Themes: All Themes
Themes: The Nature of Man
Given the dramatic situation at its center, it is inevitable that a major theme of A Lesson Before Dyingmust be that announced by the questions that trouble Grant: What is a man? How must a man live? How must a man die? The word “man” here must be understood in two senses. One of these is the inclusive sense, according to which “man” is synonymous with “human being.” This usage has become suspect as sexism in language has become an issue. In this...
(Read more)Themes: Irony and Personal Growth
Ironically, it is Vivian’s situation that keeps him at his school, not any sense of self-sacrifice or humanistic concern for his charges. In fact, at first he seems to have accepted Antoine’s assessment of his worth, much as Jefferson, in jail, accepts the view of himself as hog. Like Jefferson, Grant must learn in his own prison, his racially inherited place under a brutal Southern sun, that it is possible to find both dignity and hope.
(Read more)Themes: Struggle for Identity and Change
Through education, Grant has distanced himself from the faith that steadies Tante Lou and fires the righteous anger of Mose Ambrose. He is the new Southern black, struggling to redefine himself in the face of changes that are eroding a way of life that for prior generations had at least allowed a modicum of pride and self-respect. The time is not yet right for collective action, the boycotts and sit-ins of the next generation; for Grant,...
(Read more)Themes: Inner Conflict and Redemption
A Lesson Before Dyingreads a bit like a sophisticated morality drama. It is not, of course, a religious allegory in the mode of the medieval morality plays, but like them, it involves an outward test that reflects the psychomachia, or mind struggle, within the protagonist. Grant’s inner conflict is between despair, articulated by Matthew Antoine, and hope, held out by Vivian. At stake is his secular redemption, and the challenge he must meet and...
(Read more)Themes: Courage and Dignity in Adversity
What Gaines shows is that even in the face of such abysmal conditions, a man or woman can reveal courage and dignity—or even, like Jefferson, regain them when they are lost. Some of the novel’s characters, especially Tante Lou, define their humanity by their faith both in God and tradition. Others, such as Grant, must define it on their own terms through personal exorcism, not of the devil, but of doubt and despair, and through contact with their...
(Read more)Themes: Racial Injustice and Its Impact
In A Lesson Before Dying, the personal problems of the black and Creole characters are the bitter fruit grown from seeds sown in the soil of racial bigotry. For them, the injustice of the caste system is the central, inescapable burden that weighs them down with poverty and ignorance, often with little hope of amelioration. That fundamental fact of their life is gleaned at the novel’s outset, when, with prophetic resignation, Grant explains that...
(Read more)Themes: Social Realism and Character
In its attention to social interaction, to the casual injustices of the period, and to the nuances of interaction, A Lesson Before Dying manifests the concerns associated with social realism. Social realism, however, tends to define character as a social product: We are what society makes us. In depicting characters who transcend social determinism, the novel moves on to the psychological, or, as some might say, to the spiritual.
(Read more)Themes: Transcendence and Community
The possibility of transcendence found in the individual human being may point to possibilities for the human community as well. Much of the interaction of black and white characters in this novel is based on conventions established over generations; the power of the past is strongly felt. The relationship of Paul to Jefferson and Grant suggests that the past may be transcended, a suggestion consistent with the thematic emphases of Gaines’s...
(Read more)Themes: Resistance to Change
The meaning of the novel rests as well on the psychological truth of its observations. For all the novel’s emphasis on transcendence, it also shows, especially in most of the white characters, the strength that can be embodied in the struggle against change, whether individual or social. Henri Pichot seems related to characters found elsewhere in Gaines’s work: white men (they usually are men) who are aware at some level of the inevitability of...
(Read more)Themes: Possibility of Change and Transcendence
The possibility of change, and of positive change, has been a frequent theme of Gaines’s fiction. That possibility propels the action of his two best-known novels, The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman (1971) and A Gathering of Old Men(1983). That theme is present here as well. It is the possibility of change, of development, of transcendence that comes from within, from an awareness of self, that defines the humanity of both Jefferson and Grant....
(Read more)Themes: Connection to Society and Community
The central theme of A Lesson before Dyingis the way an individual connects with society, particularly their own community and heritage. This connection involves relationships with elders, family members, children in the community, shared religious beliefs, and the segregation present within the community. Gaines explores a social framework that educates individuals on becoming civilized members of society. He portrays Jefferson's increasing...
(Read more)Themes: God and Religion
Miss Emma, Tante Lou, and Reverend Ambrose are deeply concerned about Jefferson's spiritual relationship with God and his understanding of concepts like faith, heaven, and salvation. They believe that Wiggins's visits will help Jefferson confront his impending death with dignity. They have faith that Wiggins, with his education, can help Jefferson develop a sense of self-worth and explore his profound thoughts about life and his approaching...
