Student Question
How does Ken Liu portray Jack's attitude towards his mother in "The Paper Menagerie"?
Quick answer:
Ken Liu portrays Jack's attitude towards his mother as one of growing contempt and embarrassment in "The Paper Menagerie." As Jack enters his teenage years, he becomes estranged from his immigrant mother, feeling ashamed of her inability to speak English and her background. This contempt drives a wedge between them, contrasting with their earlier close relationship. Jack's ignorance of his mother's history contributes to his attitude, which he later regrets as she nears death.
Ken Liu presents Jack's attitude towards his mother in the short story “The Paper Menagerie” as one of contempt.
When Jack reaches high-school age, he begins to show contempt for his mother, who is an immigrant from China. His contempt for his mother, which he admits to feeling good, “like wine,” manifests itself in Jack's not talking to his mother, who does not speak English.
Jack's contempt for his mother is mixed with a fair amount of embarrassment at her inability to speak English and the manner in which she met Jack's father after he picked her out of a catalog.
The effect of Jack's contempt for his mother is to drive a wedge between them. When Jack was little, he had a good relationship with his mother; he would delight in all the remarkable origami animals she made for him and which would magically come to life.
But when Jack hits his teen years, he becomes increasingly estranged from his mother and, as we've seen, feels contempt towards her. However, it's clear that Jack's feelings are a consequence of ignorance. As he readily confesses when his mother lies dying, he doesn't know much about her. But then, the same can be said about his father.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.