Discussion Topic

Similarities between "The Open Window" and "The Emperor's New Clothes."

Summary:

Both "The Open Window" and "The Emperor's New Clothes" explore themes of deception and gullibility. In "The Open Window," Vera deceives Mr. Nuttel with a fabricated story, while in "The Emperor's New Clothes," the emperor and his subjects are fooled into believing in invisible clothes. Both stories highlight how easily people can be misled by convincing tales.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is one similarity in irony between "The Open Window" and "The Emperor's New Clothes"?

The similarity in irony between these stories is that someone tells a deceptive story to someone else that has a great effect on their present lives and on the future course of their lives. Irony in this instance comes in at two levels. The first level is in the deceptive stories, The second level is in the effects or results of the story.  

The deception told by Vera in "The Open Window" involves irony because she takes information she gets from Framton then uses it against him to scare him out of his wits. In contrast, the expectation is that she would use the information she gets from him to make him feel welcome and at his ease.

"Then you know practically nothing about my aunt?" pursued the self-possessed young lady.

The deception told by the swindling weavers in "The Emperor's New Clothes" involves irony because they prey upon the common human weaknesses of vanity and gullibility to con the kingdom out of wealth in the Emperor's treasure coffers by weaving invisible (nonexistent) cloth. The contrasting expectation is that they would weave real fabric.

this cloth had a wonderful way of becoming invisible to anyone who was unfit for his office, or who was unusually stupid. (Andersen, "The Emperor's New Clothes")

This similarity brings up the important thematic point of motive: What was the motive of the deceivers? In Andersen's tale, the answer to this is an easy one: they deceived in order to get riches (and make fools of the townspeople). The answer to this from Saki's is harder to find. On the one hand, it may be that Vera's motive was simple, unthinking playfulness. On the other hand, it may be that Vera's motive was malicious with secret intent to torment. Saki leaves the text compellingly ambiguous (with no textual evidence supporting one idea or the other) though critics often agree that Vera is the enfant terrible who intentionally torments Framton out of disdain for weak and foolish adults (like her own relatives: "a pack of pariah dogs").

This leads to consideration of the second level: the effects or results of the ironic deceptions. Neither story states the effects or results, but conclusions can be drawn from actions in the resolution. In Framton's case, he runs off in terror. It can be supposed that the remainder of his "rest cure" is a dismal failure. It can be supposed that, ironically, what his sister dreaded is precisely what happens: Framton sits alone without speaking to a sole while his nervous condition grows worse and worse--unless--he is admitted to a hospital for extensive treatment.

In the Emperor's case, the text reveals that, with a "shudder" of cold, he realizes the innocent child is right and he has nothing on. Since he is Emperor, he cannot be removed from office but it is possible some of his wise advisers will be removed, and it is very possible that the Emperor will not stir out of doors again for a long long while. In that regard, he and Framton can be thought of as suffering a similar effect: solitude.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is a similarity between "The Open Window" and "The Emperor's New Clothes"?

Both Saki's short story,"The Open Window," and Hans Christian Andersen's tale, "The Emperor's New Clothes," have narratives that are predicated upon the weaknesses of the listeners.  For, Vera's fabricated tale relies upon the nervous condition and guillibility of Framton Nuttel who is unfamiliar with the countryside where she resides; likewise, the fabricated illusion of the two scoundrels' having made invisible clothes that will reveal the character of his subjects relies upon the emperor's vanity as well as his ego which will not permit him to admit that he sees nothing.

In "The Open Window," for instance, having recognized the timorous and anxious nature of Nuttel, Vera builds a tall-tale from the frame of an open window, thereby creating believability.  Her mixing of truth with fiction generates enough verisimiltude to her tale that Nuttel believes it.  Similarly, the two scoundrels of "The Emperor's New Clothes" blur the lines between imagination and reality by playing upon the emperor's egotistical refusal to admit that he sees nothing lest he seem "ignorant and incompetent."

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial