Leslie Marmon Silko Criticism

Leslie Marmon Silko, a pivotal figure in American literature, is renowned for her distinctive blend of Western narrative forms and the rich oral traditions of her Laguna Pueblo heritage. Emerging as a significant voice during the Native American literary renaissance of the 1970s, Silko's body of work, which includes novels, poetry, essays, and short stories, intricately explores themes of identity, spirituality, and cultural intersection. Her acclaimed novel, Ceremony, is a profound narrative that delves into the journey of Tayo, a mixed-heritage World War II veteran seeking healing through indigenous rituals, as examined by Susan Blumenthal through the novel's symbolism of spotted cattle.

Silko’s narratives, often interlaced with both prose and poetry, challenge stereotypes by emphasizing the ongoing vitality and cultural significance of Native Americans. This narrative approach is characterized by a dynamic interplay between past and present, as noted by critics of works like Storyteller. Elizabeth N. Evasdaughter observes how Silko's literature dismantles stereotypes, while her analysis highlights Silko's emphasis on cultural resilience. Furthermore, in her novel Almanac of the Dead, Silko critiques European colonial impacts, proposing a return to indigenous stewardship as a path to healing societal rifts, a vision acknowledged by critics including Linda Neimann.

Gender dynamics within Native American communities also feature prominently in Silko's work. Edith Swan's analysis of Laguna Pueblo's matrilineal influences reveals how Silko's narratives articulate the resilience and transformative potential of Native traditions. Through her storytelling, Silko cements her role as a pivotal figure in contemporary Native American literature.

In an interview with Leslie Marmon Silko, she discusses the profound influence of her mixed heritage and family storytelling traditions on her writing. Her work, including Ceremony, Laguna Woman, and Storyteller, showcases a narrative style uniquely hers, weaving myth with autobiography, as noted by Patricia Jones. This blending creates complex intergenerational female narratives and highlights cultural conflicts and healing through Native traditions.

The critical response to Silko's work, particularly Ceremony, has been predominantly positive, often drawing comparisons to works like N. Scott Momaday's The House Made of Dawn. While some critics argue that Silko's novel might lack the intensity of her short stories, others, like Linda Krumholz, praise her for engaging non-Native readers with Laguna culture through her compelling storytelling.

In Storyteller, Silko crafts a unique form of autobiography by interweaving personal narratives with Laguna history, analyzed by Arnold Krupat and Helen Jaskoski who highlight her transformation of Laguna tales into universal stories. Silko's narratives depart from bleak portrayals of Native Americans, instead offering perspectives filled with resilience and hope. Her characters draw strength from cultural heritage, acknowledging historical injustices yet affirming cultural identity, as emphasized by Simon J. Ortiz. Through storytelling, Silko exemplifies cultural affirmation and resistance, cementing her role as a leading voice in Native American literature.

Read Full Introduction

Leslie Marmon Silko Criticism

Contents