessness and rage”. He sees discarded flowers, plastic chairs, a green robe, and human interaction.

This is why the speaker likes the hospital.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Reviewed by eNotes Editorial on