Themes
Last Updated October 6, 2024.
Growth and Development
This novel explores the fundamental debate of "nature" versus "nurture" by
examining life on Gethen. It questions which cultural characteristics are
taught and passed down through generations and which stem directly from one's
environment. On Gethen, the absence of gender distinctions allows for a society
with fewer limitations on where individuals can go and what careers they can
pursue. The phrase "The king is pregnant" might sound unusual to those from
Earth, where the roles associated with "king" and "pregnancy" differ
significantly. However, on Gethen, such an announcement is not surprising. What
astonishes them is that humans can engage in sexual activity daily, unlike
their own monthly cycles. The infrequency of sexual activity results in
Gethenians being intensely affected by their "kemmer" or sexual cycle. Without
the daily distraction of sexuality, they focus more on unity rather than
differences. Gethenians, known for their spiritual enlightenment, have
developed the ability to gather and predict the future, although they find
little practical use for this skill. Meanwhile, advanced members of the Ekumen
have learned to connect with others' minds, a skill rooted in recognizing
differences. Another key factor in Gethen's development is its Ice Age climate.
The absence of birds means they lack a natural model for air travel, hindering
their progress toward space exploration. Much of their physical energy is
devoted to generating heat, resulting in less developed muscles. As illustrated
in Chapter 17's Creation Myth, where warmth is derived from a house built with
Edondurth's brothers' bodies, Gethenians have learned to be more
resource-conscious, as wastefulness can be a matter of survival.
Sex Roles
When Genly Ai's Gethenian friend inquires about the differences between men and
women on Earth, Genly replies, "It's extremely hard to separate the innate
differences from the learned ones. Even where women participate equally with
men in the society, they still do all of the child-bearing, and so most of the
child-rearing...." After contemplating the minimal differences between men and
women and their distinct societal roles, he concludes, "In a sense, women are
more alien to me than you are. With you I share one sex, anyhow...." One of the
most debated concepts in this novel is the portrayal of a race on Gethen that
is free from the constraints of gender identity expectations. Their traits
evolve based on the environment and circumstances. This presents a challenge
for Genly Ai, who was raised on Earth, in effectively fulfilling his role as an
envoy, as he struggles to understand their thoughts. He is accustomed to
viewing human identity in binary terms, categorizing people as either similar
or different from him, which leads to some unusual and incorrect assumptions
about his hosts. For instance, he perceives their historical lack of war as a
flaw rather than a strength: "They lacked, it seemed, the capacity to mobilize.
They behaved like animals, in that respect; or like women. They did not behave
like men, or ants." Genly's inability to perceive them accurately results in
disappointment early in the story when Estraven does not act as assertively
with the king on his behalf as Genly expects. Although Gethenians develop
sexual identities every twenty-six days, and pregnancy can assign a maternal
role during gestation and nursing, they are not truly asexual; they are
ambisexual. Instead of having no gender, they experience both. Due to the
limitations of the English language, it is challenging for readers to fully
grasp this concept of sexlessness, as characters are consistently referred to
as "he" in the narrative.
Politics
As an outsider, Genly Ai is unfamiliar with the cultural norms in Karhide and Orgoreyn....
(This entire section contains 899 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
However, as a diplomat, he must navigate the upper echelons of government, exposing him to the concentrated ideologies of each culture. In Karhide, a monarchy, citizens are more straightforward in expressing their thoughts. The Karhide government permits Ai to live openly as an extraterrestrial and even announces his arrival on the radio. Although Ai perceives Estraven, the Karhidian Prime Minister, as somewhat secretive, it is later revealed that Estraven's actions stem from courtesy rather than self-interest. In a nation so heavily influenced by one individual's will, complex political schemes offer little benefit. Conversely, in Orgoreyn, deceit is advantageous due to the presence of thirty-three Commensals, making the power dynamics volatile. The Orgota display friendliness toward Ai, which is a necessity in their environment, where Commensals are in perpetual conflict with one another. When a group opposing Ai gains control, he is not exiled publicly like Estraven in Karhide; instead, he is abducted at night, and the public is falsely informed of his death.
Survival in Nature
The latter half of the book details Ai and Estraven's journey across the ice to
find safety in a land they both fled under threat. It is through their shared
struggle against the harsh environment that they truly come to understand each
other, recognizing strengths and weaknesses that lead to insights about each
other's culture. Isolated in their tent at night, they exchange stories and
opinions they never had the opportunity to share in society. This intimacy
extends to the mind-speaking technique Ai teaches, which produces unexpected
effects: Estraven perceives Ai's voice as identical to his brother's, while Ai
hears Estraven's voice as his own. Depending on each other for survival, they
forge a connection unlike any that could be formed while adhering to social
roles and trying to decipher the other's intentions.
Themes
Last Updated October 6, 2024.
Beyond the central theme of androgyny, Le Guin explores significant topics such as war, politics, and religion, alongside more intimate themes like love, friendship, and integrity. One of the most notable aspects of life on Gethen is the complete absence of war. Their languages lack even a word for it. As war, seen as the ultimate form of aggression, is compared to rape, its absence is partly due to the fact that men and women are not distinct entities. This absence of war also influences political dynamics. Political interactions on Gethen are governed by a sophisticated code known as "shifgrethor," which relies on the nuances of language and gesture. This complex code serves as a replacement for open aggression.
Gethen is home to two major religions, which are opposites in their beliefs and rituals. One is mystical and inspired, while the other is rational and philosophical. The contrast between them is depicted through imagery of light and darkness, including an explanation of the title, derived from a line of poetry, "Light is the left hand of darkness."
On a personal level, the themes of love and friendship are explored through the relationship between the protagonist-narrator and a Gethenian politician. Their relationship evolves from initial antagonism, due to the Gethenian's seemingly feminine mannerisms, to a friendship built on trust. Eventually, after enduring the hardships of an epic journey across a glacier, it develops into a profound but non-sexual love. The impact of gender on relationships with others and on one's own sense of integrity is addressed with sensitivity.