Student Question
How does one write a dialogue between a detective and assistant discussing why a book of poems found next to a victim could be a vital clue?
Quick answer:
To write a dialogue between a detective and assistant about why a book of poems found next to a victim could be a vital clue, consider classic detective models. Use Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson's intellectual discussions as a template, focusing on observation and analysis. Alternatively, employ the hard-boiled detective style, like Sam Spade and Effie Perine from The Maltese Falcon, where intuition and hunches play a significant role in deducing clues.
It would be best to look at models from classic detective novels and short stories. I would suggest examples that represent two different types of detective. You could start with Sherlock Holmes, the gentleman consulting detective, who relies on intellectual prowess and uncanny powers of observation. Examine any of his conversations between Doctor Watson or Inspector Lestrad. You could also watch an episode of the television series Elementary, which imagines Holmes as a consulting detective in modern day New York City, to glean a useful example of interaction between Holmes and a variety of characters he uses as a sounding board for his analysis of a crime scene.
The second would represent the hard-boiled private investigator. He usually relies on a "Girl Friday" who acts as his receptionist. Unlike Holmes, this type of detective relies more on instinct than intellect. He will examine hunches and treat them on the same level as solid deductive reasoning. A good example for this type is Sam Spade in The Maltese Falcon. His secretary is Effie Perine, and Sam relies on her women's intuition especially when a case centers on a femme fatale (dangerous woman).
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.