Discussion Topic

Comparing and contrasting "The Seafarer" and "The Wanderer."

Summary:

"The Seafarer" and "The Wanderer" both explore themes of exile, loss, and the search for meaning. While "The Seafarer" focuses on the harsh, solitary life at sea and the speaker's spiritual journey, "The Wanderer" emphasizes the sorrow of a warrior mourning his lost lord and comrades, reflecting on the impermanence of life.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How would you compare and contrast "The Seafarer" and "The Wanderer"?

Hi there-

I think you will find it helpful to visit our How to Write a Compare and Contrast Essay page.   

There are other topics on our "how to" pages you might find helpful as well, including:

How to Analyze a Poem

How to Read Literature Critically

How to Write a Good Essay on English Literature

Hope that helps.  Thank you for using eNotes!

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Decide on three or four aspects that you could compare and contrast.  For example, the use of Christian elements and Pagan elements, the speaker, and the reason for a nomadic lifestyle. Both poems are also broken into essentially two parts--the first, explaining who the speaker is and what is going on in his life and the second addresses man's fate and/or relationship with God.

In The Seafarer, the speaker is a Christian who absolutely loves the sea.  He can not think of...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

anything else, even though it is not an easy or comfortable life.  He prefers it to the life of ease and physical comforts that living on land provides.  The sea is ingrained in him, and he longs to be on the water when he is not.  You would probably understand this longing if you compared it to something you enjoy doing that would effect you negatively should you not be allowed to enjoy it any more--sports, music, shopping, or surfing the internet might be among the pasttimes you enjoy most.

In the second part of the poem, the speaker gives advice about how to live life.  It is very much like a prayer to the Lord as he finishes with "Amen".

In The Wanderer, the speaker has lost his home, family, friends, and the generosity of his king.  He roams the land looking for some friendly face to take him in where he may find comfort in human companionship.  He addresses man's fate in the world in the second part.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Compare and contrast the speakers in "The Seafarer" and "The Wanderer."

"The Seafarer" and "The Wanderer," both of which have distinct thematic similarities—the exile of the speaker and longing for what has passed into oblivion—are very different in their focus but end in a similar place. One is a firsthand account, and the second is a retelling by a second party of what he has heard.

First, in "The Seafarer," the speaker begins the poem with his personal experience:

I can make a true song
about me myself,
tell my travels,
how I often endured
days of struggle,
troublesome times,
how I have suffered
grim sorrow at heart
have known in the ship
many worries.

The speaker's account is intensely personal, obviously based on first-person experience, and leading toward a sorrowful experience centered on his life at sea. The speaker in "The Wanderer," on the other hand, is introduced by an omniscient observer:

Often the solitary one finds grace for himself
the mercy of the Lord
Although he, sorry-hearted,
must for a long time move by hand
along the waterways, along the ice-cold sea
tread the paths of exile. Events go as they must.

Even though the two poems recount the experience of exile and loss of their relationships to other men, the focus of their experience is very different. One, the wanderer, finds salvation in his experience of exile immediately, while the seafarer searches throughout the poem for his salvation—in both poems, the exiles find resolution, but the wanderer, despite his early discovery of "grace," finds his resolution slightly more problematic as he explores what he has left behind.

The seafarer focuses on the hardships of his exile from his fellow men, an exile obviously tied to the sea:

This [the hardships of exile at sea] the man [those who are at home on land] does not know
the warrior lucky in worldly things what some endure then,
those who tread most widely the paths of exile.

The seafarer speaks most eloquently about exile at sea—he is "fettered by cold" and "bound by frost"—and even though he experiences some pleasurable moments (e.g., "the gannet's noise and the voice of the curlew"), he misses the life of comradeship and the warmth of the hearth. His discomfort seems centered on physical rather than on mental deprivations.

The wanderer, on the other hand, focuses on his inner being, his ability to reach out to his fellow men and unburden himself through conversation:

So I, often wretched and sorrowful,
bereft of my homeland, far from noble kinsmen,
have had to bind in fetters my inmost thoughts...

The consequence of his exile, unlike the seafarer's, is not just physical hardship but also mental hardship—his exile has imposed a kind of mental imprisonment, like the seafarer's being "bound by frost," that binds him "in fetters" because he cannot share his experience with others.

Both men, however, share the same sense of a world gone by, one that both look back on as a better world which was not permanent. The seafarer makes this point starkly when he says,

I do not believe
that the riches of the world will stand forever.
Always and invariably, one of three things
will turn to uncertainty before this fated hour
disease or old age, or the sword's hatred
will tear out the life from those doomed to die.

The seafarer has identified the three most common causes of death in the Scandinavian/Anglo-Saxon world—disease, old age, and warfare—that are the only permanent elements in the world of the seafarer. He follows this observation with "all that old guard is gone, and the revels are over," a clear statement of the impermanence of mankind and the world he misses more than any other.

The wanderer, in perhaps the most memorable lament for the impermanence of man and after having recounted the number of ways men die, asks,

Where is the horse gone? Where is the rider?
Where the giver of treasure? Where are the seats at the feast?
Where are the revels in the hall? Alas for the bright cup!
Alas for the mailed warrior!

If the first two lines sound familiar, you might have read J. R. R. Tolkien's TheLord of the Rings—he uses these lines in the Rohan episode to express the loss of power once wielded by men. The wanderer is not lamenting the loss of his present world; he is recalling, with sadness, the world that pre-dates the Christian world.

Both poems end with very conventional and doctrinally correct praises for the new belief system, Christianity, but, considering the passion with which the speakers lament the passing of their former lives, one cannot help but conclude that these men are looking back rather than forward.

In the final analysis, both The Seafarer and The Wanderer, with slightly different points of view based on the speakers' experiences, explore the loss of what was and the replacement by what is: the loss of a pagan world in which loyalty, military power, individual honor, and gold are the measure of a good life and the new Christian belief system that they now follow, perhaps not with any enthusiasm.

Approved by eNotes Editorial