Law and Politics

Start Free Trial

Compare Freud's explanation of criminality with other past and current psychological theories of criminality, and assess whether or not Freud's theories fit the current thinking on causes of criminal behavior.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This is a very complex question, and I can provide only a brief overview on eNotes. Freud's theory of criminality was based, in brief, on the subconscious processing of sexual instincts and how well or poorly a child was able to process instinctual needs for attachment to and defense against the competition of parents. Comparing this to another classic psychological theory of criminality, it was shown in Bandura's behaviorist Bobo doll studies that children learn through modeling and not just through direct rewards and punishments, therefore, social modeling is a determinant in developing criminality. Each of these has flaws, the most obvious flaw being that not all individuals with flawed parental relations or who grow up in high crime areas become criminals.

A current theory of crime is personality and/or intelligence theory that finds a strong connection between persistent criminal behavior and (1) innate personality characteristics that may or may not have been marked by disadvantageous early childhood experiences and (2) intelligence levels with low intelligence, particularly a significantly low Verbal Intelligence score that is also significantly lower than the Performance Intelligence score. While Intelligence Quotient (IQ) test were driven out of favor by sociologists, recent studies have found no confirmation of social, ethnic, racial, or economic bias in IQ tests. Intelligence theory of criminality finds a strong connection between low intelligence and criminality but also between other social failures like teen pregnancy in young women and unemployment in men and women.

Freud's theory of criminality has some carry-over and positive relation with current personality theories of criminality though there is negative relationship with current intelligence theories of criminology.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Research Freud and prepare an outline on his contributions to the explanation of criminality. Compare his explanation with other past and current psychological theories of criminality, and assess whether or not Freud's theories fit the current thinking on causes of criminal behavior. 

The great psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud held that one's childhood played a tremendously significant role in the formation of the adult. In terms of criminal behavior, Freud contended that 

  • Criminal behavior can be traced back to deep-rooted problems in childhood. If parents are neglectful, the superego does not develop and the id will dominate and demand satisfaction, often immediate gratification, of urges.
  • Behavior and unconscious motives are often connected, and their interaction can produce criminal behavior. Often, traumas and abuse, especially by mothers, are the foundation of sexual crimes against women.
  • Deep-rooted problems in childhood produce psychoses in adulthood. Criminal behavior is essentially a manifestation of psychological conflict.

Modern psychologists, psychiatrists, and criminologists still hold that negative childhood experience plays a crucial role in criminal behavior. In addition, they contend that inadequate or improper socialization also plays a significant role in criminality as socialization determines cognitive development. This concept is beyond Freudian theory as it identifies Social Learning Theory, and Cognitive Theory, as well as discoveries in science. The Social Learning Theory holds that an individual learns a behavior when it is reinforced and in not learned if there is no reinforcement. Within this theory is the concept of "Differential Association" which holds that criminal behavior is learned as opposed to the cause/effect of Freudian theory:

  • Criminal behavior is acquired through interaction with other persons, especially within intimate groups
  • If a person learns that it is more favorable to violate the law in his environment, he will exhibit criminal behavior
  • This learning includes the adoption of motives, impulses, and attitudes toward criminality as well as the acquisition of techniques for committing crimes.--

--The "Cognitive Theory" also comes into play in the contemporary lexicon of criminality. That is, offenders of the law have failed to develop their moral judgment capacity beyond the "pre-conventional level." This is only stage one of three stages of Cognitive Development

  • Pre-Conventional Level- Children (9-11) will consider the short-term consequences of committing a crime. (i.e. "What happens if I get caught?")
  • Conventional Level - Adolescents consider the morality of an act against the law. ("It is wrong to steal, so I should not, no matter what the circumstances are.")
  • Post-Conventional Level - Adults 20 and over critically examine issues of custom and society and measure them according to their own perspective of human rights.

--The "Criminal Personality Theories" are those theories that hold with the development of criminality as a result of deep-seated personality disorders.

  • Low intelligence, impulsive tendencies, and insensitivity to others ["lack of empathy"] are identified as conditions of many offenders.
  • Hans Eysenck contends that criminal behavior may be the result of both conditioning and personality differences (i.e. neuroses and extroversion are found in many offenders). Some people resist proper social conditioning and develop antisocial behaviors, instead.

Further, scientific study of the brains of criminals, especially murderers, reveals that the broad area of the cortex is often larger than in the normal brain. Also, high testosterone levels and other biological and chemical imbalances can exist in those men who exhibit aggressive and violent behavior.

While Freud's theories yet work in criminology, there are other theories and developments which contribute, beyond the scope of the Freudian analysis.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on