Larry Kettelkamp Criticism
Larry Kettelkamp, an American nonfiction writer and illustrator, is known for his diverse works aimed at young adults, drawing from his personal interests. A versatile musician, Kettelkamp has authored introductory texts on musical instruments, such as Flutes, Whistles, and Reeds, and engaged in hobbies like magic and craft, resulting in books like Magic Made Easy and Kites. His most significant contributions lie in exploring the paranormal, with subjects ranging from haunted houses to hypnosis, as seen in titles like Sixth Sense and Investigating Psychics. Despite his scientific approach, which involves presenting research studies, Kettelkamp's works have been critiqued for a lack of objectivity, often reflecting his beliefs in reincarnation and ESP. As noted by critics like Marjorie Halderman, his works, such as Spooky Magic, effectively engage young audiences. However, as Olive Mumford observes, titles like Singing Strings sometimes suffer from overlapping objectives. His books often tread the line between informative content and personal conviction, a balance critiqued by Philip and Phylis Morrison and Zena Sutherland. Kettelkamp's previous roles as a teacher and art director enrich his illustrated publications, which include collaborations with authors like Herbert S. Zim.
Contents
-
Marjorie Halderman
(summary)
In the following essay, Marjorie Halderman praises Larry Kettelkamp's Spooky Magic for providing young magicians with simple yet effective tricks that require no expensive props, highlighting Kettelkamp's ability to clearly convey instructions that enable children to entertain their audiences.
-
Olive Mumford
(summary)
In the following essay, Olive Mumford critiques Larry Kettelkamp's Singing Strings for its attempt to cover the history, science, and construction of stringed instruments, noting that its overlapping objectives lead to a lack of clarity and an inadequate glossary for young readers.
-
Virginia Haviland
(summary)
In the following essay, Virginia Haviland praises Larry Kettelkamp's works "Drums, Rattles, and Bells" and "Song, Speech, and Ventriloquism" for their engaging and informative nature, highlighting their appeal to children and usefulness to librarians, parents, and voice teachers seeking accessible explanations of musical instruments and voice mechanics.
-
Philip and Phylis Morrison
(summary)
The critic discusses Larry Kettelkamp's works, highlighting Song, Speech, and Ventriloquism as a practical guide to mastering ventriloquism, and critiques Dreams for its oversimplified treatment of dream symbolism, especially its avoidance of sexual themes, which limits its depth and potential audience.
-
Zena Sutherland
(summary)
In the following essay, Zena Sutherland critiques Larry Kettelkamp's Dreams as a popular yet speculative exploration of the history and scientific study of dreams, suggesting it lacks scientific rigor but remains an engaging overview inclusive of parapsychological considerations and personal dream recording methods.
-
Jerome Beatty, Jr.
(summary)
In the following essay, Jerome Beatty, Jr. critiques Larry Kettelkamp's "Haunted Houses" for its lack of spookiness, favoring a scientific approach over emotional evocation, and also discusses "Dreams," noting the simplistic yet effective summarization of Freud and Jung's work, while questioning the value of its speculative interpretations.
-
Margaret A. Dorsey
(summary)
In the following essay, Margaret A. Dorsey critiques Larry Kettelkamp's Sixth Sense as a lucid and well-organized overview of psychic phenomena, though she notes it sometimes leans towards more speculative interpretations like reincarnation and survival after death, while still offering a balanced account of parapsychology.
-
Randolph Hogan
(summary)
In the following essay, Randolph Hogan critiques Larry Kettelkamp's "Sixth Sense" for its engaging discussion on psychic phenomena while noting its shortcomings in documentation and structure, suggesting the book could benefit from a more scientific approach and better integration of practical experiments for young readers.
-
Zena Sutherland
(summary)
In the following essay, Zena Sutherland critiques Larry Kettelkamp's works on psychic phenomena, UFOs, and comparative religion, highlighting a lack of balance in presenting evidence and a tendency towards sensationalism and anecdotal content, which may undermine the educational value of these texts.
-
Sister Mary Etheldreda Smeltzer
(summary)
In the following review, the critic highlights the clarity and informative nature of Larry Kettelkamp's Religions East and West, emphasizing its importance in the contemporary study of comparative religions and its appeal to young readers searching for truth.
-
Denise Murko Wilms
(summary)
In the following essay, Denise Murko Wilms critiques Larry Kettelkamp's works on astrology, hypnosis, and biofeedback, highlighting his broad historical surveys and realistic reports while pointing out the lack of critical examination and bibliography in his hypnosis introduction.
-
Herbert J. Stolz
(summary)
In the following essay, Herbert J. Stolz praises Larry Kettelkamp's Hypnosis: The Wakeful Sleep for its accurate and accessible discussion of hypnosis and its practical applications in fields like medicine and psychotherapy, highlighting its value as an introductory text for young readers.
-
Zena Sutherland
(summary)
In the following essay, Zena Sutherland commends Larry Kettelkamp's A Partnership of Mind and Body: Biofeedback for its authoritative examination of biofeedback, highlighting its scientific grounding, comprehensive coverage of research experiments, and potential applications in the medical field.
-
Sarah Gagné
(summary)
In the following essay, Sarah Gagné highlights the importance of Larry Kettelkamp's book A Partnership of Body and Mind: Biofeedback for its comprehensive exploration of biofeedback, particularly the role of brain waves in creativity and mental control, emphasizing the educational context over sensationalism.
-
Anne C. Rayme
(summary)
In the following essay, Anne C. Rayme discusses Larry Kettelkamp's book "Investigating Psychics: Five Life Histories," highlighting its objective exploration of psi research and its profiles of five psychics, while cautioning against laymen's attempts at psi feats.
-
E. Virginia Demos
(summary)
In the following essay, E. Virginia Demos criticizes Larry Kettelkamp's Investigating Psychics—Five Life Histories for its lack of investigative rigor and its biased portrayal of parapsychology, arguing that the book misleads readers with an uncritical acceptance of secondary sources and a tendency towards evangelizing rather than educating.
-
Montague Ullman
(summary)
In the following essay, Montague Ullman critiques Larry Kettelkamp's works, arguing that they present an unbalanced and overly simplistic view of parapsychology and holistic medicine, lacking rigorous evidence and promoting uncritical acceptance of claims without appropriate scientific backing.
-
Kathryn Weisman
(summary)
In the following essay, Kathryn Weisman evaluates Larry Kettelkamp's The Healing Arts as a comprehensive survey that objectively explains a wide range of healing methods, including both alternative and traditional Western medicine, while highlighting their scientific foundations.