Student Question

Analyze the treatment of race in "Borders" and "Squatter."

Quick answer:

King’s story is an example of a kind of Canadian literature called “Indigenism,” a term that refers to the political movement that aims to strengthen the collective identity of First Nations people by recognizing their national rights as distinct from those of European nationalities. Laurence’s story is part of what literary critics call “The White-Indian Story,” one in which the main character, usually female and white, has a romanticized encounter with someone Indigenous and learns about her own prejudices.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Thomas King’s story “Borders,” the primary personal relationship discussed is between mother and child, both of whom are Blackfoot. The family resides in Canada but is attempting to visit their relatives in the United States. The racial and ethnic dimensions are emphasized in relation to nationality because Indigenous group...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

identity takes precedence in the mother’s perspective. She refuses to recognize nation-state jurisdiction as superior to, or other than, Indigenous nation, or “tribal,” identification. For her, Blackfoot group membership does not simply span national borders but eliminates them. She does not recognize the nation-state’s right to divide her family and all their people.

In Margaret Laurence’s “The Loons,” white European heritage is contrasted to First Nation heritage primarily through relationships between two women who are members of families with those respective backgrounds. Vanessa is a white, Euro-Canadian girl with a romantic image of Indigenous worldview. Her father is a physician. She thinks of herself as broad-minded, however, in comparison to her father’s racist mother, a white woman who refuses to interact with multiracial (“metis”) people. When another local girl, Piquette, who is metis, becomes ill, Doctor MacLeod invites her to stay with the family at their summer camp. Vanessa imagines that all people of Native heritage love nature and assumes that Piquette will join her in appreciating the outdoors. Suffering from tuberculosis, the sick girl wants to stay indoors and recuperate. Vanessa’s stereotypical way of thinking blocks her ability to understand or communicate with Piquette as an individual person.

Approved by eNotes Editorial