Linguistics

Start Free Trial

Student Question

What is Roger Fowler's concept of mind style?

Quick answer:

Roger Fowler's concept of mind style refers to the linguistic representation of a character's worldview, distinct from point of view. It involves consistent structural choices in language that reveal a character's perception of the world, often reflecting the author's own perspective. Examples include characters like Benjy in The Sound and the Fury and Lennie in Of Mice and Men, whose speech patterns and thought processes provide insight into their mental states and personal experiences.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Hello! Mind-style is the linguistic representation of an individual's mental perception of the world. To put it simply, mind-style is a description of our personal worldview. My worldview may differ from yours; individual worldviews may be based on personal knowledge, how we process information, our prejudices, our beliefs, our disabilities or challenges, our personal preferences, and even our tendencies towards a particular mode of action.

In the world of literature, a person's world view may also be recognized from an individual's diction; someone who is mentally challenged may exhibit certain distinctive speech patterns. Our recognition of this individual's disability may prompt us to realize that his worldview may differ from ours; quite possibly, he may even exhibit heightened perception in certain areas, superior to ours. His speech may also feature certain transitivity patterns.  An example is Benjy in William Faulkner's The Sound And The Fury.

Mind-style in literature is therefore the worldview of the author. It differs from point of view because the concept of worldview is unique to the author.

Another way mind-style can be conveyed in literature is through the use of the conceptual metaphor. For example, in JM Barrie's Peter Pan, Mr. and Mrs. Darling's trepidation in keeping Wendy as their daughter is apparent. She is another mouth to feed; the conceptual metaphor is that children are a financial burden, a commodity, that may or may not produce a positive return on investment.

Mind-style can also be conveyed through the use of faulty logical reasoning. An example is Miss Shepherd in The Lady In The Van. She argues with another character that she knows all about paint jobs because she won a prize for painting while in infant school. We learn later that her rather odd way of rationalizing her argument stems from her involvement in an accident years before. Her guilt and sense of paranoia are the result of this experience; consequently, the resulting negative emotions have impaired her thought processes.

I hope this helps. Please read the link below, as it really explains how Roger Fowler's mind-style concept is used in literature. Thanks for the question.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is Roger Fowler's concept of "mind style"?

In Fowler's  own words, mind style must be a consistent and contextual demonstration of the views of the world by a character. It must do so in a way that shows

“cumulatively, consistent structural options, agreeing in cutting the presented world to one pattern or another, to give rise to an impression of a world-view”. 

Mind Style is not an easy concept to understand so let's not confuse it with focalization or point of view. They are related to it, but not the same. 

Whenever a writer wants to focalize on one character, thus showing the reader how this character understands the world around it, he or she (the author) often gives the character a unique way to express itself, so that the reader can discern several things about the character that go indirectly characterized. 

A good example would be George and Lennie in Of Mice and Men. Notice how each character is linguistically represented based on each of their life experiences, cognitive levels, exposure to the world and to malice. Without explaining too much, the narrator does not need to tell us that Lennie is mentally challenged, nor that George is a tad more life-savvy. All comes together when we witness their speech, how they use it, and how they apply it. 

At a metalinguistic level, the mind style also reveals a lot about the author and his or her own views of life, temperament, and their capacity for rage, or even mercy. 

Notice that, in the same example Of Mice and Men, Steinbeck is forgiving toward Lennie in the way that he narrates the accidental killing of Curly's wife.

Lennie's other hand closed over her mouth and nose.

Steinbeck hints at us to understand that, as he owns the power of omniscience as an author and as a third person narrator, he could very well decide whether there is malice and intention behind Lennie's actions. As such, he has chosen to take the agency of the action away from Lennie, and he instead placed it in his hands; the hands of a man who is mentally challenged, brusque in both action and thought, and clueless about his own strength.  

Does Steinbeck tell us any of these? He does not have to. He shows clearly what the mind style of each character is, particularly Lennie's. It is now the turn for us, as readers, to commiserate with Lennie and George because we, too, understand the mind style of these two sad men. We understand that Lennie will suffer the consequences of having accidentally killed a woman who was nothing but trouble in the first place.

We are able to sense the inevitability of his fate because we also understand that George and Lennie lived off a dream that would never come true. All of these emotions are not conveyed by descriptions alone. They are powerfully submitted through the linguistic structures that makes each character unique. Surely not every writer can do this effectively, which is the reason why some works of literature are superior to others. 

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial