Life Is a Dream Themes

The main themes in Life Is a Dream are reality and illusion, parental responsibility, and what honor demands.

  • Reality and illusion: The play raises the question of whether life itself is a kind of dream or illusion and invites the audience to question the reality of their lives.
  • Parental responsibility: King Basilio is responsible for his son’s imprisonment and its effects on Prince Segismund’s character.
  • What honor demands: The demands of honor are particularly important to Clotaldo, Basilio, Rosaura, and Segismund, who concludes that it is best to behave honorably whether one is dreaming or awake.

Life Is a Dream Study Tools

Ask a question Start an essay

Themes

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Reality and Illusion

The title of Life Is a Dream (La vida es sueño) expresses the central idea of the play. In the most simplistic and literal terms, the audience knows more than the characters, being aware, for instance, that Segismund is not dreaming in act 2, when Clotaldo later assures him that he was, or in act 3, when he believes he might be. Any sense of certainty, however, comes under philosophical attack in act 4, when Segismund questions how anyone can ever be sure they are not dreaming. Perhaps all of life is a dream.

The Catholic background to Calderón’s work is of vital importance here. Segismund ends the play by saying that the dream in which everyone lives will only be dispelled by “the Last Trumpet of the eternal Day.” In this sense Segismund stands as synecdoche for the whole of humanity. The life that everyone has been trained to accept as real is nothing but an illusion when compared with the ultimate and eternal reality of heaven. Life serves much the same function in God’s plan as Segismund’s brief appearance at court served in act 2 of the play: it determines whether one is worthy of heaven or not.

The audience or reader of the play starts out with the certainty that Segismund is being deceived. He is told he is dreaming and later decides that he might be, when in fact all these things happen when he is wide awake. By the end of the play, however, Segismund may have convinced the audience that everything presented to them was an illusion. This works as a metatheatrical conceit—since a play is an illusion—but also invites them to question the reality, certainty, and stability of their everyday lives.

Parental Responsibility

This theme is more prominent in the version of the play in which Clotaldo turns out to be Rosaura’s father (rather than a friend of her father, as here). However, the main plot still provides ample exploration of the theme, particularly in the question of Basilio’s actions toward Segismund and whether the father is responsible for the actions and disposition of his son.

Even before Segismund raises this question in act 2, Basilio has reproached himself with it. The audience may well agree with Segismund that it is rather late for the thought to occur to Basilio that chaining his son up alone in a remote dungeon for twenty years may not have improved his temper or made him well-suited to wield power.

When Basilio enters the throne room in act 2, the first observation Segismund makes is that he has no feelings for this old man. He can see from his crown that Basilio is the king, but nothing tells Segismund that this is his father. This is scarcely surprising, since Basilio has played no part in Segismund’s upbringing, has robbed him of his birthright, and has chained him up “like a wild beast’s whelp” rather than a prince.

It is only at the end of the play that Basilio recognizes Segismund’s outstanding qualities and talents, from his courage and prowess in battle to his intelligence and rationality. These attributes make it clear that Segismund is correct to conclude that Basilio misread the stars, or blamed them for his own prejudice, and that he himself created the defects he deplored in his son earlier in the play.

What Honor Demands

The theme of what honor demands is the one that ties the plot and the subplot together most completely. Rosaura is the character most entirely motivated by honor, and Astolfo the character most lacking...

(This entire section contains 829 words.)

See This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this study guide. You'll also get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

in it. It may seem strange to modern audiences that the reward for Rosaura’s courage and chivalry is to marry Astolfo, but this only reinforces the point that her aim is not love or even marital harmony, but the satisfaction of honor.

The demands of honor are also important to Segismund, Clotaldo, and Basilio. Basilio initially feels that he has to balance public and private duty, choosing what he believes he owes to Poland as its king, rather than his duty as a father. The plot of the play is set in motion when he begins to think he may have got the balance wrong. For Clotaldo, honor is principally a matter of loyalty to his king. This forces him to treat Segismund unjustly, but he attempts to allay this unfairness by giving the prince advice and explaining matters to him in a way that has ethical value, if not literal truth.

For Segismund, the demands of honor are a guiding light in the midst of uncertainty. Even if one cannot be sure whether one is dreaming or not, one can always behave honorably. It is this notion that leads him to conclude that it is not ultimately very important if one is in the midst of an illusion. A base or noble action remains base or noble if one happens to be dreaming.

Previous

Act Summaries

Next

Characters