(Read more)Themes: Civil Rights and Racism
The story unfolds in the late 1940s, a time when the Civil Rights movement was advocating for integration. Integration seeks to ensure equal rights for everyone, fostering harmonious coexistence regardless of race or skin color. However, during this era in the South, segregation remained widespread. Segregation, which stands in stark contrast to integration, keeps races separate. Racism arises when one race considers itself superior to another...
(Read more)Themes: Justice and Injustice
From the start to the finish of A Lesson Before Dying, a strong sense of injustice is constantly present. While this theme originates from the larger issue of racism, Gaines emphasizes specific incidents to illustrate how deeply ingrained racist ideologies can result in miscarriages of justice. Jefferson, who is intellectually challenged, innocently accepts a ride from two dishonest young men intending to rob a white businessman. During the...
(Read more)Themes: Mentorship and Role Models
At first, Grant is reluctant to become a mentor to Jefferson. Yet, he quickly understands that a major problem within the Black community is the absence of positive role models for young men. Many of Grant's contemporaries from the Quarter have either passed away or are imprisoned. He notices a troubling trend where men leave women to raise children by themselves. Through Jefferson, Grant learns an important lesson: he can make a meaningful...
(Read more)Themes: Educational Inequality
The superintendent's visit underscores the minimal expectations set for the school and its students. Dr. Joseph, the superintendent, fails to recall Grant's last name, mistakenly calling him Higgins this year, just as he did the last year, and Washington the year before. When Grant asks for additional supplies and better books, Dr. Joseph disregards his request and instead suggests he concentrate on hygiene and have the students collect pecans to...
(Read more)Themes: Injustice and Dehumanization
The next day, Grant is summoned to the main house for a meeting with Mr. Henri. Mr. Farrell, the handyman, tells him, "He say it be all right if you come up by five this evening." Grant arrives about ten minutes before five, is let into the kitchen by Inez, and is offered a seat, which he declines, remembering how his aunt and Miss Emma were not invited to sit the previous night. Inez informs Grant that Mr. Louis is attempting to convince Mr....
(Read more)Themes: Racial Dynamics and Social Hierarchy
The relationship between Black and White communities in the Southern United States during the 1940s is vividly illustrated by Miss Emma's response to Jefferson's sentencing. She anticipates the guilty verdict even before the trial starts and understands the actions she must take to support Jefferson. This dynamic is further highlighted by the treatment of Tante Lou, Miss Emma, and Grant when they visit the plantation house to meet with Henri...
(Read more)Themes: Community Support and Resistance
People have noted that the "issue of capital punishment has been overshadowed by a focus on highlighting and emphasizing the positive aspects of the traditional Black community." Jefferson emerges as the most compelling figure in the story by deciding not to play the victim. Miss Emma assists Jefferson by making sure he realizes that "he's not a hog, he's a man," as she explains to Mr. Henri while seeking his assistance to obtain the sheriff's...
(Read more)Themes: Racial Injustice and Capital Punishment
The narrative centers on the execution of an innocent man who is denied a fair trial due to his race; the jury is made up entirely of White men who do not view themselves as his equals. Jefferson's attorney shows such a lack of respect that, in his closing statement, he argues they might as well electrocute "a hog as this thing." The trial spans only a Friday morning and ends after lunch with a guilty verdict for robbery and first-degree murder....
(Read more)Expert Q&A
What three literary devices developed the theme of A Lesson Before Dying?
In "A Lesson Before Dying," Ernest J. Gaines develops the theme of injustice through characterization, symbolism, and dialogue. Characterization reveals the transformation of characters like Grant and Jefferson as they face internal and external challenges. Symbolism, such as Jefferson's diary, signifies his reconnection with humanity. Dialogue conveys deeper meanings and reflects societal constraints, illustrating the pervasive racism and injustice they confront. These devices collectively enhance the thematic exploration of dignity and identity.
How does Jefferson's transformation in A Lesson Before Dying reflect the central theme?
Themes in A Lesson Before Dying
A Lesson Before Dying explores themes of justice, racism, and humanity within the context of the Jim Crow era in Louisiana. The novel highlights the systemic injustice faced by African Americans, as seen in Jefferson's wrongful conviction and dehumanization. It also examines the struggle for dignity and identity, as both Jefferson and Grant Wiggins learn crucial lessons about humanity and self-worth. The narrative underscores civil rights and the transformative power of education and empathy in confronting racism and inequality.
Setting's Impact on Plot, Characters, and Theme in "A Lesson Before Dying"
The setting of Ernest Gaines's A Lesson Before Dying is crucial to its plot, characters, and themes. Set in 1940s Louisiana, the novel explores the destructive power of racism and segregation. The setting highlights the harsh realities faced by Jefferson, a black man unjustly sentenced to death, and Grant, the educated black teacher grappling with systemic oppression. The small-town environment amplifies themes of dehumanization, acceptance, and dignity, as the characters navigate societal prejudices and internalized oppression.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.